Tesla Inc. shares fell on Thursday as Wall Street wondered if demand for its mass market Model 3 sedan could be sustained while it tries to make substantial inroads in China.
Chief executive Elon Musk said he sees higher demand for the Model 3, as the electric carmaker begins to ship cars to Europe and Asia from its factory in Fremont, Calif.
“The critical Model 3 cost structure appears to be improving with both scale and manufacturing experience, with the company expecting a 25 per cent gross margin ‘at some point’ during 2019,” Canaccord Genuity analysts said.
The company estimated that Model 3 production at its Fremont plant will rise to 7,000 cars, and its Shanghai factory will build 3,000 Model 3s weekly by year’s end.
“The profitability picture for Tesla looks encouraging … with Musk & Co. giving some good granularity around projections for 2019 on the demand and production fronts, with ample cash to pay its upcoming debt payment which is around the corner,” Wedbush analysts said in a note.
But some analysts were concerned by Tesla’s indication that it is only making cars for China and Europe right now, and expects a gap of about 10,000 vehicles between production and deliveries because of vehicles in transit at the end of the first quarter.
“This is a strong indication that demand in the U.S. for both the mid-range and long-range Model 3 versions has largely been exhausted, and the company is still working through the estimated ~6.8k of unsold Model 3 inventory,” Cowen analysts said.
The company’s shares pared most of their losses to trade down 0.5 per cent at US$307.02 by the end of the day.
Tesla is pumping money into the Shanghai factory, which it aims to bring on line at the end of this year with a target of producing 500,000 vehicles annually. But several analysts questioned whether the investment would pay off.
“Tesla serves the purpose of a ‘stalking horse’ to the fast growing domestic Chinese EV industry, but we believe it has limited to zero terminal value in a region where a number of domestic champions should emerge,” Morgan Stanley analysts said.
Tesla’s weaker-than-expected fourth quarter profit, and its announcement that chief financial officer Deepak Ahuja would leave and hand over the reins to 34-year-old Zach Kirkhorn, its vice-president of finance, surprised investors, sending shares lower on Wednesday.
JPMorgan analysts warned that Mr. Ahuja’s departure deprived the company of long automotive industry experience and relative stability in a company that has seen a steady stream of senior staff come and go since 2016.
The company is striving to stabilize production and deliver consistent profit. It ended the quarter with US$4.3-billion in cash and said it had “sufficient cash on hand” to pay a US$920-million convertible bond maturing in March.
Of the 31 brokerages covering Tesla, 10 have a “buy” or higher rating, 10 “hold” and 11 have a “sell” or lower rating and their median price target is $327.50.
Only five changed their price targets on Thursday, with three raises and two cuts. Wedbush cut its price target by US$50 to US$390.