The bake-off for brownie points

The city's independent food stores have become unintentional combatants in a battle of local bite-sized brownies, taking a run at the supermarket two-bite treats. On one side is caterer Toben Kochman (Susur Lee's right-hand man from 2002 to 2005), who has developed Best Bite Brownies with the help of his sister Elana. On the other side is nutritionist and personal chef Tara Ott, creator of Brownie Bits. Some Globe and Mail guinea pigs had a go at them and offered their feedback. As Amy Verner discovered, by the end of the day, only crumbs remained

Amy Verner

AMY VERNER

Company tagline:

Brownie Bits (BBs): Food for conscious living

Best Bite Brownies (BBBs): The art of eating happy and healthy

What this means: Brownies are an alternative to prescription medication.

Brownie points of interest: Quantity/Size/Weight/Price

BB: Approximately 10; 18 cm{+3}; 141 g per bag; $4.99 to $5.99

BBB: Between 18 and 22; 18 cm{+3}; 360 g per bag; $8.99 to $10.99 (the four-pack costs $1.99 to $2.99)

What this means: The BBBs are denser morsels, weighing in at 20 g each to BBs' 14 g. Denser equals more indulgent.

Basic ingredients:

BB: Certified organic spelt flour, fair trade chocolate chips, organic cane sugar, Rowe Farm eggs, Ontario butter, sea salt and non-alum baking powder

BBB: Semi-sweet chocolate chips, sugar, flour, eggs, butter, vanilla.

What this means: With chocolate as the first ingredient and no leavening agent, the BBBs are a cousin to fancy restaurant molten desserts; the flour-based BB has a more discernible crumble.

One bite or two?

BB: The plump square shape lends itself to a one-pop mouthful.

BBB: Although technically the same volume, this crackle-topped rectangle can be nibbled and stretched out.

What this means: Mindless eaters are likely to eat more BBs.

Nutritious? Really?

BB: People sensitive to gluten may find spelt flour easier to digest.

BBB: Calories per brownie (between 84 and 90) are listed on the front label. On the back is a complete nutritional breakdown.

What this means: Some people would prefer to nosh without a niggling number in their face. "It's too many calories for such a small thing," one sampler griped. Spelt has a polarizing effect, pleasing new-wave carb cravers while turning off purists.

Ranking the flavours

BB: Espresso, mint, chipotle

BBB: Classic, peanut butter, raspberry, mint

What this means: Classic is always king; even the chocolate chunks in the BBB put off those who prefer a consistently baked texture.

Sound Bites

BB: The coffee chocolate combination proved a resounding success, although one taster declared that it had a "burnt" aftertaste. A self-described brownie expert had to spit out the chipotle flavour. "It tastes like poorly seasoned dirt," she said.

BBB: Thanks to raspberry puree, the swirl-topped brownie was the sleeper hit. "The flavours complement each other rather than being like a back-alley fist fight," said one enthusiastic eater. As for the peanut butter: "It's not too sweet and it tastes natural."

What this means: Everyone happily agreed that both these brownies out-flavoured the commercial versions.

BB: Available at the Big Carrot, Fresh & Wild and the Sweet Potato plus three other locations. http://www.feedyourbody.ca.

BBB: Available at Pusateri's, Nortown Food and Harvest Wagon plus five other locations. http://www.tobenfoodbydesign.com.

Join the Discussion:

Sorted by: Oldest first
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Oldest to Newest

Latest Comments

Sponsored Links