Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

People walk past a Coach store on Madison Avenue in New York, in this January 23, 2013 file photo. (CARLO ALLEGRI/REUTERS)
People walk past a Coach store on Madison Avenue in New York, in this January 23, 2013 file photo. (CARLO ALLEGRI/REUTERS)

Coach sales in North America plummet as market share erodes Add to ...

Coach Inc.’s sales in North America fell sharply during the key holiday quarter as the handbag maker continued to lose customers to fast-growing rivals.

The New York company, known for its leather goods, on Wednesday reported a 13.6-per-cent decrease in comparable-store sales in North America.

It was the third consecutive quarter of decline in a market that accounts for 70 per cent of its revenue, and a much deeper drop for the holiday quarter than Coach forecast in October.

More Related to this Story

There were some bright spots in Coach’s results: sales in China rose 25 per cent, quelling fears a slowdown in luxury spending growth there would hurt Coach. And sales in North America for handbags priced above $400 were also up.

Still, company executives expect Coach’s problems to persist in North America in the next six months, predicting continued sales drops there.

Relief may only come in the fall, when the first collection designed under its new creative director, Stuart Vevers, hits stores.

Until then, Coach will have to make do with offerings many analysts said are stale and less appealing than merchandise offered by rivals such as Michael Kors Holdings Ltd., kate spade and Tory Burch, which are aggressively expanding their fleets of stores.

“These guys are definitely losing share. Fashionwise, they’re missing the beat,” Edward Jones analyst Brian Yarbrough said.

Between 2011 and 2012, Coach’s share of the U.S. handbag market fell to 17.5 per cent from 19 per cent, according to Euromonitor International. Michael Kors’ market share rose to 7 per cent from 4.5 per cent.

North American sales fell 9 per cent to $983-million in the second quarter ended Dec. 28, a startling drop in a women’s handbags and accessories market Coach executives said grew by a “high single-digit” percentage points during the period.

Chief executive Victor Luis is pinning Coach’s turnaround hopes on Vevers’ collections, making Coach fashion-forward again. Luis told analysts on a call that Vevers was “providing a fashion relevance for the brand like we have never had.”

Vevers joined Coach from Loewe – a luxury handbag brand owned by LVMH – in September, replacing longtime creative director Reed Krakoff.

Coach’s overall revenue fell 5.6 per cent to $1.42-billion, in the second quarter, while profit dropped to $297.4-million or $1.06 per share from $352.8-million or $1.23 a year earlier.

Analysts on average had expected earnings of $1.11 per share on revenue of $1.48-billion, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.


To win back shoppers, the 73-year-old company is trying to offer more footwear and fashion to become a lifestyle brand. Coach will be presenting a collection at New York Fashion Week next month for the first time.

Mr. Luis, who took the reins this month from long-time CEO Lew Frankfort, told Reuters that Coach is “rebalancing” its merchandise selection and increasing its offerings of handbags priced $400 or more.

After the 2008-09 recession, Coach had ramped up its selection of lower-price handbags.

During the 2013 holiday season, Coach had to contend with a problem many retailers have complained about: a drop in traffic to shopping malls, and fewer shoppers coming into its stores. Still, kate spade and Michael Kors, which operate many stores in the same malls as Coach, are expected to report sales gains.

Coach’s poor sales led to a surplus of merchandise it said it would clear through its factory outlets, raising the spectre of more pressure on its profit margin. Inventory levels were up 12 per cent at the end of quarter, while company-wide sales fell 3 per cent, stripping out the effect of currency fluctuations.

Its gross profit margin fell 3 percentage points to 69.2 per cent of sales during the quarter, hurt by deep discounting.

The 2013 holiday season was the most discount-driven period since the recession, leading many large U.S. retailers to slash profit forecasts earlier this month.

Security Price Change
COH-N Coach Inc. 49.25 0.39
0.798 %
Add to watchlist
Live Discussion of COH on StockTwits
More Discussion on COH-N


In the know

Most popular video »


More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories