Skip navigation

 Login or Register | Member Centre

Blair: The good and bad of standing pat


My initial reaction upon discovering that the Canada's Sports Hall of Fame was going to induct Pat Gillick this year was the same as my reaction when I found out that we members of the Baseball Writers Association of America were going to elect Peter Gammons a few years ago: Eh? He's not already in there?
Gillick deserves recognition for more than merely being part of a management team that brought back to back World Series to Canada. Considering the Montreal Expos had a head-start on the Toronto Blue Jays, it was remarkable how quickly the Blue Jays brand spread across the country and essentially over-ran that of the Expos. For a while, it was practically impossible to go to a baseball banquet anywhere in this country without seeing somebody from the Blue Jays. Or hearing a telegram of congratulations read out from the Blue Jays. Or seeing an autographed Blue Jays bat being auctioned off. Rare is the American who exhibits an understanding of Canadian sensibilities. Gillick was - and is - one of those. It's true that the Blue Jays never managed to translate that brand recognition into an ability to unearth Canadian talent - Eric Gagne ... Russell Martin ... Justin Morneau ... Joey Votto ... whoever, the Blue Jays never seemed to be able to land a good Canadian without trading for him - but it was apparent that in the early days, at least, the emphasis was on developing the game across the country. The current crop of Canadian-born players likely wouldn't be as deep without the influence - accidental or otherwise - of the Blue Jays.
Indeed, Gillick's legacy - which includes stops with the Baltimore Orioles, Seattle Mariners and now Philadelphia Phillies - is such that even today the wishful thinkers say only he can turn around the current edition of the Blue Jays, which would be accurate were it not for the fact that indications are Gillick is looking to scale down his daily involvement in the game. Still, it's remarkable how a guy once derided with the nickname 'Stand Pat' suddenly became an agent of change.
Which gives us a segue into ....
Your 2008 Blue Jays!
It's nice that G.M. J.P. Ricciardi is saying publicly that this he's pretty much done with player moves. Even nicer knowing he'll forgive me if I tell him I don't believe him. I understand Ricciardi's thinking: you aren't going to be able to trade for another Vernon Wells. And I also understand his reluctance to move a starting pitcher, especially if all it's going to do is give him somebody else's over-paid dray horse (Adam Dunn? Yeah, he'll help the Blue Jays! The fact that failed Mets G.M. turned ESPN drone Steve Phillips has run the idea up the flag pole ought to be good enough to rubbish it. Barry Bonds? Sure. I'm all about that! Three weeks of playing in the minors and he should be good to go ... if he can get across the border.) But let's take a step back for a moment and look at the Blue Jays as they broke spring training. They were shy of lefthanded hitting. They did not - and do not - have an everyday shortstop either in the person of John McDonald or David Eckstein. (Sorry, all you grit-meisters.) And they did not - and do not - have an everyday catcher.

At best, they were cutting and pasting to fill those two positions at a time when a $100 million payroll doesn't guarantee you much beyond being middle of the pack. In other words, there were issues with the construction of this team long before everybody stopped hitting. Those issues still must be addressed because the short-term - and likely mid-term - answers are not down on the farm. Travis Snider? Call me suspicious, but I'd feel better about him helping out in 09 if he had two healthy elbows.
Beyond that, am I the only one concerned that even when he's back after eight weeks Wells ... well, you know, that he might not be able to hit with power for awhile? I won't use the word 'ever,' because that's a long time. But I have seen guys come back from fractured wrists or hands and not hit with as much authority. So there you go: the Blue Jays need two more every day players. Good, athletic players. Not slow, old guys. If that means moving a pitcher? So be it, and ideally that bridge should be crossed long before it's time to wonder how much longer Roy Halladay is going to be happy staying here beyond the expiration of his contract ....

  1. Luke P from Vancouver, Canada writes: Looking at everyday catchers, I only see Gerald Laird and AJ Pierzynski as vets who would be available. I'm sure the Angels would be willing to part with one of their two youngsters (Mike Napoli or Jeff Mathis), but neither of those guys have yet shown the ability to carry the load. Kenji Johjima might be available, since he's been struggling and the M's have given Jeff Clement some time at catcher (that said, Clement's hitting .162).

    Other than that, there isn't much in the way of catchers available that would be a significant upgrade here.

    It's even worse at short - I can't find a single team who I think would be a logical trade partner for a shortstop.
  2. A Realist from Canada writes: One can argue if Ricciardi's moves have been good, bad, or neutral, but what is not arguable is the dearth of major league ready position players in the Jays farm system. Was that not Ricciardi's primary stated goal when he was brought here?

    The Jays lose a couple of SSs and an OF to injury and the best he can do is bring up a career minor leaguer SS and get a couple of retread OFs?

    I was a JP backer because he said all the right things, but have to admit his performance is about as good as the Jays offense.
  3. Randall Gray from Vancouver, Canada writes: Wholeheartly agree with your analysis of the Jay's weak points; (hitting) shortstop, catcher and some serious bats (esp. for average) are definitely on the wish list. Also agree that the MBA offers rather slim pickings. Have the Jays ever shopped in Japan? Korea?

  4. Randall Gray from Vancouver, Canada writes: MBA? where'd that come from? MLB obviously.
  5. E N from Toronto, Canada writes: How is Zaun not performinng offensively? The average AL catcher has a 713 OPS this year, same as last year. Zaun is at 732 this year, so even though he's down from what he's capable of (prolly around 750), he's still above average.
  6. John S from coupdaville, Canada writes: I was always okay with Zaun offensively and management seems to really like the way he calls a game. Defensively I'm thinking Frank Thomas will attempt his first steal next time Jays and A's play - just to make a point (or two). Even money who wins that one. I think the Jays got a break last year when Barajas bolted on them. I also cant get why he's here now. Hell, Thigpen would've been way ahead of the game if they'd have given him the backup position in spring training.
    As for shortstop, go figure why, after signing Johnnie Mac, JP brings in Eckstein. I'll never be convinced that Macdonald wouldnt have been a much better full time shortstop. As it is with both sharing time there, no one has a chance to slot in. You have to come to the inevitable conclusion that JP's grasping at straws and that Johnnie Mac (like Reed Johnson) will end up paying for it.

Join the Conversation, Leave a Comment

This conversation is semi-moderated What is moderation? | How do I report a comment?

You must be logged-in to submit a comment — login now!

Not registered with globeandmail.com? Register now. It is quick and free.

close

Alert us about this comment

Please let us know if this reader’s comment breaks the editor's rules and is obscene, abusive, threatening, unlawful, harassing, defamatory, profane or racially offensive by selecting the appropriate option to describe the problem.

Do not use this to complain about comments that don’t break the rules, for example those comments that you disagree with or contain spelling errors or multiple postings.

Back to Globe on Baseball

Globe on Baseball

Jeff Blair has been writing about baseball since 1989 and has been covering baseball for The Globe and Mail since joining the paper in 1997. This is where he will present news, views and analysis about baseball, focusing mostly (although not exclusively) on the Toronto Blue Jays. Robert MacLeod, a Globe and Mail reporter for close to 30 years, is turning his attention to coverage of the Toronto Blue Jays and Major League Baseball after eight years following the trials and tribulations of the Toronto Raptors.

Blogroll

Latest Blog Posts

Market Blog 
At the open: Don't bank on it
From Deep  
Newspapers 101
Blogolitics 
Headlines Of The Week
Globe on Baseball 
MacLeod: Burnett Sits And Savors
Number Cruncher 
Seeing opportunity in energy-exposed small caps
Streetwise 
Gluskin Sheff deepens team, plans succession
Theatre 
Summerworks: A playwright pillow fight
The Office 
How to bring Feng Shui into the office
Kapica's Cyberia 
How to print money in broadcasting
On Soccer  
Knight: The ball that decided it all

Back to top