Specialized fund managers who pioneered green investing for decades are missing out on some of the spoils as the sector goes mainstream and large firms move in.
So-called sustainable funds, which pick stocks based on environmental, social or governance (ESG) criteria, are on track to take in more than US$16-billion in net new deposits this year, triple last year’s record of US$5.5-billion, according to fund tracker Morningstar Inc.
But the new money has largely gone to top asset managers such as BlackRock Inc. and Vanguard Group, which were late to the sector. BlackRock’s iShares ETF line had the most inflow, with US$3.75-billion for the nine months ended Sept. 30, with Vanguard in third place with US$2-billion of new money.
Meanwhile, several well-known socially responsible investment firms that began developing the sector as early as 1971 have had net customer withdrawals from their mutual funds this year, Morningstar found.
Those included Parnassus Investments and Pax World Funds. Another, Boston Common Asset Management, had net outflows through September but turned things around in October in its mutual funds, which account for only about 10 per cent of its assets.
The main reason for the pattern is structural: The top firms have the scale to handle big institutional deposits, often in low-cost passive funds that track indexes and do not require active stock-picking.
“We’re not getting those same kinds of flows and yes, that’s a little frustrating,” said Pax World senior vice-president Julie Gorte.
She spoke during a sustainable-investing conference in Colorado last week, The SRI Conference, which drew a record attendance of about 900 people. Sustainable investing still represents just a small fraction of the US$21-trillion U.S. mutual fund market but lately has proved popular, especially with young investors concerned about climate change and social issues.
To differentiate themselves, Gorte’s firm and others say they are better activists and press harder for corporate policy changes compared with the index shops, which do not file shareholder resolutions, rarely single out companies for attention and hold oil and gas companies widely in their portfolios.
For instance, Pax World last week refiled a shareholder proposal asking Oracle Corp. to report on gender pay equality, and Parnassus in September swore off investments in fossil fuel companies. For its part, Boston Common touts how it held talks with retailers such as Costco Wholesale Corp. and Kroger Co. on nutrition and food waste.
“That’s our core message, that we’re an advanced authentic sustainability player,” said Lauren Compere, Boston Common’s director of shareholder engagement.
BlackRock and Vanguard argue that their approach resonates with clients. “Sustainable investing has moved from a satellite allocation to the core of a portfolio for financial advisers and institutional investors,” a BlackRock spokesman said.
Vanguard executives said the firm offers a wide range of products aimed at clients with many different views and financial needs. Some may want only to have certain sectors screened out of their index funds, while others “may desire a more active approach,” spokeswoman Carolyn Wegemann said.
To be sure, Morningstar found other sustainable firms took in money this year, including Green Century Capital Management and Trillium Asset Management. They had US$35.4-million and US$16.6-million in net new deposits respectively through September, small amounts compared with the index firms.
Traditionally, socially minded funds had poorer performance. But that penalty has faded as top companies, including Apple Inc. and Walmart Inc., took steps such as using more solar power, allowing sustainable funds to invest in them and to participate in the steady rise of their stock prices.
The US$3.8-billion Parnassus Endeavor Fund, for instance, was up 29 per cent this year through Nov. 15, 2.27 percentage points better than its benchmark Russell 1000 index. Over the past five years, its total annualized return of 11.75 per cent beat 95 per cent of peer funds, according to Morningstar.
Like other active funds, however, it has had some down years, which has steered investors to passive products with more consistent performance such as the US$6.7-billion Vanguard FTSE Social Index Fund. It is up 28 per cent so far this year, 1.76 percentage points better than the benchmark Russell 1000 index. Its five-year total annualized return of 12.07 per cent beat 97 per cent of peer funds.
Parnassus chief marketing officer Joe Sinha said flows can return if markets turn choppy while managers use sustainability as a marker to pick well-run companies. Until then, his firm and rivals may face headwinds.
“We’re not immune to the trend into passive investing,” he said.