Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Think you know which drivers are safest? The answer may surprise you

We're all too familiar with the automotive stereotypes: speed demons at the wheels of Lambos, Porsches and Ferraris like to burn rubber; Volvo drivers think safety first; Hybrid motorists are tree-hugging plodders and BMW enthusiasts are, well, y'know ... less than revered.

However, a study commissioned by insurance website disputes many of these preconceptions. "Based on millions of quotes over a two-year period," it compiled some interesting data on Canadian motorists and their driving habits. Among the findings:

  • Only 5 per cent of drivers of Aston Martins have been involved in an accident, followed by Lamborghini drivers (7 per cent) and Porsche drivers (9 per cent).

"It's a surprising finding, because it's true, many of us do perceive drivers of high-end vehicles to have a somewhat heavy foot on the pedal considering all that horsepower," Natasha Carr, a spokeswoman for, said in an e-mail. "It may be that drivers of these vehicles take special care to keep these cars in mint condition and are more sensitive to the insurance costs to cover damage."

Story continues below advertisement

  • Kia led the way at the other end of the spectrum. Fifteen per cent of Kia drivers have been in a collision, followed by Ford, Hyundai, Infiniti, Lexus, Mazda and Nissan motorists, all at 14 per cent. The average accident rate for all vehicles was 13 per cent.

So why are Kias involved in more crashes? "We have observed that younger drivers tend to have the most accidents and young drivers tend to drive less expensive vehicles," said Carr.

  • Infiniti drivers are more likely to break a rule of the road – 29 per cent – compared to the national average of 22 per cent. BMW, Land Rover, Lincoln and Porsche motorists (each at 26 per cent) were also more likely to be pulled over by police.

"We didn't specifically look at the profile of the Infiniti driver but perhaps their marketing is working," said Carr. "A recent Globe article quoted Alfonso Albaisa, Infiniti's design director, as saying, 'I want to capture a kind of emotional spontaneity in the design that I don't think other auto makers have ever attempted. I want a Latin look which, to me, means romance and red-blooded sensuality.' Perhaps we can draw our own conclusions from that.

"It's also worth noting," said Carr, "that almost four times more men drive Infinitis and males tend to get more tickets and be in more accidents."

  • The best behaved motorists - the ones who obey the rules of the road and avoid tickets? Lamborghini (16 per cent) and Aston Martin (18 per cent) drivers.

"Just like the cars, perhaps drivers of these high-end vehicles are also in a class of their own; precise, controlled, and focused on the task at hand with superior handling," said Carr.

  • Fifty-three per cent of all Canadians have a clean driving record – no tickets or accidents.

But what about the stereotypical BMW driver, the motorist that everyone loves to hate?

"There's no data to prove that BMW drivers are the most unpleasant of us all," said Carr. "Perhaps a lot of us have encountered an unsafe driver of this type of car, and maybe it's more memorable because it's a high-end car."


Story continues below advertisement

If you have questions about driving or car maintenance, please contact our experts at

Follow us on Twitter @Globe_Drive.

Add us to your circles.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Correction: The quote attributed to Alfonso Albaisa in the story above was incorrectly attributed to Tim Franklin in an earlier version of this story.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Deputy Editor at Globe Drive

Darren McGee is an editor and writer for Globe Drive. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨