Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

British Columbia teachers protest for better student learning conditions outside the cabinet offices in Vancouver, March 18, 2013. The opposition New Democrats said Feb. 12, 2014 that court documents show the Liberal government was intent on provoking teachers into job action, rather than bargaining in good faith. (ANDY CLARK/REUTERS)
British Columbia teachers protest for better student learning conditions outside the cabinet offices in Vancouver, March 18, 2013. The opposition New Democrats said Feb. 12, 2014 that court documents show the Liberal government was intent on provoking teachers into job action, rather than bargaining in good faith. (ANDY CLARK/REUTERS)

Court papers show B.C. Liberals wanted to provoke teachers strike, Dix says Add to ...

The Opposition New Democratic Party says court transcripts show B.C. Premier Christy Clark was involved in plans to provoke a full-blown strike in the public school system in a bid to gain public support for legislation that would end a labour dispute with the B.C. Teachers Federation (BCTF).

“I think that it’s reasonable to conclude from the evidence provided – not by teachers or by parents or by anyone else, but by evidence presented by government people in the court – that the Premier and her government set out to provoke a strike to stop kids from going to school, to further Liberal political interests,” NDP leader Adrian Dix told the House.

More Related to this Story

A day after Ms. Clark said she “fundamentally” disagreed with a Supreme Court judgment that her government tried to provoke a strike rather than bargain in good faith, the NDP opposition read the court transcripts in the legislature. The NDP said they show the government’s lead negotiator in the talks discussed the labour strategy with John Dyble, the top bureaucrat in the Premier’s Office, to prepare cabinet for a briefing.

The province has applied to the B.C. Court of Appeal to challenge the B.C. Supreme Court ruling that the government’s legislated settlement of the teachers’ dispute was unconstitutional.

The province’s lawyers are also seeking to keep under wraps cabinet documents that were tabled in court that deal with the government strategy around the BCTF labour dispute.

But on Wednesday, the NDP skirted that court battle by reading aloud from transcripts of Paul Straszak’s testimony about the strategy under cross-examination last September.

Mr. Straszak, the former CEO of the government’s bargaining agent, the Public Sector Employers’ Council, explained in court that he provided a strategy document to Mr. Dyble setting out how to manage the teachers’ labour dispute that was brewing in 2011 and 2012. The Premier is not directly mentioned in the transcripts the NDP released on Wednesday.

At the time, the teachers’ union was engaging in job action such as refusing to participate in extracurricular activities. The government wanted to legislate an end to that in 2012, but Mr. Straszak warned that could alienate the public unless the teachers could be goaded into a full strike.

“What we are talking about here is cabinet is going to be in an awkward situation in the context of a low-scale strike, meaning it’s going to want to put an end to it, but the public won’t necessarily see the need for the legislation because the kids are still in school,” he explained in court.

He then was asked how the government intended to address the situation: “We have some tools to increase the pressure on the TF [Teachers’ Federation] to escalate the strike,” the court heard. Those tools included cutting teachers’ pay – a measure that the Labour Relations Board later rejected.

The Premier refused to take questions in the House about the revelations, deferring to Justice Minister Suzanne Anton. Ms. Anton also declined to answer questions: “All of the evidence will be before the Court of Appeal,” Ms. Anton told the House. “The Court of Appeal will make its judgment accordingly and we must leave them to it.”

As recently as Tuesday, the Premier denied to reporters that her government tried to engineer a full-scale strike. “Absolutely not,” she said. “I understand that was the characterization that was set out [in the judgment]. I fundamentally disagree with that, it is not correct, that is one of the many reasons we are going to have another judge take a look at it.”

Ms. Clark did not speak to reporters after Question Period. Education Minister Peter Fassbender insisted the judge was wrong. “Clearly this government has worked very hard … to not provoke strikes in any sector and that is the case in this as well. I’m not going to comment on [Mr. Straszak’s] testimony.”

Follow on Twitter: @justine_hunter

Rafal Gerszak the The Globe and Mail

Vancouver School Board

The Vancouver School Board estimates it would need $47-million in additional funding to match the 2002-2003 service levels. This breaks down to $31.5-million in lost staffing, including 524 entry-level teachers, and $15.5-million in loss of supplies and services such as technology and building maintenance, according to the VSB. This estimate is based on the school board’s 2002-2003 base budget, which was adjusted to reflect a number of factors, including collective agreement increases and changes in student enrolment. (Pictured: Grade 12 students Stephen Keitlah, 17, left, and Gerald Angus, 17, talk outside Britannia Secondary School in Vancouver on Jan. 21, 2014.)
Rafal Gerszak for The Globe and Mail

Surrey Schools

Surrey is one of the fastest-growing cities in the Metro Vancouver area, with one-third of its residents under the age of 19. If pre-2002 contract language was restored now, the city says it would have 18 more teacher-librarians, 19 more counsellors, 51 more special-education teachers and 80 English-language learner teachers. (Pictured: Robyn Thiessen works with students Mehar Shergill, 10, left, and Kabir Sidhu, 10, at Green Timbers Elementary School in Surrey, B.C., on Jan. 09, 2014.)
Keith Anderson/Kamloops Daily News/The Canadian Press

Kamloops/Thompson (School District No. 73)

The Kamloops/Thompson school district is calculating what a restoration of the contract language would mean and is expected to have a better idea next week, said Superintendent Terry Sullivan. While he says some teacher-student ratios are better than 2002 levels, he expressed concern that a shift in ratios could create a ripple effect through schools (Pictured: A third of the students at Brocklehurst Secondary School in Kamloops, B.C., about 300 in total, walk out of school on Jan. 9, 2002, in protest to send a message to the government that they would like the teachers' job dispute to end.)

In the know

Most popular video »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories