Skip navigation

 Login or Register | Member Centre

Knight: One town, two stadiums

So, I took a brief break from soccer Sunday afternoon, and did something I haven't done in 14 years.
 
I went to see the Toronto Blue Jays play at the ‘Dome.
 
Away from the footie pitch, and away from children's music, I work part-time with special-needs adults for a wonderful organization called Community Living Toronto.  I assist folks who have their own apartments, but need some help with normal, day-to-day
 chores. 
 
It was CLT day at the ball park on Sunday, so three clients and I trooped down to watch Jays' ace Roy Halladay pitch against the Chicago White Sox.
 
(There is a strong soccer angle coming.  I promise.)
 
I'm honoured to work with some very dear people on this job, and we all had a wonderful time.  I also got to compare the experience of watching baseball at Rogers Centre with the Toronto FC phenomenon that is rocking BMO Field right off its foundations.  It was … interesting.
 
Background: I went to 40-odd Blue Jays baseball games a year, from that famously snowy opening day in 1977 right up until about 1990.  I hated Exhibition Stadium for its dreadful sightlines, but came to dislike the ‘Dome even more for its impersonality, odd angles and non-stop blaring hype.
 
I still went occasionally, up until the strike wiped out the World Series in 1994.  Yep, I'm one of The Fans Who Never Came Back.  By the time '94 rolled around, I was a ravenous travelling lacrosse fanatic, which took up a lot of my time and passion.  I was married then, too, which took up a lot more.
 
Lacrosse became my sporting grande passion.  I didn't need the Blue Jays anymore.  Honestly didn't much miss them, either. 
 
My final baseball game was at Three Rivers Stadium in Pittsburgh, in August of '94.

The Mets and the Pirates.  Lovely little 3-2 game.  Can't even remember who won.  And I honestly knew, as I sat there that night, I was probably never going to give a dime of my money to Major League Baseball – ever again.
 
(Soccer angle approaching.)
 
And so, my CLT clients and I settled into some very nice 14th-row aisle seats in short left field, and I was reunited with the grand old ritual of watching Blue Jays baseball live.  The differences from BMO Field are, indeed, hugely noticeable.
 
The Rogers Centre seats rise from the playing field at a very shallow angle.  If you're on the aisle, your view of the infield is blocked anytime anybody stands up.  Yes, you can watch the action on the Jumbotron, but at any given moment, on any given play, your view can vanish. 
 
The hype is pounding, and relentless.

Someone, somewhere, decided that baseball fans need to be entertained every single second, even though baseball is a slow, poetic, thoughtful, reflective game.  But who needs poetry when you get to guess which animated recycling truck is carrying the hidden giant baseball on the Jumbotron?
 
You're being sold something – aggressively – from the moment you enter the stadium till the second you finally get squeezed through the exit door.

And nobody seems to mind in the least that their 14th-row seats have an obstructed view.
 
My clients had an amazing, wonderful, fantastic time.  They were beaming on the subway home.  Happy, excited, it was a joy to see.  Whatever role the Blue Jays played in putting the day together, thank you very much and we all look forward gleefully to doing it again.  Whatever thoughts I'm offering now do not reflect the views of Community Living Toronto, or its clients, in any way at all.
 
I'm speaking, instead, as the starry-eyed 17-year-old who watched Bill Singer throw the first pitch to Ralph Garr of the White Sox from way WAY out behind the right field foul pole on April 7, 1977, and fell in love for years.
 
(Cue the soccer angle.)
 
If you haven't yet experienced BMO Field on a Toronto FC game day, things are hugely different.  The seats are all right on top of the play.  Clear straight views from everywhere – unless you got bought scalped tickets in the supporters' section behind the south goal and naively thought you were going to be able to sit down back there.
 
The hype is kept to a minimum.  We're informed of the waybill number the courier company used to deliver the game ball to the officials, but that passes quickly.  A watch company “sponsors” the time added on at the end of each half.

Personally, I don't think you should ever be allowed to sponsor a dimension, but no one asked me, and there you go.
 
In the end, the only thing that ever much happens at a TFC game is people who love the game, watch the game – and make a huge and happy noise cheering.
 
There is nothing really wrong with Blue Jays baseball.  I moved on long ago, but it's still a good and grand institution, and good for them for hanging in there.  I've just come to want something simpler – purer.  For years it was lacrosse, and right now it's Toronto FC.
 
There is so much less happening at BMO Field.  And it's so much more enjoyable.

Onward!

  1. John McFetridge from Canada writes: Wow, I've had an eerily similar experience (I even worked for Burlington Community Living years ago). I grew up a member of the Young Expos in Montreal and after moving to Toronto I even went to Blue Jays games, but since the strike, not so much.

    I've also discovered TFC and have been going to BMO and having a fantastic time. I can only see it getting better.
  2. Dave Hunt from Canada writes: Ben: I could not agree with you more. My Grey Cup experience was not any different than your Blue Jay experience(lots of staff being shoved dowm my throat---fans asked to clap, cheer, shout etc. on the Jumbotron--what a joke?!)

    I've attended ALL pro sports in Toronto--for years--nothing enthuses me more than speding time at BMO Field watching TFC. I believe the TFC experience will only get better with time.

    Threre will be a "BRING REAL GRASS TO BMO FIELD PETITION" on the Internet soon for fans to sign(after testing the idea with some fans I've gotten extremely positive responses--real grass is the way to go!!). I think if real grass is installed in the not too distant future---the BMO Field experience will be more amazing(I think most palyers hate playing on a carpet full of rubber pellets).
  3. Trilly B from Canada writes: I haven't been to a Jays game since... who knows. Before the lockout, in any case.

    I've been dying to get to a TFC game, simply because of the atmosphere. It's been a few years now since I was at a loud Toronto sporting event.
  4. Andrew Bucholtz from Kingston, Canada writes: I don't mind the atmosphere at Jays' games, which are still a lot of fun. That said, as you point out, BMO Field and TFC provide superior entertainment in almost every respect. There's a reason (beyond just the larger seating capacity) you have to sell your soul to get a TFC ticket, but you can walk up to the Rogers Centre right before a Jays' game and snag a ticket for around $10. The Jays are fun to watch, but a TFC match is an amazing experience.
  5. Random Person from Heard and Mc Donald Islands writes: In soccer at least you can tell if they are playing and/or are on a break,which in baseball is impossible to differentiate,for me anyway.
  6. Young Gunner from Toronto, Canada writes: I still find it really hard to believe that so called baseball fans in Toronto stopped following baseball after the Strike! A lot of people in this town have expressed a similar notion, almost as if they felt betrayed. However, hockey, Canada's claim to fame, the be all and end of all sports, takes a break, and Canadians come flooding back. No questions asked. No bitterness. No spitting at players or management types, like what happened to some TTC employees after their recent hiatus. I expected more of a backlash from hockey fans, but that didn't come. Why? Why turn your back on baseball, and not on hockey? The NHL and it's Canadian fans are a lot like the castaways on the show 'Lost': incredibly short memory and lousy, 'big-pictureless' leadership.
  7. Michael Enright from Toronto, Canada writes: We need a northern end-zone section and a re-design of the south to accommodate more fans. 30,000 is a good attendance number.
  8. Random Person from Heard and Mc Donald Islands writes: And grass turf....
  9. Dave Hunt from Canada writes: Michael Enright: WE NEED REAL GRASS BEFORE ANYTHING ELSE. PRO SOCCER IS NOT MEANT TO BE PLAYED ON A SYNTHETIC CARPET FULL OF RUBBER PELLETS!
  10. Random Person from Heard and Mc Donald Islands writes: Why not just lay a real grass turf before each outdoor season...and then go back the artificial turf for the "indoor winter" months...
  11. Tim Swinarton from Canada writes: I hate to burst your bubble, but some of those same Blue Jay fans must come to see the Reds. I sit on an aisle in the corner and spend half of my standing time because people are marching up and down to get food or worse. Why can't people just come to the game to watch? People sitting behind me were yelling for the people in front of them to sit down because they couldn't see. To make matters worse, some of these wanderers actually stop in front of our seats to watch or wait or whatever... GO BACK TO THE DOME!
  12. Random Person from Heard and Mc Donald Islands writes: That's what the baseball crowd is all about hot dogs and pop.....

Join the Conversation, Leave a Comment

This conversation is semi-moderated What is moderation? | How do I report a comment?

You must be logged-in to submit a comment — login now!

Not registered with globeandmail.com? Register now. It is quick and free.

close

Alert us about this comment

Please let us know if this reader’s comment breaks the editor's rules and is obscene, abusive, threatening, unlawful, harassing, defamatory, profane or racially offensive by selecting the appropriate option to describe the problem.

Do not use this to complain about comments that don’t break the rules, for example those comments that you disagree with or contain spelling errors or multiple postings.

Back to On Soccer

Back to top