Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

Philip Baker is stepping down as dean of the University of Alberta's medicine faculty.
Philip Baker is stepping down as dean of the University of Alberta's medicine faculty.

Probe of dean's plagiarized speech won't be made public, University of Alberta says Add to ...

The University of Alberta will not release the results of its investigation into the medical dean who resigned after admitting he plagiarized parts of a speech to graduates.

But if Philip Baker returns to teaching on campus next term, an official with the students’ union thinks he should talk openly with students about what happened.

More related to this story

“We feel that it’s important for Dr. Baker to take personal responsibility for his actions, if they are raised by students in class,” student vice-president Emerson Csorba said Monday.

He said the students’ union trusts that the university conducted a thorough investigation and took appropriate action. But said he hopes officials change their minds about releasing details.

“It’s important that the university is transparent about the process,” Mr. Csorba said.

Dr. Baker apologized in June for a “lapse in judgment” that led him to lift parts of an inspirational speech he gave to future doctors at a convocation banquet.

He said that when he was researching the speech, he was inspired by the text of a convocation address given by Atul Gawande, a surgeon and an associate professor at Harvard Medical School.

The “Velluvial Matrix” speech, given last year to graduates at Stanford University in California, was published in The New Yorker magazine.

Some students listening to Dr. Baker’s version of the speech quickly found Dr. Gawande’s original address online using their smart phones, and some said they followed along with what he was saying.

Dr. Baker quickly apologized to students. But after a week-long firestorm of criticism, he offered his resignation as dean and took a four-month administrative leave.

University president Indira Samarasekera said at the time staff would further investigate the matter and Dr. Baker could face further discipline.

University spokeswoman Deb Hammacher repeated Monday that Dr. Baker will not be reinstated as dean and an international search is under way for a replacement.

She said Dr. Baker is set to return as a professor in October. It’s not known whether he will teach or focus on research. He is listed on the university's website as an adjunct professor in the school’s physiology department.

Ms. Hammacher said the university cannot make its investigation public because it is an employee disciplinary matter and the faculty agreement requires that the process remain confidential. But Dr. Baker and the Association of Academic Staff University of Alberta can agree to release the information.



Ms. Hammacher said the same private process is in place for students who plagiarize. She added it’s a common misperception that students are expelled for stealing other people’s work.

“That’s just not true,” she said. “A first offence would never result in expulsion. There would have to be a pattern of behaviour and multiple offences for that to happen.”

Ms. Hammacher said she doesn’t believe the university’s reputation will be damaged by secrecy over the investigation. “As far as the institution is concerned, it’s a closed issue. And it’s behind us, and it was dealt with appropriately. I think the academic community feels like it was handled appropriately as well.”

Jeremy Richards, a professor in the university’s earth and atmospheric sciences department, publishes a regular blog about academic issues at the school and thinks Dr. Baker has suffered enough by leaving the dean’s office.

“It’s all very unfortunate,” Prof. Richards said. “Most of us were just stunned that someone in that position would let that happen. But I guess when you’re busy, you do things. It’s a very strange situation, and no one can really figure it out or understand why that happened.”

London’s Daily Mail newspaper reported last month that the General Medical Council, which grants licences to doctors in Britain, could remove Dr. Baker from its registry for plagiarism. A spokeswoman said any investigation is confidential and Dr. Baker remains on the registration list.

Dr. Baker received his training as an obstetrician and gynecologist at Nottingham University Medical School and was director of the Manchester Biomedical Research Centre before he joined the U of A in 2009.

Trevor Theman, registrar of Alberta’s College of Physicians and Surgeons, said it’s rare for the organization to investigate a complaint of plagiarism. He could not confirm whether the college is reviewing Dr. Baker’s status.

Follow us on Twitter: @globeandmail

In the know

Most popular video »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories