Skip to main content
theatre review
Open this photo in gallery:

Daren A. Herbert as Harold Hill in The Music Man.Cylla von Tiedemann

  • The Music Man
  • Book, music and lyrics by: Meredith Willson
  • Directed by: Donna Feore
  • Starring: Daren A. Herbert and Danielle Wade
  • At the Festival Theatre in Stratford, Ont.


3 out of 4 stars

If you’re looking for a night of entertainment to take your mind off any contemporary troubles with a capital T – say, an unsettling bomb threat against a Shakespearean theatre company − march on over to The Music Man at the Stratford Festival.

Director and choreographer Donna Feore’s production of Meredith Willson’s musical set in 1912 Iowa had the audience on its feet before the first act had even finished, when a corps of 10 dancers playing River City teens delivered a highly athletic, amped-up routine to accompany Seventy-Six Trombones in front of Daren A. Herbert’s suave Professor Harold Hill.

I haven’t seen a show-stopping standing O in Stratford’s Festival Theatre since, well, Feore’s production of Fiddler on the Roof, also at the end of a highly athletic, amped-up dance routine. Why mess with success?

It is true the crowd at opening night of The Music Man on Tuesday was very eager to have a good time just one day after what should have been the season opening performance, The Tempest starring 80-year-old Stratford legend Martha Henry as Prospero, was cancelled on the same famous thrust stage when local police received a vague threat against the festival.

Open this photo in gallery:

From left: George Krissa, Robert Markus, Sayer Roberts and Marcus Nance in The Music Man.Cylla von Tiedemann

Even the pre-show singing of the national anthem ended in cheers from a crowd that had passed a low-key police presence and purse checks by private security on their way into the Festival Theatre to see what may be the most anodyne American musical of all time.

The strongest aspect of Feore’s production is Danielle Wade’s performance as Marian Paroo, the librarian who quickly realizes that the travelling band-equipment salesman Harold Hill is a con artist, but comes to love him anyway as she observes the positive effects of his enthusiasm for art on the small-minded population of 1912 River City, Iowa.

Wade, who won CBC’s Over the Rainbow reality-TV competition to star in The Wizard of Oz in Toronto in 2012, has developed some serious stage presence in the ensuing years. She’s equal parts fierce and sweet as a woman deemed an “old maid” at 26 standing up proudly in the face of gossip about her sex life and her advocacy for what locals have deemed “dirty books” (by Chaucer, Rabelais and Balzac).

Feore’s production likewise shines new light on the subplot involving Eulalie Shinn – a very funny and surprisingly powerful Blythe Wilson – slowly but surely standing up to her husband, Mayor Shinn (the always-wonderful Steve Ross).

Open this photo in gallery:

As usual, director Donna Feore’s energetic choreography is a major draw.Cylla von Tiedemann

This is a trademark of the director’s work at Stratford – subtly reinvigorating the female leads in classic musicals and giving heft to their emotional journeys. So too is her deft hand with child actors, in this case Alexander Elliot as Winthrop Paroo, Marian’s lisping younger brother; and Sarah DaSilva as the girl next door, Amaryllis. A scene between these two kids is the most complex in the show.

But unlike Feore’s smart take on The Sound of Music a few years ago – which made a solid case that it is the greatest Rodgers and Hammerstein musical, not merely the most popular – there’s not as much complexity to find in The Music Man.

You can’t make too sophisticated the gender politics of a show in which the big dance number in the second act, Shipoopi, is to a song in praise of women who wait to kiss until the third date. (Harold Hill’s follow-up song, The Sadder-but-Wiser Girl For Me, isn’t much of a rebuttal.)

It’s always a bit strange to remember that Willson’s nostalgic musical arrived on Broadway in the same season as West Side Story. Best to view it simply as fantasy – especially in an essentially colour-blind production such as this one that could otherwise be seen as serious American historical revisionism.

Open this photo in gallery:

The strongest aspect of Feore’s production is Danielle Wade’s performance as Marian Paroo.Cylla von Tiedemann

The Music Man is a triumph of musical-comedy craft, certainly, from the opening number Rock Island, “rapped” by salesmen on a train to River City, to the brilliant way Marian’s Goodnight My Someone and Harold’s Seventy-Six Trombones give us a heroine and hero singing the same tune, just needing their tempos and time signatures to sync up to realize it.

As for Herbert’s Hill, I was impressed by the salesmanship in his patter songs, the fresh and funny gospel howls he brought to Ya Got Trouble and the groovy curlicues in his choreography that suggest the professor may have run into the ancestors of the Jackson family when he was studying in Gary, Ind. (A few months after The Music Man won the Tony for Best Musical in 1958, Michael Jackson was born in Gary.)

But Herbert sometimes seemed to be playing more to the offstage audience than connecting with the other characters onstage.

As usual, Feore’s energetic choreography is a major draw – but it doesn’t always feel entirely integrated here.​ The Seventy-Six Trombones number – featuring high jumps, dizzying spins, back flips – was definitely thrilling to watch, but felt more like something out of Bring It On than The Music Man. If the teens in this town are already this liberated, what exactly has Hill brought to River City?

The Music Man ( continues to Nov. 3.

Follow related authors and topics

Authors and topics you follow will be added to your personal news feed in Following.

Interact with The Globe