Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

Ian Hunter

Here today, a museum exhibit tomorrow? Add to ...

Charles Moore wrote a column not long ago in Britain's Daily Telegraph so politically incorrect as to take my breath away.

The former editor of the newspaper was reflecting on the opening of a museum exhibition that documented the history of slavery; in his column he wondered if the day might come when a similar exhibition would open dealing with abortion. He imagined it depicting how "... in one ward, staff were trying to save the lives of premature babies while, in the next ward, they were killing them."

More Related to this Story

The exhibition, he thought, might "... display the various instruments that were used to remove and kill the fetus, rather as the manacles and collars of slaves can be seen today." He ended his column by saying: "With the passage of time, abortion, especially late term abortion, is slowly coming to be seen as a 'solution' dating from an era that is passing. It will therefore be discredited."

It is doubtful that Mr. Moore's column could have been published in Canada. What Canadian newspaper would want to join Mark Steyn and Maclean's magazine in the dock before a human rights kangaroo court for publishing something that might ruffle the delicate sensibilities of an Osgoode Hall student? No, no ... not in Canada.

But what about Mr. Moore's crystal ball and his museum exhibition on abortion, could that happen?

Until recently, I would have said no.

Through most of my decades as an active member of the pro-life movement, I was pessimistic about the prospect of making any real difference: The Canadian pro-life story is one of unbroken parliamentary and judicial defeats.

Recently, however, and rather to my surprise, I have become more hopeful. Although not yet ready to join Charles Moore in predicting that abortion will some day acquire the odium of slavery, there are three reasons, looking ahead, for at least modest optimism.

First, thanks to ultrasound, sonography, and similar medical advances in fetal imaging and treatment, no rational person any longer denies the humanity of the unborn.

In the early days, abortion advocates used to say that a fetus was just a blob of tissue, so abortion had no greater moral significance than, say, an appendectomy. Medical advances mean that those days, and those arguments, are gone forever.

Second, recent studies suggest that the younger generation (those under 30) are more opposed to abortion than their parents were. At least in the United States, where anti-consensus thinking is not yet either a crime or a human rights violation, young women in particular seem to be more strongly pro-life than one could have hoped. Just why this is so is the subject for another column, but it is the reality, not the reasons, that is most intriguing.

In fact, after rising for decades, the number of abortions performed annually in the U.S. has actually begun to decline. In 2003, the U.S. Congress passed the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act. And on April 18, 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld its validity in Gonzales v. Carhart, a decision that might be the first step in a gradual retreat from the infamous Roe v. Wade decision in 1973. All of these developments give grounds for hope.

Third, history suggests that systems constructed entirely upon lies cannot stand; one observes how the pro-abortion state must contort itself into ever more bizarre and despotic ways in order to sustain the abortion-related lies.

I retain a perhaps naive belief that at some moment, and without much forewarning, the whole edifice of abortion, like the Berlin Wall, will crumble and collapse before our eyes.

A museum exhibit - certainly not in my lifetime. But greater respect, and perhaps at least some minimal legal protection for the weakest, most vulnerable members of our society, the unborn - yes, a distinct possibility.

Follow us on Twitter: @GlobeDebate

 

In the know

Most popular video »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories