Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

If jumping into Toronto’s housing market now, you’d be wise to consider staying put for the long term. (Brett Gundlock/ Boreal Collectiv For The Globe and Mail)
If jumping into Toronto’s housing market now, you’d be wise to consider staying put for the long term. (Brett Gundlock/ Boreal Collectiv For The Globe and Mail)

Suburbs vs. city: Which is cheaper? Add to ...

There’s no refuge in the suburbs from Canada’s housing affordability problem.

You can buy a home for less money in the suburbs than you can in a big city, but the cost of commuting may kill almost all your savings. Some number-crunching by a public-spirited mortgage broker David Hughes in the Toronto area makes this point quite clearly.

Mr. Hughes uses some contentious assumptions, but his spreadsheet is a great conversation starter and a must-read for home buyers who are searching for affordability in the suburbs.

Read the full story.

Living in the suburbs

Home purchase price$500,000
Downpayment$50,000
Mortgage principal (includes 2% CMHC fee)$459,000
Auto costs annually$19,000
25 years of automobile costs$475,000
Monthly mortgage payment 25 years at 3.5%$2,291
Monthly automobile expenditures$1,583
Mortgage plus automobiles, monthly$3,874
Post-mortgage car costs: 15 years of 1 car$142,500
Total paid for home (interest and principal)$687,495
Total paid for cars$687,495
Total paid to live and get around for 40 years$1,304,995

Living in the city

Home purchase price$720,000
Downpayment$50,000
Mortgage principal (includes 2% CMHC fee)$688,425
Auto costs annually$6,000
25 years of automobile costs$150,000
Monthly mortgage payment 25 years at 3.5%$3,437
Monthly automobile expenditures$500
Mortgage plus automobiles, monthly$3,937
Post-mortgage car costs: 15 years of 1 car$90,000
Total paid for home (interest and principal)$1,031,130
Total paid for cars$240,000
Total paid to live and get around for 40 years$1,271,130

Assumptions

  • Car costs estimated at $9,500 per year for a compact car using CAA numbers times two vehicles
  • Downtown transportation costs pegged at $235.50 for 2 adult transit passes per month plus discretionary transit spending of $264.50 per month
  • Mortgage is paid over 25 years at a constant rate of 3.5 per cent

SOURCE: DAVID HUGHES
GRAPHIC BY STUART A. THOMPSON AND JOHN SOPINSKI

Follow on Twitter: @rcarrick

In the know

Most popular video »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories