Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

Alberta Premier Allison Redford listens during the budget speech in Edmonton on Thursday, Feb. 9, 2012 at the Alberta Legislature. (Ian Jackson/Ian Jackson/THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Alberta Premier Allison Redford listens during the budget speech in Edmonton on Thursday, Feb. 9, 2012 at the Alberta Legislature. (Ian Jackson/Ian Jackson/THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Top Business Stories

Alberta-Ontario cold war to linger amid strong Canadian dollar Add to ...

These are stories Report on Business is following Thursday, March 1, 2012. Get the top business stories through the day on BlackBerry or iPhone by bookmarking our mobile-friendly webpage.

Follow Michael Babad and Globe top business news on Twitter

What commodity prices, dollar have wrought The strength of the Canadian dollar threatens to prolong inter-provincial tensions as its effects are felt differently across the country.

More related to this story

Strong commodities prices have helped buoy the loonie , a combination that boosts Alberta's fortunes but hurts Ontario as it hammers manufacturing. Indeed, BMO Nesbitt Burns noted today, some 500,000 factory jobs have been lost in Canada over the 10 years since the currency began climbing back from its 62-cent lows.

In a separate study today, senior currency strategists David Watt and Stewart Hall of RBC Dominion Securities pointed out that "wrenching adjustments are imposed on a relative few" by the high currency. And they noted the spat between Alberta's Premier Alison Redford and her Ontario counterpart Dalton McGuinty.

"With future oil sands production, global oil demand and oil exports seen keeping [the Canadian dollar]persistently strong, regional tensions are likely to linger, particularly if the benefits remain highly concentrated."

They cited "a (cold) war of words" between Alberta, home to Canada's oil industry, and Ontario, a manufacturing hub. Ms. Redford had wanted Ontario to help in the fight for pipelines, while Mr. McGuinty responded by saying he'd take a weaker currency over a "rapidly growing" energy sector in Alberta.

"Reasonable projections for oil sands production, global oil demand and oil exports, with almost all of the increased oil production destined for foreign shores ... suggest persistent tailwinds to [the Candian dollar]over time," said the RBC strategists. "McGuinty’s statement hints at the potential for lingering regional tensions during the next commodity super cycle."

Ontario's factories have been hit hard, though the province has still created hundreds of thousands of jobs in other sectors over the past several years. Mr. Watt and Mr. Hall believe most of the hit to manufacturing jobs is now done, though they don't see that work returning in the near future.

Their comments came as BMO's deputy chief economist, Douglas Porter, published a study showing the impact of the dollar's return to grace over the past 10 years.

Here's what he found:

  • Employment in manufacturing plunged 22 per cent, a cost of almost 500,000 jobs. More than half of the losses came before the recession, and none of the positions lost to the slump have come back. Having said that, he added in an interview, the U.S. also suffered factory losses, so more was at play. Still, it had a big impact.
  • The manufacturing job losses have been "largely mirrored" by a strong showing in resources, though those industries are just about 20 per cent of the size of the factory sector.
  • Canada's "previously robust" current account surplus, the broadest measure of trade, has plunged to a deficit, reported by Statistics Canada today at $48.3-billion for 2011, given the dollar's lofty levels along with a drop in U.S. spending.
  • Merchandise trade has come back, but the surplus "remains a shadow of itself from 10 years ago." And, he added, "perhaps the most telling statistic in the sea of data ... is the $32-billion swing in auto trade over the 10-year period, from a surplus of around 2 per cent of GDP in 2001 to a deficit of 0.7 per cent last year." That wasn't all the fault of the dollar, but it certainly played a role.
  • Investors in Toronto-listed stocks were doing better than those in the S&P 500 even without factoring in the dollar, largely on the surge in commodities. "However, when adjusted to common currency terms, the relative return gap swells tremendously, with holdings in foreign markets shredded by the loonie's surge."

A separate study this week by CIBC World Markets economists Avery Shenfeld and Warren Lovely also found that while factory output has rebounded from the recession, its outlook for growth is dim because of the "structural hit" from the loonie.

"The crux of the issue is that the climb in the Canadian dollar has pushed goods sector wages (and other local costs) well above those state-side in common currency terms," they say.

"As a result, Canada is no longer a cost-effective location for a host of non-resource-related manufacturing activities. Initially, shutdowns were seen in sectors like apparel and furniture that had earlier hung on in part due to an undervalued exchange rate. More recently, Canada has lagged in attracting or retaining facilities for autos and parts, rail cars, steel mills, and other goods where the competition is now more weighted to U.S. producers."

Mr. Shenfeld and Mr. Lovely also note the shift in power caused by both the dollar and high resource prices.

Alberta, Saskatchewan and Newfoundland and Labrador benefit, while Ontario and Quebec lag.

"Within Canada, labour will continue to seek out brighter opportunities in the West," the CIBC economists said.

"As economic, fiscal and political power consolidates in Western Canada, regional income inequality will soar and inter-provincial tensions will rise. Canada’s monetary authorities can avoid accelerating that process by keeping rates on hold for longer, but even a sidelined Bank of Canada won’t prevent a further hollowing out of Canada’s manufacturing heartland."

RBC, TD boost dividends Unlike their counterparts in other countries, shareholders of Canada's major banks are enjoying higher dividends.

While Bank of Montreal left its payout unchanged earlier this week, both Royal Bank of Canada and Toronto-Dominion Bank hiked theirs today.

Others have also boosted their dividends since the slump.

As The Globe and Mail's David Berman reported earlier this week, it's been a while since dividend hikes and share buybacks were unveiled in the United States, for example.

That could change this year, analysts at Credit Suisse say, noting that dividends and buybacks averaged just 23 per cent of earnings in 2011 in the U.S. financial sector. But for now, shareholders in the Canadian sector can count their pennies.

RBC today boosted its quarterly dividend by about 6 per cent, or 3 cents, to 57 cents, while TD hiked its by 4 cents, also 6 per cent, to 72 cents.

But the market outlook for the sector overall?

"Consumer and financial stocks have also outperformed in the U.S., a trend that could persist given the macro-economic backdrop," Robert Kavcic of BMO Nesbitt Burns said in a recent report.

"There is far more pent-up demand for homes and cars south of the border, and credit growth has turned positive after two years of deleveraging. In Canada, household debt is elevated, the post-recession surge in housing demand appears largely tapped out, and the bank sector faces a slower earnings growth environment."

TD profit slips TD may have increased its dividend, but its first-quarter profit slipped, The Globe and Mail's Tara Perkins reports.

TD said today it earned $1.48-billion or $1.55 a share, diluted, in the quarter, compared to $1.56 or $1.67 a year ear earlier. TD was hit by a weaker showing in its capital markets unit, and a litigation reserve.

"While we knew going into 2012 that our businesses would continue to grow in the face of a challenging environment, their performance has exceeded our expectations," said chief executive officer Ed Clark.

RBC posts lower profit RBC also posted lower first-quarter results, The Globe and Mail's Grant Robertson writes, also because of weaker earnings in its capital markets operation.

Profit slipped to $1.86-billion or $1.21 a share, from $1.95-billion or $1.27.

"Looking ahead through 2012, we believe that we are very well positioned to continue extending our lead in Canada and building client relationships in select U.S. and international markets, while maintaining our strong capital position and strict risk and cost discipline," said chief executive officer Gordon Nixon.

No 'credit event' in Greece, panel says An industry panel determined today that next week's planned swap of Greek debt doesn't constitute a "credit event," a key ruling in the ongoing euro zone debt crisis.

The decision by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association means billions in default insurance won't be paid to debt holders. It settles two complaints from parties wanting the insurance to be paid out on the basis that the European Central Bank is getting a better deal than others in the restructuring.

The ISDA, though, didn't close the door entirely, citing the findings of its EMEA determinations committee.

"The EMEA DC noted, however, that the situation in the Hellenic Republic is still evolving and today’s EMEA DC decisions do not affect the right or ability of market participants to submit further questions to the EMEA DC relating to the Hellenic Republic nor is it an expression of the EMEA DC’s view as to whether a credit event could occur at a later date, in each case, as further facts come to light," it said in its statement.

Standard & Poor's has decided that Greece is now in "selective default" because it changed the rules of the game retroactively via "collective action clauses," or CACs that force some bondholders into new payment terms. That remains an issue.

"As was largely expected, ISDA has made the announcement that a credit event has not occurred on the back of the ECB debt swap," said Mark Chandler and Ian Pollick of RBC Dominion Securities. "Recall, though, this is not the 'end all be all,' as there could be another ruling if CACs are used (which many are expecting to be a considered a credit event)."

Bombardier profit slides Shares of Canada's Bombardier Inc. tanked today as the company capped what it called "good financial results" for 2011 with a dip in fourth-quarter profit and revenue. The fourth quarter, though, was marked by a change in the its aerospace division's reporting period, shaving off a month's worth of results.

The plane and train manufacturer posted a fourth-quarter profit of $214-million (U.S.) or 12 cents a share, diluted, down from $295-million or 16 cents a year earlier. Revenue slipped to $4.3-billion from $5.6-billion.

Chief executive officer Pierre Beaudoin said Bombardier's aerospace unit "navigated through another demanding year" successfully, while the transportation business continued to see "steady" growth.

"With our two groups, we’re uniquely suited to weather today’s environment, with our unrivalled product portfolio and greater geographical reach," he said in a statement. "And we keep on investing and putting the pieces in place to be a very different company in five years."

The company also projected deliveries this year of about 180 business and 55 commercial aircraft, which UBS Securities Canada analyst Hilda Maraachlian described as "relatively flat" year over year, on an annualized basis. As she put it in a research note, the results marked a "Q4 beat but weak C2012 aero guidance."

Desjardins analyst Benoit Poirier called Bombardier's projection "underwhelming," but added its shares "represent attractive value for long-term investors, with several upcoming catalysts."

Analyst glum on RIM A prominent industry analyst has cut his price target and profit estimates for Research In Motion Ltd. ahead of the BlackBerry maker's fourth-quarter results later this month, The Globe and Mail's Iain Marlow reports.

Jeffries analyst Peter Misek also warns there's a "greater than 50-per-cent chance" that RIM will negatively pre-announce the quarter and is now selling far fewer BlackBerrys than expected.

Mr. Misek's target price is now just $12.

RIM is scheduled to report fourth-quarter results March 29, the same day that Finance Minister Jim Flaherty brings down his budget. Let's see who can upset people more.

Big Deals In just eight months, the business of investment banking has gone from high-flying to just plain trying for bankers who make their living helping companies raise money or buy competitors, The Globe and Mail's Boyd Erman writes.

Business ticker

Follow on Twitter: @michaelbabad

In the know

Most popular video »

Highlights

More from The Globe and Mail

Most Popular Stories