Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

AdChoices
Architect Martha Dorion discusses renovations with her client Louise Wickson, in her recently renovated kitchen
Architect Martha Dorion discusses renovations with her client Louise Wickson, in her recently renovated kitchen

Real Estate

Home renovation: How much to spend, and where Add to ...

To Louise Wickson and Les Horswill, the house they shared for 22 years in mid-town Toronto always felt spacious.

But when husband and wife both started working at home, the house suddenly became much, much smaller.

"We each needed offices," Ms. Wickson says. "We had to make rules of engagement about disturbing each other."

And soon enough, Ms. Wickson says, with two adults in the house 24/7, the couple acquiesced to another Canadian rite of passage: It was time to renovate.

In cities across the country, dumpsters are arriving in driveways to accommodate changing lifestyles and shifting real estate markets. In Toronto, a dearth of houses for sale and a zealous attachment to a singular street or neighbourhood have driven many homeowners to renovate the homes they already own. In Vancouver, soaring prices are pushing the traditional move-up buyer to the sidelines. And in Calgary, a correction in the housing market is causing many homeowners to call in the trades while they stay rooted in place.

While the market dynamics are different, in all three cities homeowners need to decide what the reno costs will enrich - their lives or the resale value of the property.

In the case of Ms. Wickson and Mr. Horswill, they thought about moving to a condo with a more commodious layout. But they love their verdant street, their nearby friends and the summer ritual of a backyard barbecue.

"No condo would let us have all of that."

They brought in Toronto-based architect Martha Dorion and builder Scott Harper of Harper House Contracting to turn their third floor from a family room into separate offices.

That led to reconfiguring the first floor so they could more comfortably relax and entertain in the living and dining rooms. And the kitchen that they had replaced 22 years earlier? That was still just fine, in Mr. Horswill's opinion. But the cabinet configuration did not suit the new plan for the ground floor. And besides, the kitchen was looking tired, pointed out Ms. Wickson, in persuading her more conservative husband.



The architect advises homeowners with a limited budget to invest in a well-built structure with good-quality windows and stalwart appliances instead of expensive finishes. She favours old-fashioned serveries for people who like to entertain and humble walk-in pantries for chefs who need lots of space.


Ms. Dorion, the architect, has a busy practice helping clients to see the possibilities in renovation. Indeed, she so often accompanies her clients on their house-hunting trips that she has studied to become a real estate agent and recently joined a boutique brokerage.

Ms. Dorion has watched homeowners' expectations change over the years. Even newly installed kitchens are often torn out if they don't coincide with the tastes of new owners. And many clients put additional bathrooms as the top priority.

"People grew up with one bathroom for six people," she says. "Parents don't share bathrooms with their kids any more. It's quite amazing."

Complete back-to-the-bricks renos are common as people make the rickety old housing stock more energy efficient and modern.

Ms. Dorion says renovation budgets commonly range between $300,000 for a relatively small addition and a new kitchen to $1-million for a thorough renaissance.

The architect advises homeowners with a limited budget to invest in a well-built structure with good-quality windows and stalwart appliances instead of expensive finishes. She favours old-fashioned serveries for people who like to entertain and humble walk-in pantries for chefs who need lots of space.

"It's a great way to get a lot of good storage at a really great price."

An Ipsos Reid survey conducted for Royal Bank of Canada last fall found that 55 per cent of homeowners plan to renovate or make improvements this year. The average that homeowners plan to spend is $10,064, which is an entire bathroom for some and an egg-shaped bathtub for others.

The Appraisal Institute of Canada offers an online guide which helps homeowners calculate the average return on their investment in a renovation project.

Choose "bathroom renovation" and plug in an outlay of, for example, $30,000 into the calculator and RENOVA niftily tallies a 75- to 100-per-cent return, which translates to an added $22,500 to $30,000 on the resale value of your home. Kitchens also rank well up the list with a similar 75 to 100 per cent payback.

Swimming pools, home theatre rooms and interlocking brick driveways yield only 25 to 50 per cent. The payback for installing central air conditioning ranges widely, from 25 to 75 per cent. Putting in a skylight may turn out to be a waste of cash, with the estimated return varying from zilch to 25 per cent at the most.

Builder Doug Campbell of DC Construction Ltd. believes the hectic pace of the real estate market in the Toronto area this spring is also driving the reno business. He has been on a stream of visits with real estate agents and potential purchasers who ask him to look over houses before an offer even goes in. How much will it cost to replace that antiquated knob and tube wiring, they wonder, or add a family room with a master suite above?

Report Typo/Error
Single page

Follow on Twitter: @CarolynIreland

Next story

loading

Trending

loading

Most popular videos »

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular