Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Was Brian Linehan right to want a star system in Canada?

"I ought to punch you right in the nose," said Brian Linehan the first time I met him.

A celebrated broadcast interviewer from the seventies until his death in 2004, Linehan was not known for being confrontational. Widely admired for his deep-dish knowledge of the movies and loquacious interviewing style, he was often as famous as his celebrity guests, as the title of his biography, Starring Brian Linehan, suggests.

His threat came in response to a question: Why would he want to be host of the Genies? At the time, I was young and thought everyone knew awards shows were a crock. The Oscars too often rewarded schmaltz over genius (Robert Altman, Howard Hawks and Alfred Hitchcock won consolation awards). In the seventies, serious artists such as George C. Scott, Marlon Brando and Woody Allen shunned the event. From another perspective, though, these events are the apotheosis of a celebrity- and movie-loving culture.

Story continues below advertisement

From Linehan's point of view, it was an insult to even ask him such a question, after all his years of support for Canadian film artists and love of the movies. After more talk and many more coffees (no refills, fresh cups), he warmed up. Somehow, after the rough start, that half-hour interview stretched into six hours of movie talk.

Linehan continued to support Canadian talent even after his death in 2004, when his estate became the Brian Linehan Charitable Foundation, which trustee Michael Levine says promotes Linehan's legacy as an interviewer and continues his "quest for a star system in Canada."

Starting this week, in a co-venture with the Toronto International Film Festival and the National Screen Institute, the charity's website is releasing about 50 of Linehan's interviews online ( Only about five of the 33 subjects so far are Canadian (and two of those – Anne Murray and Burton Cummings – are musicians), but they're an enjoyable flash from the past. The Linehan foundation has also donated hundreds of thousands of dollars in the last few years to Hot Docs, TIFF and various film and theatre programs to foster Canadian young talent.

It's the phrase "star system" that I stumble on. In the basic sense, I suppose, it means a training system for work in movies. Yet the term is inextricably tied to the classic Hollywood studio factory model of the 1920s to 1940s, in which actors were often groomed, given new names and even fictitious backgrounds, then marketed more on glamour that talent. Hollywood was the American Dream in a hurry: One day you're in a drug store in a clingy sweater, the next you're an adored celebrity. It was part of the illusion machine, and as actors fought for more freedom from the 1940s on, the system collapsed.

In the wake of classic Hollywood, the American movies still often operate on a celebrity-focused studio system. As screenwriting sage William Goldman has pointed out, top stars routinely bring in their own writers to boost their roles and ruin good scripts. It's not much of a model for anyone else. In the relatively tiny English-Canadian cinema niche (about 1 per cent of domestic box office) it makes more sense to support imaginative directors and versatile actors that bring strong stories to life – stars might emerge, but let's not get it backward.

I don't know if Brian Linehan believed there could be a glamorous, star-studded Canadian movie industry, though it's been one of those questions that's been circling around English-Canadian film for years: Where is our star system? I think we already know the answer. The pull of a superior gravity force has dragged it south. You want Canadian stars? Go to the multiplex: There's Rachel McAdams in The Vow and Ryan Reynolds in Safe House, the No. 1 and 2 films at the North American box office.


Story continues below advertisement

Act of Valor

The gimmick here is that real U.S. Navy Seals are used in this custom-built drama about the rescue of a kidnapped CIA agent.


Could it be the Canadian Slapshot at last? Jay Baruchel wrote the script and Michael Dowse directs this story of the outcast of a brainy family (Sean William Scott) who becomes a successful hockey enforcer.

The Flowers of War

The first Chinese movie with a major Western star, Yimou Zhang's tale of the Nanking invasion by the Japanese features Christian Bale as a dissolute Westerner who helps protect prostitutes and school girls from the occupiers.

Story continues below advertisement


Woody Harrelson has already earned major kudos for this story of a dirty L.A. cop facing the consequences of his action in this film directed by Owen Moverman ( The Messenger) and co-written by James Ellroy ( L.A. Confidential).


David Wain ( Role Models) directs this comedy about a couple (Jennifer Aniston and Paul Rudd) who lose their New York jobs and decide to start over on a commune.

Report an error Editorial code of conduct Licensing Options
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to