Skip to main content

While investors obsess with ‘fair value’, markets rarely find it, never mind settle there.

Markets have had good reason for dramatic and sometimes violent repricing due to serial economic shocks over the past two years - but there’s a gnawing sense of overstretch in many areas and a feeling that a lot of upheaval is already priced.

It’s always risky calling turns that never materialize, and markets routinely overshoot - or undershoot - fair values for long periods. FX markets are a great case in point - they often reflect temporary divergences between otherwise highly integrated economies, and are a magnet for huge speculative capital flows.

Look at the dollar’s parabolic rally against the yen.

The dollar has soared to a 24-year high above 144.00 yen. It has strengthened more than 25% this year - on course for its biggest annual rise ever - as U.S.-Japanese yield spreads have blown out to their widest in favor of the greenback since 2007.

Zoom out a little, and the move is even more astonishing. The dollar has strengthened more than 40% since the start of last year. Dollar/yen is a G3 currency pair, not an illiquid emerging market prone to wild and unpredictable price swings.

A reversal must surely be imminent, right? Yes, says JP Morgan analysts, but not before new highs are reached.

“If policy/rhetoric around the (Japanese) currency remains unchanged, a move toward 150 does not look impossible,” they wrote on Monday.


There have been notable moves and wide regional differences in other markets recently.

The Bloomberg Global Aggregate Bond Index has slumped as much as 24% from its peak, a record fall. The ICE BoFA U.S. Treasury Index, meanwhile, is on track for its worst annual performance on record too, but is down ‘only’ 11% this year.

The plunge in non-U.S. bonds is reflected in the spread of two-year U.S. yields over euro and UK yields. This widening gap had helped propel the dollar to a 20-year high, but it is now shrinking as European Central Bank and Bank of England rate expectations shift.

The two-year U.S.-euro zone spread has narrowed 40 basis points in the last month, and the comparable U.S.-UK spread has tightened 100 bps. If the euro and sterling do fall further against the dollar from here, it may not be by much.

“Our baseline assumption is ... that the most rapid phase of sterling underperformance is now behind us,” Goldman Sachs’s currency strategy team reckons, adding: “We see few barriers to dollar/yen continuing to press higher.”

Societe Generale’s Kit Juckes believes the euro, back below dollar parity, will remain anchored at “very low levels” for the rest of this year. “But we are not sure that we will see much lower levels.”


Europe is at the heart of many of these extreme pricing and flow divergences. Take equities.

According to Bank of America, a net 34% of fund managers were underweight euro zone equities in August. That is 2.0 standard deviations below the long-term average, and similar to July’s net 35% underweight, the most bearish position in a decade.

Investors are gloomier on euro zone equities than any other region, sector, or asset class. The only region on the global equities map where investors are bullish is the United States, with a net 10% overweight position.

Fund flows reflect the divergence. Goldman Sachs’ equity strategists note that investors have pulled money out of Western European funds for 29 straight weeks, with total redemptions of $90 billion. U.S. equity inflows in the same period are around $100 billion, and are around $300 billion since July last year.

The charts are striking.

The dim view investors have on European stocks has made them significantly cheaper. European equities’ 12-month forward P/E ratio is just above 11.5, according to Morgan Stanley, indicating that they are the cheapest since 2014.

Perhaps they may need to cheapen more before investors buy them again. Morgan Stanley sees a “plausible” risk that the P/E ratio will fall to 10.0, significantly lower than the S&P 500 P/E - it is currently 16.5, and Morgan Stanley reckons it will stay above 16.0 for the next 12 months.

“While sentiment and positioning can prompt short-term tactical bounces from time to time, the negative fundamental backdrop (in Europe) suggests that these should be viewed in the context of ‘selling the rally’ (in contrast to ‘buying the dip’),” Morgan Stanley analysts wrote on Sunday.

Both Morgan Stanley and Goldman see European stocks significantly underperforming Wall Street over the next six months before re-aligning next year.

Be smart with your money. Get the latest investing insights delivered right to your inbox three times a week, with the Globe Investor newsletter. Sign up today.