Skip to main content

Ex-Ontario PC leadership hopeful Granic Allen under fire for online comments on Muslims

Tanya Granic Allen participates in a debate in Ottawa on Feb. 28, 2018.

Justin Tang/The Canadian Press

Former Ontario Tory leadership hopeful Tanya Granic Allen, who is now seeking a party nomination ahead of a spring provincial election, is defending herself after coming under fire for comments made online years ago about Muslims and gay marriage.

Ms. Granic Allen, a parental-rights and anti-abortion advocate, denied on Tuesday that posts and tweets in which she suggests gay marriage shouldn’t be legalized in Britain and says women should not wear burqas in public reflect Islamophobic or homophobic views.

“My concern … has always been about the freedom of religion, the freedom of conscience and freedom of expression and protecting those very important rights, which is why I opposed the banning of the niqab even though I personally take issue with it,” she told The Canadian Press.

Story continues below advertisement

Her online comments, which date back to 2013 and 2014, were condemned by the Liberals and New Democrats, who said it would be up to Tory Leader Doug Ford to decide whether he wants someone with those beliefs as a candidate.

Mr. Ford, meanwhile, said only that the sentiments expressed by Ms. Granic Allen, who is seeking to run in the Toronto-area riding of Mississauga Centre, do not reflect his views or those of the party.

“Our base is growing, and we want all Ontarians to feel like they have a place in our party,” he said in a statement.

Mr. Ford and Ms. Granic Allen were considered the more socially conservative candidates in the Tory leadership race and Ms. Granic Allen was the only one to appear by Mr. Ford’s side as he was declared the winner in March.

In a 2013 post discussing Quebec’s controversial and ultimately unsuccessful proposal for a charter of values, Ms. Granic Allen described niqabs and burqas as “masks” that cover the face.

“I don’t believe people should dress like ninjas when going for an afternoon stroll. I don’t believe that people should dress like bank robbers when going to vote,” she said. “My daughter loves wearing a spider-man mask, but I forbid her from wearing it out in public.”

In another case, she linked to a news story about an attack on two teenage girls in Zanzibar, calling it “yet another reason not to vacation in a Muslim country.”

Story continues below advertisement

Ms. Granic Allen said on Tuesday that she was voicing concerns about travelling to countries in which there have been terrorist attacks, but not advocating against visiting Muslim countries specifically.

“I didn’t say people shouldn’t [go], I just said it’s perhaps a reason not to,” she said, adding that she wants to visit Egypt and see the pyramids.

She also denied that a tweet in which she wished the Queen would not allow gay marriage meant she opposed the practice. “Somebody wrote that gay marriage would force the Queen to break her oath and I simply said, ‘Well the Queen should keep her oath,’ because we should not lie,” she said.

Another tweet in which Ms. Granic Allen expressed shock that Malta had passed a law allowing gay marriage and adoption “wasn’t anything pro or con,” she said, simply an observation on how quickly the country had acted on the issue.

Ms. Granic Allen would not, however, clarify whether she supports gay marriage, saying it is a federal issue. “It has nothing to do with this election and I don’t need to comment on that,” she said.

Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne and NDP Leader Andrea Horwath said such comments are unacceptable.

Story continues below advertisement

“The Conservatives will have to decide … how they will go forward, but that kind of behaviour, that kind of language, that kind of attitude I believe has no place in our society,” Ms. Wynne said.

Ms. Horwath said it was disappointing to see someone with views “that can be described as racist and homophobic” seeking public office.

“It’s certainly not something that I would be condoning as leader of my party,” she said.

Helen Kennedy, executive director of the LGBT rights advocacy group Egale, said Ms. Granic Allen’s statements were “very alarming,” but not surprising given some of the opinions Ms. Granic Allen voiced during the leadership campaign.

This kind of speech “does a huge amount of harm, not only to the LGBT community, obviously, but she’s targeting other communities as well,” she said.

Ms. Kennedy said that kind of “ignorant rhetoric” is exactly why children should be taught about inclusion and acceptance – topics included in the sex-education curriculum that Ms. Granic Allen vehemently opposes and has lobbied to repeal.

After his tumultuous win as leader of the Ontario Progressive Conservative Party, Doug Ford sets out to begin his campaign before the provincial election on June 7, 2018.
Report an error
Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons or for abuse. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Due to technical reasons, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this fixed soon. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback@globeandmail.com. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters@globeandmail.com.