Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

Toronto's bike-share program: Who should pay? Add to ...

Globe contributor Ivor Tossell and Candice Malcolm of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation square off on the issue.

Bike-share programs have been struggling to get off of the ground in several Canadian cities. On Wednesday, Toronto said it would take over its Bixi program in the spring and hopes to find private sponsors to pay for it. Globe contributor Ivor Tossell and Candice Malcolm of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation face off on the issue.

The program must grow to be successful

Yes, it’s a money loser, but Torontonians are all suffering from the fact that city is gridlocked. If we can spend billions of dollars on subway extensions of varying merit, then we can afford a few million dollars to give people an option they can use right now.
Read more +

Put the brakes on bike-sharing subsidies and bailouts

Taxpayers should not be responsible for saving poorly run and mismanaged ventures. Toronto city councillors seem exempt from the laws that govern the rest of the world. 

In the real world, if a company were unable to pay down its debt, the bank would not volunteer to give it more money. Unfortunately, Toronto's City Council seems exempt from the laws that govern the rest of the world.

City bureaucrats now want taxpayers to bailout Bixi, at an unknown cost. Montreal taxpayers have already bailout its parent company, PBSC, to the tune of $108-million.

While Bixi is a privately owned company, its financial statements are not available to the public. We do know that it was given a $4.5-million loan in 2011, but taxpayers were assured the city was merely guaranteeing this loan for capital costs and it would be repaid within 10 years. Leaked reports however show that the company has lost nearly $400,000 in its first two years, has failed to reach its sponsorship targets, and still owes over $3.7-million from its initial loan.


Taxpayers should not be responsible for bailing out poorly run and mismanaged ventures. On behalf of taxpayers who would rather see our money go to comprehensive transit strategies, the CTF says let Bixi fail.

Candice Malcolm is Ontario director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation

Read more +

Now have your say

Who do you agree with?

Please log in to save your answer

Share your thoughts
Visit the comment pages or share your thoughts on Facebook or Twitter.