Press release from PR Newswire
JANA Partners Urges Agrium Shareholders: Make Your Vote Count, Vote "Blue" To Unlock Value Before April 5th Deadline
Wednesday, April 03, 2013
JANA Partners Urges Agrium Shareholders: Make Your Vote Count, Vote "Blue" To Unlock Value Before April 5th Deadline09:51 EDT Wednesday, April 03, 2013
Urges Shareholders to Reject Agrium's Vote Buying Plan
Nominee Biographies and More Information Available at www.JanaAGUAnalysis.com
NEW YORK, April 3, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- JANA Partners LLC today urged shareholders of Agrium (TSX / NYSE: AGU) to vote their BLUE proxies or VIF "FOR" value-unlocking change by 7:00am Calgary time / 9:00am Eastern time on Friday, April 5 in order to ensure that their votes are counted.
Strong Support for JANA: "We want to thank the many Agrium shareholders who have expressed their support and already voted for the independent nominees we have put forth," said Barry Rosenstein, JANA's Managing Partner and a board nominee. "We look forward to bringing relevant experience and an enhanced shareholder mindset to the board, which will unlock long-term value for all shareholders."
Last week, North America's leading proxy advisory firm, ISS, concluded that there is a "compelling" case for change at Agrium and advised shareholders to vote on JANA's BLUE proxy. ISS noted that "While the board has begun implementing a number of [JANA's] proposals to drive shareholder value . . . its simultaneous, emphatic rejection of [JANA's] calls for these same initiatives, and its attempts to paper over other issues, raise significant concerns about its commitment."
JANA believes enhancing a minority of the board by adding its nominees, whom Bank of America has called "highly credible" and whom CIBC said "could help unlock value", can address these concerns for the benefit of every Agrium shareholder.
Agrium's Vote Buying Efforts: JANA also emphasized the importance of every shareholder vote in light of Agrium's unethical and undisclosed plan to use shareholder money to pay brokers and financial advisers to cause their clients to vote for Agrium's board, paying 25 cents for each vote. This strategy has been uniformly condemned and just today The Globe & Mail said it "should be banned" in Canada, and JANA believes it is questionable whether it is truly even permissible now.
While Agrium has issued no response since its plans were uncovered, last night it dispatched a legal representative to Canada's BNN to defend the practice, who offered only this justification: "79% of our shareholders are not accessible through normal means" and "this is the only way to get to them". This statement is patently false and demonstrates a high level of disdain for shareholder intelligence. The large majority of Agrium's shareholders are institutional investors (like JANA) and the company knows who they are and has met with or directly contacted most of them. The remaining individual shareholders are not likely to have missed Agrium's numerous press releases, presentations and mass mailings (which do reach most shareholders through a shareholder services company). In any case, Agrium is not paying to inform shareholders, it is only paying for votes for the current board.
Even before this revelation, ISS pointed to the board's "questionable actions which raise questions about its credibility", underscoring the need for new voices and greater shareholder representation on the board. For any shareholders considering the recommendations of ISS or any smaller proxy advisory firm, we encourage them to consider that such recommendations were made before the discovery of Agrium's undisclosed vote buying plan, which indicates a clear need for a stronger shareholder voice on its board.
JANA also urged shareholders to reject Agrium's disingenuous attempt to confuse them about JANA's proxy or the ISS recommendation, noting that both could not be clearer or easier to follow.
VOTE ONLY THE BLUE PROXY OR VIF "FOR" UNLOCKING AGRIUM'S TRUE VALUE
Your vote is important, no matter how many shares you own. If you have not yet voted your BLUE proxy or VIF, please do so today FOR the election of the JANA nominees. Even if you have already voted using the white proxy, you can change your vote by submitting a BLUE proxy or VIF now, which will revoke any previously submitted proxy or VIF and be counted at the Meeting.
For questions or assistance, please contact Kingsdale Shareholder Services Inc., at 1-866-581-1514 toll-free in North America, or 1-416-867-2272 outside of North America, or by email at email@example.com. To keep current with further developments and information about voting your Shares, visit www.JanaAGUAnalysis.com.
SOURCE Jana Partners LLC
For further information: JANA Partners LLC at (212) 455 0900