On the Toronto periphery, real estate begins to bounce back

Open this photo in gallery:

The real estate market in Ontario largely pauses while schools send their students off for March break, but the end of the holiday is likely to bring a crop of new listings in cities around the province.

In Barrie, Ont., the market is reaching balanced territory as buyers begin to move off the sidelines, says Shawna Toole, a real estate agent with Right at Home Realty.

She notes that sales and prices have started to edge up again.

In Barrie and Simcoe County, home sales dropped 43.4 per cent in February to 371 compared with the 656 transactions recorded in February, 2022, according to the Barrie & District Association of Realtors.

Months of inventory rose to 3.9 in February from 0.8 in the same month last year. The average price in February was $762,485, which marks a 24.6 per cent decline from the average price of $1,011,031 recorded at the peak in the same month last year.

Looking at just the City of Barrie, sales tumbled 50 per cent in February to 129 from 258 in February of last year.

Sales in Barrie became more tilted towards a buyers’ market after the Bank of Canada began raising interest rates in March, 2022.

The city about one hour north of Toronto also saw one of the most dramatic run-ups in prices during the pandemic as people from around Ontario migrated to the shore of Lake Simcoe. Barrie was especially popular because it offers plenty of opportunity for outdoor recreation and easy access to cottage country.

“I feared for people,” Ms. Toole says of the buying spree during the pandemic. “You’re going to spend $150,000 over ask for this already over-priced house? Things were just getting way out of hand.”

Ms. Toole says some Barrie residents sold at the peak and then decided to rent for a while, move into a trailer, or head south for a few months. Now some are returning to the market to buy. Others are first-time buyers.

The average price for a three-bedroom detached house was $680,000 in February, she notes. That’s up from $650,000 in January and $640,000 in December.

In February of last year, a typical three-bedroom detached was trading hands for $875,000.

Ms. Toole notes that higher interest rates have made it difficult for prospective buyers to obtain a mortgage. Buyers who could qualify for a $700,000 loan in the past now only receive approval to borrow about $500,000.

But now that prices have come down by approximately $200,000 for an average house, purchasers are willing to take on a mortgage at a higher interest rate with the hope that rates will come back down before too long.

Ms. Toole says areas such as Bear Creek and Innisfil are popular with buyers, who favour properties close to GO Transit train and bus stations in south Barrie for commuting to Toronto.

But some people who relocated to communities without GO service are now reconsidering that decision if they are being called back to their workplaces, she adds. Residents of Angus and Wasaga Beach, for example, have less access to transit.

“You’d better not work in Toronto because it’s a long haul.”

In a balanced market, sales are picking up but bidding contests are still in the distant past, adds Ms. Toole. Properties languish when sellers are unrealistic about current prices.

“The ones that are sitting are the ones who think it’s worth what it was one year ago.”

Ms. Toole says investors are still unwilling to purchase in the current market because with interest rates, property taxes and utility costs so elevated, rents don’t cover the expenses. Lengthy delays in Ontario’s legal process also discourage landlords who may need to evict tenants for non-payment of rent, she says.

As a result, some potential investors are looking to buy in Alberta and Nova Scotia, where they figure landlords have more clout.

As for sellers, some homeowners who purchased at lofty prices during the pandemic would have to sell for a lower price today. To avoid locking in a loss, some are renting out properties instead or leaving them vacant.

Others are people who purchased a condo townhouse or detached house in a new sub-division with the intention of selling it upon completion.

“They’re not going to make what they bought it for,” she says.

Some of those investors are unable to obtain a mortgage now, she says, so they are scrambling to borrow extra funds from family or private lenders.

Many of those properties end up on the rental market as well, she says.

“Six months ago I couldn’t find a rental. Now I can find a lot of rentals but they’re extremely high-priced.”

Anita Springate-Renaud, broker with Engel & Volkers, says agents are receiving calls for evaluations from homeowners in parts of Ontario such as Collingwood, Owen Sound and Muskoka. Many are considering selling as the weather improves.

Some prospective sellers are downsizing from a large property or letting go of a vacation home. Others purchased in remote areas and are now gravitating back towards larger cities.

Collingwood’s position on the edge of Georgian Bay made the city popular during the pandemic amongst people who pursue outdoor sports such as skiing, sailing and hiking. To the north-west, Owen Sound provided more affordable properties on an inlet of Georgian Bay.

Ms. Springate-Renaud says Collingwood in particular saw a strong run-up in prices. Many times, she saw fierce bidding by people who sold their property in Toronto and then used the funds to buy in smaller cities.

If they decide to sell now, they are likely looking at a loss, she says.

“They way overbid everybody else. If it was listed at $999,000, they would offer $1.4-million. They’re not going to get that back.”

Smaller markets are more susceptible to price swings than the Greater Toronto Area, she adds.

Ms. Springate-Renaud does not expect to see listings rise in cottage country until farther into the spring.

“Muskoka doesn’t start picking up until things melt.”

But judging by the number of calls Engel & Volkers is receiving, she expects a busy spring.

Homeowners who are struggling with higher interest rates will typically sell a cottage or ski chalet before their principal residence, she adds.

Housing affordability improved in Canada in the fourth quarter of last year, according to Kyle Dahms and Alexandra Ducharme, economists at National Bank of Canada.

The shift ended the longest sequence of declining home affordability since the 1986-1989 interlude, they say.

Home prices declined at the fastest pace since 1990 during the quarter, but the economists stress, the median home is still not affordable when they look at the mortgage payment as a percentage of income.

During the fourth quarter, the benchmark mortgage rate for a five-year term rose, but houses prices fell and incomes continued to increase.

Victoria, Hamilton and Toronto were the markets that improved the most on the affordability scale, while Edmonton and Calgary became less affordable.

Ms. Dahms and Ms. Ducharme expect affordability will improve in the coming quarters as mortgage rates peak, listings rise, and home prices continue to decline.

Editor’s note: Editor's Note: A previous version of this story used data that combined results from multiple real estate boards. This version has been clarified.