We have three vehicles (well, four counting the motorcycle), all gently aging, a bit silly for two (also gently aging) drivers. We’ve always had sedans with a bit of a sporting bias. I’m thinking of swapping two of those cars for one, more sporting sedan. Any thoughts on a car for us in the $30,000 to $35,000 area? – Larry
Gentile: Hi Larry! One of my favourites is the Honda Civic Type R.
Richardson: You’re kidding, right? First off, it’s around $41,000 before taxes – way over his budget.
Gentile: Don’t be a penny pincher. It’s only a few thousand more.
Richardson: But that awful design with the massive, rear-wing spoiler – it’s ugly and way over the top. A friend of mine owns a Civic Type R and he says the only people he impresses are teenage boys.
Gentile: Maybe it’s just too young and hip for you. At least the design is different from anything else on the road. And I like the ride and handling. It’s fun to drive, and it’s the fastest Civic money can buy.
Richardson: Sure, it’s got a great engine, with a 306 horsepower, turbocharged 2.0-litre and a six-speed manual transmission, but my buddy couldn’t even buy replacement tires for it at his local Honda store. More trouble than it’s worth for Larry.
Gentile: Okay already! What do you think Larry should consider?
Richardson: For my money, you can’t beat a VW GTI. Not too flash but plenty quick, and only driveable with a stick. Hey – I’m a poet!
Gentile: Nothing beats a stick.
Richardson: Drive it fast or drive it slow – shift it smooth, or heel-and-toe. I’m on a roll here …
Gentile: Enough already! Don’t quit your day job.
Richardson: Harrumph. What do you think of the GTI?
Gentile: I hate to agree with you. But I like it, too. That would be my second pick – it’s sporty, quick, nimble and fun to drive.
Richardson: You also get a lot of sport for not so much money, at just less than $31,000 before taxes.
Gentile: Like I said, I hate to agree with you, but the GTI is well priced for the package.
Richardson: Larry says he has a motorcycle, so it’s safe to assume he’s happy driving a manual transmission because just about every bike has a manual clutch. But he might not want a stick. What do you think for something sporty with an automatic transmission?
Gentile: There’s the Subaru WRX – it has a great, turbocharged Subaru Boxer engine with 268 hp and all wheel drive. It comes with a six-speed stick or an optional CVT. But I’m not a big fan of the CVT. I prefer the six-speed manual. You?
Richardson: A sporty car like this is usually best with a manual; it’s only when they get to be really quick that you value the electronic fast-shifting of an automatic or dual-clutch transmission. The stick shift just helps the driver feel more in tune with the vehicle.
Gentile: Well, if we forget about silly automatics, there’s also the Ford Focus ST – that’s in Larry’s budget. It’s a sporty little hatch with a 2.0-litre EcoBoost four-cylinder with 252 hp. It only comes with a six-speed manual. But it’s a nice shifter, with quick, short throws.
Richardson: If he’s interested, he’d better get it while he still can.
Gentile: Yes – the Focus ST could become a collector’s model one day. It’s being phased out with Ford’s massive restructuring plan that shifts from building cars to SUVs and trucks.
Richardson: Well, if he can buy only one, my safe money would be for the VW GTI. Very satisfying, reliable, and sturdy. There’s a reason Europeans love it so much.
Gentile: I disagree. I think Larry should bite the bullet and pay a little more for the Honda Civic Type R. Never stop being a boy racer!
What car should you buy? Write to Mark and Petrina at firstname.lastname@example.org
Stay on top of all our Drive stories. We have a Drive newsletter covering car reviews, innovative new cars and the ups and downs of everyday driving. Sign up for the weekly Drive newsletter, delivered to your inbox for free. Follow us on Instagram, @globedrive.