Visit our mobile site

The Globe and Mail

Jump to main navigation
Jump to main content

News Search
Search Stock Quotes
Search The Web
Search People at canada411.ca
Search Businesses at yellowpages.ca
Search Jobs at eluta.ca

Tories plot new course for Ottawa and provinces

From Wednesday's Globe and Mail

The money is still at least a year away, but the federal government is giving some clear indications that it is steering the country in a radically different direction in order to deal with its perpetual fiscal tug-of-war with the provinces.

Yesterday's federal budget essentially defines the fiscal imbalance bugbear that has pitted government against government for most of Canada's history.

And it sets out five principles that will serve as a basis for Ottawa's proposals to deal with the provinces' complaints that the federal government has too much money and they have too little.

In setting out its framework for negotiations with the provinces, the federal government gives a taste of the federation of the future: a country in which Ottawa focuses on stripped-down roles in international affairs, defence and security, and cedes responsibility for health and social programs to the provinces.

"For this government, fiscal balance means that the federal government and the provincial governments have to be able to focus on their core responsibilities," Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said in his first federal budget speech.

"They have to have the resources they need to meet those responsibilities."

His principles include: a clarification of the responsibilities of each level of government; budget data that are more transparent; predictable, long-term funding; a competitive economic union; and collaborative management of the federation.

All in all, they add up to a foundation that aims to steer the country away from the Liberal past -- where federal spending often intruded on provincial responsibilities or came with strings attached -- toward a federal government that is more inclined to transfer fiscal capacity to the provinces and lets the provinces decide what to do with it.

While Ottawa's concrete proposals won't be brought forward until the fall, the declarations were enough to win the crucial support of the Bloc Québécois.

With the other opposition parties suggesting they will not vote in favour of the Conservatives' first budget, the Bloc's support is necessary to keep the Conservatives in office.

"The government's firm intention to attack and eliminate the fiscal imbalance is a major advance for Quebec, and that's why the Bloc Québécois will support this budget," Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe said. "We are obviously far from where we'd like to be," he added.

The budget does not set aside extra cash to deal with provincial demands that will no doubt total billions of dollars annually. (The budget does mention about $2-billion over two years that is not yet allocated to anything in particular).

The budget statements signal a radical change in direction for federal-provincial relations and for the role of the federal government, said expert Tom Courchene, an economist with Queen's University in Kingston.

"It's really a commitment to classical federalism," he said in an interview. "It's very respectful of the provinces."

A recent experts' report, commissioned by the provinces, recommended that Ottawa boost federal payments to the provinces by about $5-billion every year. Part of the money would enrich and overhaul the equalization formula that is meant to make sure all provinces can afford to provide their populations with the same high standards of social programs.

Another part would go toward helping every province pay for postsecondary education and training, including Alberta and Ontario.

Ontario, which is a major contributor to the equalization program despite a lacklustre economy, has already dismissed those proposals as insufficient. And Ottawa gave no indication yesterday that the provincial platform was something with which it could work.

Instead, Mr. Flaherty says he wants to wait to see what a federally sponsored panel of experts has to say on the subject later this year.