Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

The Summit: Stumbling through the retelling of a disaster Add to ...

  • Directed by Nick Ryan
  • Written by Mark Monroe
  • Starring Christine Barnes, Hoselito Bite, Marco Confortola
  • Classification PG
  • Year 2012
  • Country Ireland, U.K., Switzerland, USA
  • Language English

The Summit is a mixture of the inventive and the misguided in its attempt to recreate the circumstances of the August, 2008, disaster on the world’s second-highest mountain, K2, when 11 climbers were killed.

What happened that day, already the subject of three books, is not precisely known, in part because the survivors who lived to tell the stories suffered altitude sickness and freezing temperatures.

More Related to this Story

What viewers will get from Nick Ryan’s film (written by The Cove’s Mark Monroe) are some spectacular, hair-raising re-enactments of critical moments blended with archival footage. There are also heartfelt and moving interviews, especially with surviving climbers Cecilie Skog and Pemba Gyalje Sherpa.

But the film barely manages to make the sequence of events intelligible and, at times, needlessly compounds the complexity. Particularly puzzling is the filmmakers’ decision to include Italian adventurer Walter Bonatti’s account of a 1954 Italian team’s first successful summit as a parallel narrative of confusion and controversy, and to use a journalist (Concetto La Malfa) as a talking-head substitute for the recently deceased Bonatti.

Follow on Twitter: @liamlacey

In the know

Most popular videos »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular