The euro zone may raise the combined lending power of its bailout funds to close to €700-billion from €500-billion, in a trade-off between German opposition to committing more money and the need to calm markets, officials said.
Euro zone finance ministers and central bankers will discuss the size of their bailout capacity – the temporary European Financial Stability Facility and the permanent European Stability Mechanism – in Copenhagen on March 30-31.
The €440-billion EFSF and the €500-billion now have a combined lending ceiling of €500-billion, which means that in the 12 months from July, 2012, when they co-exist, they cannot lend more than that between them.
The size of the euro zone’s bailout fund is of keen interest to ministers of the Group of 20 economies, who are due to meet again in April. They want to stop the euro debt crisis dragging on the world economy, but are reluctant to boost the bailout resources of the International Monetary Fund unless the euro zone does more to increase its own firewall.
Markets have long been pushing for a higher lending capacity to make sure there is enough money to bail out even large euro zone economies like Italy or Spain, should that be necessary. But Germany has been adamantly opposed to such an increase.
“Given that the situation is difficult in several countries, it seems to me the easiest option is the least ambitious one,” one senior euro zone official said.
Out of its €440-billion of lending power, the EFSF has already committed €192-billion to bailouts for Greece, Ireland and Portugal.
“One possibility would be to say the EFSF has made commitments of €192-billion, but the ESM should start afresh with €500-billion,” the senior euro zone official said.
“The combined lending capacity would go from €500-billion to €692-billion – roughly €700-billion. That is one of the options under discussion and that is probably the least ambitious and therefore politically the easiest,” the official said.
A second euro zone official confirmed this was a likely solution, although both officials noted several options were being examined and the final decision was still uncertain.
EU Economic and Monetary Affairs Commissioner Olli Rehn has called for a joint lending capacity of around €750-billion, calculated as the full €500-billion of the ESM when it comes on line in July and the €248-billion of yet uncommitted EFSF funds.
But this would require all euro zone countries to pay in all their capital contributions to the ESM, now meant to be spread over four years, in one go, as well as keeping their guarantees for the EFSF’s remaining €248-billion in lending.
“That will not happen, unless there is a clear need,” the first senior official said.
“That would be totally out of line with the market at the moment. At the moment one does not see any need for more money. The markets are calming down,” the official said.
“You can only talk about potential needs. Six months ago people were talking about Italy and Spain, but all that has disappeared. They can refinance themselves at rates that are sustainable, so it is hard to build a case today that (the bailout capacity) must go up,” he said.
Euro zone countries have agreed to pay two tranches of ESM capital by July, giving the ESM an initial lending capacity of only €200-billion.
Together with the €192-billion of committed EFSF funds, that would still be well below the existing joint ceiling.
If further capital tranches are paid on an annual basis, the ESM would reach €500-billion only in four years. But officials stressed the full amount could be reached quickly if needed.
“The effective capacity is determined by paid in capital and the current thinking is to have two tranches this year,” a third euro zone official said.
“However, the rest of the capital is callable and there are also automatic mechanisms in the treaty that ensure that capital keeps getting paid in as money from the ESM is being disbursed,” the third official said.
“So if the money were to be needed, the rest of the paid-in capital can be brought to the ESM quickly and easily, effectively providing it with €500-billion of available money,” he said.
The EFSF is to end any lending operations in mid-2013, and exist only to service the lending programs that it has engaged in by then, which means any EFSF lending capacity that could be added to the ESM under the scenario advocated by the Commission would last only until mid-2013.
The European Union executive arm wants to include a review clause in any agreement on the capacity of the funds to be able to re-assess the size of the funds once again in mid-2013.