The NFT dream isn’t dead, but it’s taken a big non-fungible beating.
The market shone gloriously last year as crypto-rich speculators spent billions of dollars on the risky assets, pumping up prices and profits. Now, six months into 2022, it’s looking ugly.
Monthly sales volume on the largest NFT marketplace, OpenSea, plunged to US$700-million in June, down from US$2.6-billion in May and a far cry from January’s peak of nearly US$5-billion.
By late June, the average NFT sale sunk to US$412, from US$1,754 at the end of April, according to NonFungible.com, which tracks sales on the ethereum and ronin blockchains.
“The crypto bear market has definitely had an impact on the NFT space,” said Gauthier Zuppinger, co-founder of NonFungible.com.
“We have seen so much speculation, so much hype around this kind of asset,” he added. “Now we see some sort of decrease just because people realize they will not become a millionaire in two days.”
The NFT market has collapsed along with cryptocurrencies, which are typically used to pay for the assets, at a time when central banks have jacked up rates to combat inflation and risk appetite has withered.
Bitcoin lost around 57 per cent in the six months of the year, while ether has dropped 71 per cent.
Dip or death spiral?
For critics, the crash confirms the folly of buying such assets, tradable blockchain-based records linked to digital files such as images or videos, often artwork.
The Malaysian businessman who bought an NFT of Jack Dorsey’s first tweet for US$2.5-million last year struggled to get bids of more than a few thousand dollars when he tried to resell it in April.
But Benoit Bosc, global head of product at crypto trading firm GSR, sees the downturn as the perfect time to build a corporate NFT collection – the crypto equivalent of the fine art traditional banks display to impress clients.
Last month, GSR spent US$500,000 on NFTs from what Mr. Bosc calls “blue-chip” collections – those with large online fan bases.
His purchases include an NFT from the Bored Ape Yacht Club, a set of 10,000 cartoon monkeys made by U.S.-based company Yuga Labs and promoted by the likes of Paris Hilton and Jimmy Fallon.
Such is the hype surrounding Bored Apes that Yuga Labs raised US$285-million in April by selling tokens it says can be exchanged for land in a Bored Apes-themed virtual world it has not yet launched.
Yet the average sale price for a Bored Ape tumbled to around US$110,000 in June, having halved since its January peak of US$238,000, according to market tracker CryptoSlam.
In his New York office, Mr. Bosc put up three screens on which to display his NFTs, which include various pixelated characters and a Bored Ape bought for US$125,000.
“For us, it’s also a brand exercise,” Mr. Bosc said. Owning a valuable NFT and using it as a profile picture on social media is a way to establish “respectability, authority and influence” in the crypto sphere, he said.
Game over? Game on?
Nonetheless, the future of NFTs is distinctly uncertain, as the era of low interest rates, which encouraged investors to take risky bets, comes to an end.
Some market watchers say the influence of NFTs on the art market will shrink. Meanwhile, even though the much-hyped vision for a blockchain-based metaverse hasn’t materialized yet, enthusiasts expect NFTs to shake up the gaming industry, for example by allowing players to own in-game assets such as avatar skins.
“Everyone believes games are going to be the next big thing in blockchain,” said Modesta Masoit, chief financial officer at blockchain tracker DappRadar.
This risky combination of gaming and financial speculation may face difficulties, though. Most gamers prefer games which do not include NFTs or “play-to-earn” components, according to John Egan, chief executive of technology research firm L’Atelier.
Although the groundbreaking new crypto regulations agreed upon by the European Union last week mostly excluded NFTs, Spain is separately seeking to clamp down on the way video games sell virtual assets for real money.
Meanwhile, the biggest NFT-based game, Axie Infinity, has seen its in-game token collapse to less than half a cent, down from a peak of 36 US cents last year.
For L’Atelier’s Mr. Egan, the NFT market is unlikely to recover in its current form.
“Ultimately it’s a situation where extraordinary amounts of money are being paid for extraordinarily limited assets that don’t really produce any cash flow,” he said.
But the underlying concept of creating unique digital assets is still “fundamentally important” and will have “massive applications” for the financial sector in the future, he said.
Be smart with your money. Get the latest investing insights delivered right to your inbox three times a week, with the Globe Investor newsletter. Sign up today.