Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

My daughter needs a cheap car with a hands-free connection. What are the options?

what care should i buy

Looking for an inexpensive ride with some bells

The Nissan Micra, the cheapest new car in Canada, may be the best choice – if she's willing to forgo most creature comforts

My 21-year-old daughter needs a car for work and she'll be travelling on Highway 401 across Toronto to get to her job. What would be the best car for her for less than $20,000, taking into account the seasons and traffic? Air-conditioning is essential and a hands-free connection is also a must. All other creature comforts are not important. – Richard

Mark Richardson: Despite what the ads let you believe, there are only a handful of cars that can be bought new for less than $20,000 out-the-door, which is after all taxes, freight and PDI is added on. Cars cost money, and if you want an automatic and air-conditioning, that's usually on top of the lowest prices.

Jessica Leeder: We're looking at a small pool here to get both hands-free smartphone integration and air conditioning (which Richard's daughter definitely wants if she sticks with that cross-401 commute each day). Budget forces us to cross the Honda Fit and Toyota Yaris off the list. We're left with five real options: the Hyundai Accent (LE Auto), Mitsubishi Mirage ES Automatic (sad face), the Kia Rio LX+ in manual, Chevrolet Spark 1LT, or Mark's personal favourite, the Nissan Micra.

Story continues below advertisement

Hyundai Accent.

Richardson: Yep, I like that Micra. And, as the parent of a 20 year old myself, I like Richard's comment about creature comforts for his kid not being important – I wonder if his daughter agrees? I like the Micra because it's comfortable and reliable and the base edition handles as well as the loaded edition.

Leeder: And it's the cheapest new car in Canada.

Richardson: The base "S" edition lists for $9,988, but that's really just to get you in the store. Few Micra buyers buy that trim, which has a manual transmission, no air-conditioning and manual window winders. And remember, it's not worth much at resale time with no air and a stick. Richard can get the "S" with automatic and air for $13,598, and Nissan's giving a rebate of $1,750, which negates the Freight and PDI. Taxes in, it'll be about $15,500 out the door.

Nissan Micra.

Leeder: You really are a cheapskate, aren't you? That doesn't include the hands-free.

Richardson: Good point, though you can buy a high-quality clip-on Bluetooth speaker for less than $200 at Canadian Tire. Or you can step up to the Micra SV that includes Bluetooth, air-conditioning, power windows and power door locks for $13,998. It's a nicer car, but that's with a stick-shift. Automatic will cost an extra $1,000. Even so, the SV with automatic will be easy to resell and comes in well under budget, including winter tires.

Leeder: Better for Richard to option up. Sure, he can buy his daughter that clip-on speaker. But they can be finicky, need to be charged and take "work" compared to an integrated Bluetooth connection. Can we talk about some other cars now? I know you're not super keen on it, but I like the Chevy Spark for the technology it offers. GM is marketing it as "The Ultimate Mobile Device." The interface is slick.

Chevrolet Spark ACTIV.

Richardson: The last Spark I drove was painted in hot metallic pink. Teenaged girls loved it, but my two boys weren't keen on being seen in it – especially with me behind the wheel. Look, there's nothing wrong with the Spark, except it feels cheap, which it is, of course. It's a fine little car for getting from A to B and it's well connected for smartphone use. It's better than the Mirage, though, which I wouldn't recommend to anyone. Again, the Mirage is a car built to a low-price budget, but is the least appealing of them all.

Story continues below advertisement

Leeder: Consumer Reports agrees. The website rated the Mirage lowest of all available subcompact cars in 2017 and described it with a serious hate-on as "roly-poly", "sluggish" and "drab". In other words: Blech. We're down to the Hyundai and Kia for a third solid option here. Honestly, it's a roll of the dice. Both are decent options, but the Spark's infotainment system is tops for the millennial driver.

Kia Rio LX.

Richardson: Or Richard could just get the Micra, which is the best of all the options. He can go super-cheap, or just fairly cheap. But take my advice, Richard – buy the car you want for her and don't let her start asking for options, or it'll add $5,000 before you know it.

Leeder: Sage parenting advice. You heard it here first.

Report an error Editorial code of conduct
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles as we switch to a new provider. We are behind schedule, but we are still working hard to bring you a new commenting system as soon as possible. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to