Stock investors are watching the dramatic moves in the Treasury market for clues on the fate of one of this year’s most successful plays – the so-called reflation trade that helped power shares of economically sensitive companies higher after nearly a decade of underperformance.
Investors piled in to shares of energy producers, banks and other companies expected to benefit from a powerful economic rebound earlier this year while betting that Treasury yields, which move inversely to prices, would rise.
That trade appears to be tottering now, as worries over slowing growth send yields tumbling to their lowest level since early 2021. While stock markets have appeared largely placid, with the S&P 500 hovering near a record high, a rotation beneath the surface has accelerated in recent weeks, as investors move out of economically sensitive names and back in to the big technology and growth stocks that led markets higher for most of the last decade.
“If we do see a further drop in interest rates, if we do get below that 1.3 per cent level in any kind of meaningful way, that is going to confirm that growth over value has returned and it is not just a head fake,” said Matt Maley, chief market strategist at Miller Tabak.
Stocks pulled back on Thursday, with the S&P 500 down more than 1 per cent in early trade.
The S&P 500 had gained 7 per cent through Wednesday since the 10-year Treasury yield hit a recent high in mid-May. A look under the hood, however, shows signs that a change in stock-market leadership may be taking place. The Russell 1000 growth index gained more than 13 per cent since mid-May while the counterpart value index climbed about 1.5 per cent over the same time.
“We do not expect the reflation and rotation trades to return to their former glory,” while materials and energy stocks will likely be held back by falling commodity prices, Oliver Allen, markets economist at Capital Economics, said in a note to clients. “The big boost to rotation from recovering risk appetite and rising growth expectations may mostly be over,” he said.
Concerns about the economic impact of the Delta variant of the coronavirus and falling commodity prices are helping push bond prices higher. At the same time, the Federal Reserve surprised many investors last month with a hawkish turn that suggested two interest rate hikes by 2023, calling into question its commitment to allowing inflation to run hot for a time.
One key question for investors is whether recent signs of rising inflation – including the latest data on existing home prices, which showed them rising by their fastest pace in 15 years in April – will be short-lived.
Federal Reserve officials last month felt further progress on the U.S. economic recovery “was generally seen as not having yet been met,” but agreed they should be poised to act if inflation or other risks materialized, minutes of the central bank’s June policy meeting showed.
“The market going into the last FOMC meeting assumed that the Fed was comfortable with an inflation overshoot, but it became clear that the magnitude of how comfortable they were with an overshoot came down considerably,” said Mike Sewell, a portfolio manager T Rowe Price, who expects that the 10-year Treasury has already hit its highest level for the year.
Stocks’ relative calm does not mean that equity investors are impervious to growth worries.
BlackRock Inc., the world’s largest asset manager, said on Wednesday in its midyear investment outlook that it cut its position in U.S. equities to neutral, in part owing to expectations that corporate profit margins will decrease.
Meanwhile, a client survey from JP Morgan showed net bearish bets against Treasuries falling to their lowest level since late April in the week to July 6, while bullish positions stood at their highest since late March, suggesting there may be limited fuel for more downside moves in yield.
“It will be interesting to see how positioning unfolds to see if there is enough of a washout to make the market cleaner and just more driven by fundamentals,” said Chuck Tomes, associate portfolio manager on the global multisector fixed income team at Manulife Investment Management.
Be smart with your money. Get the latest investing insights delivered right to your inbox three times a week, with the Globe Investor newsletter. Sign up today.