Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content



As art flies off the walls at Art Basel, buyers beware, experts warn

The ranks of art buyers have swelled in recent years, but art’s one-of-a-kind nature can make it a tricky investment

Lisa Schiff, a New York-based art advisor, looks at the artwork “Rob Pruitt’s Official Art World/Celebrity Look-Alikes from 2016/2017” by U.S. artist Rob Pruitt at the Unlimited exhibition during Art Basel in Basel, Switzerland on June 13, 2017.

“When did so many people start caring about contemporary art?” wondered Marc Glimcher, head of the Pace gallery empire, as he busily made deals at Art Basel’s VIP preview this week.

With 291 galleries from 35 countries presenting 4,000 artists’ works, the world’s most prestigious art fair is as much a place to hobnob as it is to buy and sell an estimated 2.5 billion to 3 billion euros ($2.8-3.4 billion) of art.

This year’s fair — hard on the heels of a $110.5 million sale of a Jean-Michel Basquiat painting at a Sotheby’s auction in New York — got off to a fast clip, dispelling a sombre market mood last year.

At the Levy Gorvy booth, a collector snatched up a small Joan Miro on paper while the gallery’s co-founder and former Christie’s chairman Brett Gorvy showed another potential buyer a nearby work.

The artwork “Crisis X” (1982) by U.S. artist Jean-Michel Basquiat is on display at the international art show Art Basel.

A large painting from the late German artist Sigmar Polke’s flamingo and heron series, which caught the eyes of four buyers, sold for around $12 million, while a $32 million Basquiat attracted museum curators and dealers.

“I always said I won’t leave in a downturn or when the market is riding a rocket to the top,” said top dealmaker Gorvy on his departure from Christie’s in December to join forces with dealer Dominique Levy.

“It feels like there’s a nice steady rise.”

With mid-market prices ranging from $50,000 to $1 million, art deals represent “large and infrequent purchases” even among the world’s growing population of millionaires, art economist Clare McAndrew said.

In the first market report commissioned by UBS and Art Basel, she estimated art sales hit $56.6 billion last year, with the rich eager to place cash at a time of low financial returns.

A couple takes a close look at the artwork “Monochrome Yellow” (2017) by British artist Sir Anish Kapoor at the Kamel Mennour gallery’s stand during the preview day of Art Basel on June 13, 2017.

“I don’t know whether art is already an asset class,” Juerg Zeltner, head of international wealth management at Swiss bank UBS, told journalists at the fair.

“The only thing I do know is that money is worth less. Given the central bank interventions, it does look to me that a lot of private investors are looking to also invest money in art.”

But that poses pitfalls for buyers whose ranks have swelled from several dozen serious collectors to millions of active buyers in recent years.

Mark Andersen, a UBS asset allocation expert, said art’s one-of-a-kind nature makes it nearly impossible to treat as a traditional investment, lacking the predictability and standardised metrics that forecasting requires.

“The phenomenon of people not being well advised and thinking they’re going to get into the art market and buy a hot artist to make money historically doesn’t end very well,” Citi private bank’s art advisory and finance head Suzanne Gyorgy said.

Visitors look at Otto Piene’s “Blue Star Linz” and Secundino Hernandez’s “Four Seasons, Between Summer and Fall” during the press preview for Art Basel at Basel Messe.


In the Art Basel Unlimited section for video and museum-scale works, U.S. artist Rob Pruitt filled a room with images matching art world figures with their celebrity look-alikes.

Art adviser Lisa Schiff, who arranged the purchase of the work on behalf of one of her clients on the fair’s opening morning, said she was seeing a changed mindset from buyers at this year’s fair.

“The habit of the last 15 years of buying voraciously is finito,” Schiff said. “People are getting exhausted by this complete addiction to auction estimates and auction prices… Value is when you build something and you believe in it.”

But art mavens remain wary of speculative buying at a time when the world’s wealthy, waylaid by political and economic uncertainty, are eager to place cash.

A woman takes pictures from “Notes Drawn by a Negress After a Long Absence” from 2016 by U.S. artist Kara Walker during Art Basel.

Speculation had transformed the industry from one driven by art to one fuelled by finance, Galerie Gmurzynska’s Mathias Rastorfer said.

“If you’re selling for a lot of money, without critical acclaim, without peer recognition and without curatorial accompaniment, you’re still successful because you’re selling well,” Rastorfer said, adding that the phenomenon was slowly beginning to correct.

For Glimcher, who spends 14 days a month on airplanes jetting between gallery spaces spread from Hong Kong and Seoul to London and Palo Alto, a busy schedule is testament to the limited scope for scaling up an art business.

“It’s not possible to truly corporatise this business, which is built on relationships and interpersonal interactions,” he said. “That’s why we have these art fairs.”

Report Typo/Error

Next story