Go to The Globe and Mail

 

Blogs

James on Soccer

Welcome to James on Soccer, a blog combining information, commentary and analysis on all things bright and beautiful from the world of soccer. Okay, so not all things will be quite so bright and cheery as the soccer world never seems to operate over a 24-hour period without some sort of debatable incident that requires some honest, candid opinion. Rather than pigeon hole myself to one specific area of football I will try to make my commentaries as broad as possible. I hope you enjoy reading what I have to say, and I look forward to reading what you have to say. Please feel free to send me your comments, good and/or bad.

Thursday, November 19, 2009 8:55 AM

Brilliant Irish deserved better

Paul James

After seeing Thierry Henry's get away with a blatant handball in last night's pivotal World Cup qualifier between France and Ireland it was difficult to not recall a similar incident back in 1977 when Wales played Scotland in their all important final qualifying game. Scottish striker Joe Jordan handles the ball in the Welsh penalty area but David Jones gets incorrectly penalized for the handball and a penalty is awarded. Scotland score and qualify for the World Cup in Argentina and Wales as a result are eliminated.

To think 32 years later a similar incident has transpired is an absolute absurdity. While Sepp Blatter and Michel Platini adhere to their notion that video technology cannot be a part of the modern game, it is a view that appears to be in stark contrast to what everyone else in the football world demands. As a neutral observer of last night's game it was both annoying and disheartening to see the game finish in such a way. While the Irish wrath from players, staff and supporters is completely justifiable, it really should be directed in one simple direction and that is to FIFA and its leader, Blatter. While the officials are noted as being responsible it has been clear over the years (through the improved technology of cameras et al) that it is now too easy for them to be blinded to crucial incidents and therefore human error in the electric pace of the modern football game is an absolute certainty. Blaming Henry also has limitations. While his explanation - players do their job and referees do theirs - was a little nauseating it at the same time resonated some truth.

As for the game itself the Irish can consider themselves extremely unlucky.

Having scored the only "legitimate goal" they also missed three clear-cut chances to increase their lead had they been a little sharper in the final third.

Trapattoni, who has proven to be a leader sumpreme since taking over the Ireland team, should be credited with the fact they came so close in the first place. No losses in the group stage was an accomplishmnent in itself but the preparation and tactics towards the playoff games against the French was even better. Then in his final statements when addressing the controversial French goal he suggests that the referee should have asked Henry if he did in fact handle the ball - in the spirit of fair play of course! A brilliant performance from the Irish cultivated from a brilliant brain!

Latest Comments

James on Soccer Contributors

 

Paul James

James on Soccer blogger Paul James, who has an MBA in Football Industries from the University of Liverpool in England, has been involved in Canadian soccer as a player, television analyst and coach, including the last five games as the head coach of the York University women's team.

James's credentials are:

The Player

* Represented Canada 47 times at the senior level

* Competed in all of Canada's games at the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics and 1986 FIFA World Cup Finals in Mexico

* Played professionally for the Toronto Blizzard, Hamilton Steelers, Ottawa Intrepid, London Lasers and Doncaster Rovers

* Four time selection as a first-team CSL (Canadian Soccer League) All Star

The Coach

* Has coached at all significant levels of the game including professional, collegiate (both NCAA and CIS) and international levels

* Has garnered six Coach of the Year awards at varying levels - CSL, NCAA (twice), and CIS (three times) including the 2007 National Coach of the Year

* Coached Canadian U20 men's team to CONCACAF Group title win in 2001

* Was assistant coach for the National U20 women's team which won the 2008 CONCACAF championship

* From 2003 has lead the York University women's team to four division titles, two OUA provincial championships, and three national championship appearances including a second-place finish at the 2007 CIS championships tournament

* Oversaw the men's soccer program at York which has garnered a provincial and national championship in addition to two consecutive division titles

* Has attained an A licence certification as a coach in both Canada and the United States

TV Soccer Analyst

* Worked for for years as a soccer analyst on The Score network which included - the weekly Soccer Friday Show; regular midweek updates, and Sunday Premier League game broadcasts

* Worked for three years on GOL TV, providing analysis; color commentary; and instructional tips

* Over the past eight years, have worked as an analyst on Sportsnet, CBC and CTC

Writer

* Have had articles/editorials published by the Canadian Press, GOL TV website, Soccer Magazine 360, and The Score website.