Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

Lifeboats from the Queen of the North sit on the deck of the Canadian Coast Guard vessel Sir Wilfred Laurier while on route to Prince Rupert, B.C., on March 22, 2006. (Richard Lam/The Canadian Press)
Lifeboats from the Queen of the North sit on the deck of the Canadian Coast Guard vessel Sir Wilfred Laurier while on route to Prince Rupert, B.C., on March 22, 2006. (Richard Lam/The Canadian Press)

Criminal negligence trial hears catastrophic collision caught on tape Add to ...

The first moment anyone from the outside world knew something was amiss on the Queen of the North passenger ferry, crippled and taking on water off the northern coast of British Columbia, came at about 22 minutes past midnight on a windy March night seven years ago.

“Traffic: this is Queen of the North, Queen of the North, Queen of the North,” the ship’s second officer, Kevin Hilton, called into his marine radio.

More Related to this Story

“Traffic, traffic: we have run aground south of Sainty Point, several miles south of Sainty Point. Stand by for position.”

The ship had just struck Gil Island. About 20 minutes before that, the vessel missed a crucial turn as it sailed down B.C.’s Inside Passage with 101 people on board.

Audio recordings of what happened next were played on Wednesday at the criminal negligence trial of Karl Lilgert, who was fourth officer on the ship. Mr. Lilgert is charged in connection with the deaths of two passengers, who haven’t been seen since the ferry sank on March 22, 2006.

The recordings suggest there was no sign of trouble, at least none reported to marine operators, as the ship sailed on a collision course toward Gil Island.

They also show how fast the situation turned catastrophic: within minutes, the ship was listing to one side, passengers were being herded onto life boats, and nearby fishing vessels were summoned to help.

The trial has heard that Mr. Lilgert was on the bridge with quartermaster Karen Bricker, his former lover, at the time of the collision. The audio recordings suggest the accident was not reported on the radio until Mr. Hilton returned to the bridge.

In the minute or so that followed, a marine officer in Prince Rupert, which the ship had left four hours earlier, struggled to pin down the ferry’s position.

Within two minutes, the crew was asking for help.

“We require assistance,” said a crew member on the ship, identified in a court transcript as Janice O’Neill.

“And confirm that you are not taking on water?” asked marine operator Kim Brownlee, who testified about the recordings on Wednesday.

“We are taking on water,” Ms. O’Neill replied.

And then, from the ship’s captain, Colin Henthorne: “Our list is increasing. We need assistance immediately.”

Several minutes after that, the evacuation was in full swing.

“How many people do you have on board,” the marine operator asked.

“We have 101 persons on board the ship,” Ms. O’Neill replied. “We are proceeding, readying life boats and life rafts.”

Meanwhile, operators of fishing vessels offered to help. Some were a half hour from the sinking vessel. Others were hours away, but were told to head to the scene anyway.

About 12 minutes after the collision was first reported, a resident of a tiny First Nations community north of Gil Island took to the radio.

“This is Hartley Bay,” said Eddie Robinson. “We’re trying to get some boats to come out.”

Eventually, the community had at least three fast-response boats in the water and two 10-metre fishing vessels headed to the Queen of the North.

As those boats were on the way, an ominous message came from the ferry.

“We have abandoned the ship now,” chief officer Richard St. Pierre said. “We have five life rafts, one rescue boat and two life boats in the water.”

The passengers were taken to Hartley Bay, where they were put up in a local community centre, or a coast guard ship, the Sir Wilfred Laurier, that was in the area.

Throughout the morning, marine traffic operators, people involved in the rescue, and rescue officials in the Victoria area struggled to confirm how many people were on board the ship and how many made it off.

The tally of passengers and crew alternated between 101 and 102, the trial heard. So did the number of missing one, maybe two, or perhaps none.

In the end, 99 passengers and crew survived the sinking. Two passengers, Gerald Foisy and Shirley Rosette, were never seen again and are presumed drowned.

The jury heard about two hours of audio recordings on Wednesday.

The Crown has alleged Mr. Lilgert was responsible for the missed course correction, and that he failed to take any evasive actions before the ferry struck Gil Island.

The defence has suggested Mr. Lilgert was faced with poor training, unreliable equipment and inadequate policies within BC Ferries, the former Crown corporation that operates the province’s ferry system.

Mr. Lilgert has pleaded not guilty to two counts of criminal negligence causing death. His trial, before a jury, is expected to last up to six months.

 

Follow us on Twitter: @GlobeBC

In the know

Most popular videos »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular