Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Snap, Blue Apron IPO flops undercut lofty private valuations

Blue Apron Holdings co-founder and CEO Matt Salzberg, left of centre, watches traders during the company’s IPO at the New York Stock Exchange on June 29. Before its stock’s NYSE debut, the company ended up selling its shares at less than two-thirds of its initial target price.

Michael Nagle/Bloomberg

Snap Inc. and Blue Apron Holdings Inc. have swiftly gone from two of the year's most anticipated IPOs to poster children for companies whose rich private valuations haven't withstood the scrutiny of public markets.

Investors' urgency to grab a piece of what could be the next big thing – a bet on future innovation – has helped drive up valuations of unprofitable private companies facing fierce competition. Public-market investors are showing a reluctance to reward rich market values without proof of financial health and future growth. That includes Snap and Blue Apron, both of which are trading below their initial public offering price.

It's a cautionary tale for young companies taking private funding and a potentially ominous harbinger for the private tech giants yet to list: Overshoot what public investors can stomach and risk your stock taking a beating.

Story continues below advertisement

Snap, the maker of the disappearing-photo application Snapchat, fell below its IPO price per share of $17 (U.S.) for the first time on Monday and has since continued its decline. Its market capitalization of about $18.2-billion stands in disappointing contrast to the high-end valuation target of $40-billion described by a person familiar with the matter in October.

Airbnb, Dropbox

Snap was one of the biggest unicorns – private companies valued at more than $1-billion. Having amassed sometimes billions of dollars at ever-increasing valuations, the likes of the $31-billion travel rental platform Airbnb Inc. or the $10-billion cloud-storage company Dropbox Inc. may have to give investors an exit opportunity. That will be a true test at whether those valuations stand.

A near-term IPO seems even less likely for others, namely the biggest of the unicorns, Uber Technologies Inc. The $69-billion private company is currently without a chief executive after founder Travis Kalanick resigned amid scandals involving, among other allegations, sex-discrimination and harassment claims against the ride-hailing company.

Dick Costolo, Twitter Inc.'s former CEO, said in a television interview he expects the valuation declines at the IPO stage to persist in the next two years. He predicts "lots of money in the private markets chasing few deals" and driving up prices. "When these things finally see the light of day in the retail markets, it sort of – probably rightly – turns out to be the case that these are not worth as much as their last private rounds were," said Mr. Costolo, now head of his fitness startup, Chorus.

Snap downgraded

Compounding the uncertainty, Snap doesn't issue forward-looking guidance, leaving investors and analysts guessing. On Tuesday, Snap's stock was downgraded from a buy to the equivalent of hold by analyst Brian Nowak at Morgan Stanley, the lead underwriter for the company's IPO.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Nowak slashed his share price target to $16 from $28 – a 43-per-cent cut. The rationale? The company's ad products are taking longer to improve and evolve than previously expected, he said, prompting him to cut his 2017-18 revenue forecasts by seven percentage points to 13 per cent.

Blue Apron is confronting its own rival colossus. Three days before the meal-kit delivery company's IPO, Amazon.com Inc. concussed the entire food industry with an agreement to buy Whole Foods Market Inc. for $13.7-billion.

The company's aspirational $3.2-billion valuation would have been richer than the average of U.S.-listed e-commerce companies. Emphasizing its Web-based service, it angled to be valued as a high-growth tech company rather than as a grocery-delivery service, people familiar with the matter have said.

Management's spiel fell flat with public-market investors. The New York-based company ended up selling its shares for $10 on June 28, less than two-thirds of its initial target price and the second-biggest cut for a U.S. IPO in five years. Raising $300-million, Blue Apron clocked a market value of about $1.9-billion, less than its $2-billion valuation in a 2015 private-funding round, when it had less than half the net sales it did last year.

The pain doesn't end there for Blue Apron; its disappointing IPO take may force it to seek more cash soon. Shares slipped about 24 per cent below its IPO price since the stock started trading on June 29.

One analyst expects Blue Apron to fall further. Chuck Cerankosky of Northcoast Research was the first to rate the stock, giving it a $2 price target with a sell rating, citing the company's "severe cost challenges as well as a competitive set that is broadening and intensifying."

Story continues below advertisement

"It is important to note that this is not a technology company just because orders are received digitally," he wrote in a note to clients this week. "We have no doubt that Blue Apron produces a fine product for consumers. For investors however, we think the stock is less than attractive."

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles as we switch to a new provider. We are behind schedule, but we are still working hard to bring you a new commenting system as soon as possible. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback@globeandmail.com. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters@globeandmail.com.