One of the toughest jobs as an investor is telling the difference between hot stocks of the moment and solid long-term investments.
Often, the two are completely different. Shares of Metro Inc., a grocery giant in Quebec and Ontario, were off 3.4 per cent for the year to midweek, while the S&P/TSX composite index gained 20.7 per cent. But as a wealth creator for shareholders, Metro is one of the top stocks in the index.
Rogers Communications Inc. has dropped about 10 per cent this year, and yet it’s also a strong wealth creator. CGI Group Inc. was up a modest 5 per cent this year, while BlackBerry Ltd. was up 29.4 per cent. Guess which is the better wealth creator?
Let’s define wealth creation – as used here, it refers to a kind of analysis called economic value added, or EVA. “The simplest way of looking at EVA is to think of whether the company is generating wealth for shareholders over the long run,” said Michael Cloherty of Montreal-based Inovestor, a provider of financial data software. Among Inovestor’s services is StockPointer, an online tool that uses EVA to rate Canadian and U.S. stocks.
EVA starts with a company’s cost of capital, which means the interest paid on debt such as bonds plus the cost of a company’s equity. StockPointer defines the cost of equity as being as the rate of return expected by investors from stocks of comparable risk.
Cost of capital is compared with a company’s return on capital, a measure of profitability. If return on capital exceeds the cost of capital, then a company is generating wealth for shareholders. EVA measures the extent of this. “The higher the EVA, the more value the company is able to generate for investors,” Mr. Cloherty said.
The need for some perspective on stocks as wealth creators is especially important after a massive five-year stock market rally. Investors need to know whether stocks are benefiting mainly from temporary factors and market momentum, or whether they truly generate value for shareholders.
StockPointer charges $35 a month for a basic subscription to its online service, but agreed to provide several different screens for this column using a score out of 100 that is based on factors related to a stock’s performance and risk profile. Performance incorporates EVA and other factors, while risk looks at things like business model variability, variations in share price and debt levels. StockPointer scores are expressed as a percentage, which means 100 is the ideal. Mr. Cloherty said the best scores these days are in the 80 range.
The most effective way to interpret StockPointer scores is by comparing them to companies in the same industrial sector. For example, there are 10 companies in the S&P/TSX capped consumer staples index. The best wealth creators in this group as judged by StockPointer are Metro, Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. and Jean Coutu Group Inc. In the financials index, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, Intact Financial Corp., National Bank of Canada and Royal Bank of Canada are joint leaders.
Largely absent from the list of top-15 stocks in the composite index by StockPointer score are energy and mining stocks. Mr. Cloherty said companies in these sectors tend to have higher operating costs and lower profit margins, and thus don’t typically have high EVA scores. Still, EVA can be used to find best-of-sector commodity stocks.
As of midweek, the top two energy stocks as ranked by StockPointer score were ShawCor Ltd. at 72 and Imperial Oil Ltd. at 63. The top-rated stocks in the materials sector were Labrador Iron Ore Royalty Corp. at 69, and West Fraser Timber Co. at 64.
StockPointer scores can help investors uncover strong wealth creators that are out of favour and thus possibly not trading at the same elevated levels as other stocks. It can also help provide a reality check on high-flying stocks.
Consider Apple Inc. and Intel Corp. – they’re both up sharply in the past year and get very strong marks from StockPointer. The best-performing stock in the S&P/TSX composite index over the past 12 months had been Air Canada, which gets a middling score from StockPointer. In fact, almost none of the past year’s top-10 best performers in the composite index get a high score.
Editor's note: StockPointer charges $35 a month for a basic subscription to its online service, not $35 a year as originally published.
Finding the wealth creators
StockPointer is an online tool that analyzes stocks using a measure called economic value added, or EVA, which is designed to uncover the companies that are best at wealth creation. The firm’s analysis is incorporated into a StockPointer Score expressed as a percentage (100 per cent is a perfect score). Here are eight screens of Canadian and U.S. stocks provided by StockPointer. Share price data is to Aug. 13.
1. Top 15 stocks in the S&P/TSX composite index by StockPointer score:
|Alim. Couche-Tard Inc.||ATD.B-T||75%|
|Constellation Software Inc.||CSU-T||74%|
|CGI Group Inc.||GIB.A-T||73%|
|Jean Coutu Group||PJC.A-T||72%|
|Power Financial Corp.||PWF-T||72%|
|Intact Financial Corp.||IFC-T||71%|
|National Bank of Cda||NA-T||71%|
|Royal Bank of Cda||RY-T||71%|
|Tim Hortons Inc.||THI-T||70%|
2. Top 15 stocks in the S&P 500 index by StockPointer score:
|Wal-Mart Stores Inc.||WMT-N||75%|
|Discover Financial Svcs.||DFS-N||74%|
|Philip Morris Int'l||PM-N||74%|
|CF Industries Holdings Inc.||CF-N||73%|
|Ross Stores Inc.||ROST-Q||73%|
|Exxon Mobil Corp.||XOM-N||73%|
|UnitedHealth Group Inc.||UNH-N||73%|
3. Bottom 15 stocks in the S&P/TSX composite index by StockPointer score:
|Torex Gold Resources Inc.||TXG-T||12%|
|Barrick Gold Corp.||ABX-T||16%|
|Turquoise Hill Resources Ltd.||TRQ-T||18%|
|Aurico Gold Inc.||AUQ-T||19%|
|Primero Mining Corp.||P-T||21%|
|Pengrowth Energy Corp.||PGF-T||21%|
|NovaGold Resources Ltd.||NG-T||21%|
|Westport Innovations Inc.||WPT-T||22%|
|Argonaut Gold Inc.||AR-T||23%|
|HudBay Minerals Inc.||HBM-T||24%|
|Penn West Petroleum Ltd.||PWT-T||24%|
|RMP Energy Inc.||RMP-T||24%|
|Crew Energy Inc.||CR-T||24%|
|NuVista Energy Ltd.||NVA-T||24%|
4. Bottom 15 stocks in the S&P 500 index by StockPointer score:
|Vertex Pharma. Inc.||VRTX-Q||18%|
|QEP Resources Inc.||QEP-N||25%|
|E*Trade Financial Corp.||ETFC-Q||27%|
|Boston Scientific Corp.||BSX-N||28%|
|Allegheny Tech. Inc.||ATI-N||28%|
|Genworth Financial Inc.||GNW-N||29%|
|Leucadia National Corp.||LUK-N||29%|
|Hudson City Bancorp Inc.||HCBK-Q||30%|
|NRG Energy Inc.||NRG-N||30%|
|Range Resources Corp.||RRC-N||31%|
|Plum Creek Timber Co. Inc.||PCL-N||31%|
|Kimco Realty Corp.||KIM-N||31%|
|Peabody Energy Corp.||BTU-N||31%|
5. Highest-yielding stocks in the S&P/TSX composite index with StockPointer:
|Just Energy Group Inc.||JE-T||9.44%||57%|
|AGF Mgmt. Ltd.||AGF.B-T||8.40%||43%|
|Dream Office REIT||D.UN-T||7.65%||62%|
|Penn West Petroleum Ltd.||PWT-T||7.47%||24%|
|Crescent Point Energy Corp.||CPG-T||6.84%||26%|
|Bell Aliant Inc.||BA-T||6.81%||52%|
|Bonterra Energy Corp.||BNE-T||6.35%||44%|
6. Highest-yielding stocks in the S&P 500 index with StockPointer score:
|Windstream Holdings Inc.||WIN-Q||10.04%||61%|
|Diamond Offshore Drilling||DO-N||7.05%||43%|
|CME Group Inc.||CME-Q||6.26%||50%|
|Health Care REIT||HCN-N||4.98%||41%|
|Teco Energy Inc.||TE-N||4.76%||46%|
|Altria Group Inc.||MO-N||4.58%||69%|
7. Top performers of the past 12 months on the S&P/TSX composite index with StockPointer score:
|Company||Ticker||1-yr chg||SP Score|
|Bankers Petroleum Ltd.||BNK-T||112%||46%|
|Secure Energy Services||SES-T||99%||39%|
|RMP Energy Inc.||RMP-T||80%||24%|
|Canaccord Genuity Group Inc.||CF-T||80%||43%|
|Canadian Energy Svcs & Tech.||CEU-T||77%||46%|
8. Top performers of the past 12 months on the S&P 500 index with StockPointer score:
|Company||Ticker||1-yr chg||SP Score|
|Delta Air Lines Inc.||DAL-N||96%||52%|
|United States Steel Corp||X-N||90%||37%|
Follow Rob Carrick on Twitter:
- Metro Inc$43.44-0.02(-0.05%)
- Rogers Communications Inc$56.03-0.04(-0.06%)
- Rogers Communications Inc$57.66+0.91(+1.60%)
- Rogers Communications Inc$42.61-0.19(-0.44%)
- CGI Group Inc$62.79-0.43(-0.68%)
- CGI Group Inc$47.78-0.53(-1.10%)
- BlackBerry Ltd$10.50-0.39(-3.58%)
- BlackBerry Ltd$7.99-0.35(-4.14%)
- Alimentation Couche Tard Inc$63.30-0.36(-0.57%)
- Alimentation Couche Tard Inc$63.65-0.34(-0.53%)
- Jean Coutu Group PJC Inc$20.29+0.42(+2.11%)
- Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce$101.15-0.13(-0.13%)
- Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce$76.96-0.28(-0.36%)
- Intact Financial Corp$95.25-0.26(-0.27%)
- National Bank of Canada$46.65-0.05(-0.11%)
- Royal Bank of Canada$81.29-0.17(-0.21%)
- Royal Bank of Canada$61.86-0.30(-0.48%)
- Shawcor Ltd$32.19-0.14(-0.43%)
- Imperial Oil Ltd$41.74+1.20(+2.96%)
- Imperial Oil Ltd$31.75+0.75(+2.42%)
- Labrador Iron Ore Royalty Corp$13.86+0.33(+2.44%)
- West Fraser Timber Co Ltd$40.00-0.19(-0.47%)
- Apple Inc$112.59-1.36(-1.19%)
- Intel Corp$37.440.00(0.00%)
- Updated September 29 1:39 PM EDT. Delayed by at least 15 minutes.