Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Superman Week: Why Superman Returns was a superhero fail

Brandon Routh’s mopey performance in Superman Returns earned him the title of the first emo Superman.

With Man of Steel opening on Friday, Dave McGinn examines what the early Superman movies can teach us about the superhero genre, for better or for worse. Today's instalment: the failed reboot of Superman Returns. (Budget: $232-million. U.S. gross: $200,120,000).

Uninspired casting

Brandon Routh was a relative unknown when he was cast to wear the red briefs. It was going to be next to impossible to fill Christopher Reeve's red boots, and Routh, whose biggest prior role was on the soap opera One Life to Live, hardly excited fans.

Story continues below advertisement

Finding emo

Routh's mopey performance earned him the title of the first emo Superman. You know what's the lamest thing you could call a superhero? That's right, emo.

Bad guy redux

After featuring Lex Luthor in three of the four previous Superman movies, the filmmakers decided the villain in the reboot would be … Lex Luthor. And Kevin Spacey was no Gene Hackman, my friends. In fact, almost everything about the movie felt like a second-rate retread.

Reverence for imagery

Supes catching the car was a nifty homage to the cover of Action Comics #1, but while director Bryan Singer had a great grasp of the canon's imagery, he didn't understand what makes Superman so exciting and inspiring.

A not-so-dastardly plot

Story continues below advertisement

Luthor is going to use Kryptonian crystals to build a giant new land mass? Because what kids and adults who love action really thrill to see is a ripping good real-estate yarn.


It still makes me shudder, so let's not talk about the choice to introduce Superboy, okay?

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author

Dave McGinn writes about fitness trends for the Life section and also reports for Globe Arts. Prior to joining the Globe, he was a freelance journalist, covering topics from trying to eat Michael Phelps' diet to why the Joker is the best villain in comics history. He's working on improving his 10k time. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨