Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

A TNT delivery truck is seen behind a closed gate in Hoofddorp, near Amsterdam, Netherlands, Feb. 21, 2012. TNT Express NV sidestepped questions Monday about an unsolicited UPS takeover bid, announcing instead an abrupt switch in strategy to focus on its European operations after posting a large fourth-quarter loss partly due to problems at its Brazilian arm. (Peter Dejong/AP)
A TNT delivery truck is seen behind a closed gate in Hoofddorp, near Amsterdam, Netherlands, Feb. 21, 2012. TNT Express NV sidestepped questions Monday about an unsolicited UPS takeover bid, announcing instead an abrupt switch in strategy to focus on its European operations after posting a large fourth-quarter loss partly due to problems at its Brazilian arm. (Peter Dejong/AP)

Breakingviews

The courtship of TNT: Handle with care Add to ...

UPS’s €4.9-billion ($6.5-billion) love letter validates TNT Express's recent divorce. The U.S. parcel service has admired its smaller Dutch peer for years, and proposed just before Valentine’s Day. TNT is thinking about it. But clearly its 2011 split from PostNL, the dowdy domestic mail business, is finally achieving the desired effect.

More related to this story

While traditional postal services struggle with e-mail and upstart competitors, the express industry – rapid international deliveries, courier services, and parcels – has fared better. But the sector still cries out for consolidation, because zipping packages worldwide is a scale game. Hence last year’s TNT-PostNL separation, under pressure from activist investors. The newly single TNT made a clear bid target: sizable in Europe, but globally lagging UPS, FedEx and Deutsche Post’s DHL, and struggling to make money in Brazil and China.

UPS’s €9-a-share all-cash bid may look first class, pitched at an outsize 43-per-cent premium to TNT’s previous close. It values TNT at 10.4 times the €470-million in earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization that Nomura estimates it will make in 2012. UPS trades at 9.8 times current-year EBITDA and FedEx at just 6.1 times, StarMine data show.

But TNT is right to drag its feet. The offer is still a 5-per-cent discount to the shares’ first close post the demerger. Investors weary with the weak performance of TNT shares since the separation will not be easily appeased.

Big synergies, based partly on combining ground and air fleets, could justify UPS going higher. Barclays Capital reckons it could reap $451-million in annual gains if it gets TNT’s margins up to its own. Taxed and capitalized, these are worth perhaps $3.4-billion – against the $1.9-billion premium currently on offer. But disposals to appease antitrust regulators may pare back the value creation to something less stratospheric: on BarCap’s figures, UPS already has 23 per cent of Europe’s international express market, and TNT 16 per cent.

UPS is probably reluctant to launch a hostile bid. This would be a transformational deal and the company has never done anything big in Europe before; it needs to keep TNT management on side. But TNT really needs to get an auction going to force UPS to pay up. Antitrust concerns make DHL a non-starter as a counterbidder – but not FedEx. UPS’s home rival is more highly geared, and would enjoy fewer synergies. Still, FedEx also risks being marginalized in Europe, and even a failed intervention could compel UPS to raise. This courtship is going somewhere.

In the know

Most popular videos »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular