Skip to main content

Investors dream big when looking for dividends. They love large stocks with generous yields. But big isn’t always better because small dividend payers have plenty to offer.

To highlight the advantages of thinking small, it’s useful to look at past returns. A fortunate investor would have gained an average of 12.8 per cent annually by buying an equal amount of all-Canadian dividend stocks on the TSX with market capitalizations between $200-million and $2-billion over the 16 years through to the end of 2017.

By way of comparison, a portfolio with an equal amount of the relatively large dividend paying stocks in the S&P/TSX Composite Index gained 10.2 per cent annually over the same 16 years. The index itself, which is a good proxy for the Canadian stock market, averaged an annual return of 7.5 per cent over the same period.

Story continues below advertisement

(All of the returns herein include dividend reinvestment and do not include fund fees, taxes or other trading frictions. The dividend portfolios are rebalanced at the end of each year.)

The gains for the small stocks were stellar, but the ride was painful at times. When the market crashed in 2008 the S&P/TSX Composite fell 33 per cent for the year. The portfolio of large dividend stocks cushioned investors with a slightly less painful 29-per-cent drop. The small dividend stocks suffered more with a decline of 35.1 per cent. While the small stocks generated big long-term returns, they came with harsh short-term drawdowns, which some investors would find hard to stomach.

I investigated the small dividend payers in more detail by putting them through the Bloomberg back-tester. The small stocks, with a market capitalization between $200-million and $2-billion, were sorted by indicated dividend yield at the end of each year and put into five portfolios (called quintiles) containing an equal number of stocks. (The stocks were split into five groups rather than 10 because there were relatively few candidates to pick from in the early years.)

The portfolios were tracked and the results shown in the accompanying chart, which highlights the annual performance advantage offered by each group against the market index over the 16 years to the end of 2017.

For instance, the middle portfolio of medium-yielding stocks grew at a compound annual rate of 14.1 per cent and outperformed the S&P/TSX Composite Index by an average of 6.6 percentage points per year. Over the 16 years, an investment in it would have turned $100,000 into about $825,000, while an investment in the index would have grown the same amount to about $319,000.

The portfolios with the most extreme yields still beat the market but fared poorly compared with those that have more moderate yields. The small stocks with the highest yields had the worst relative showing.

Because I’m leery of stocks with extremely high dividend yields, I split the highest yield portfolio in half by yield. That is, I tracked one portfolio of stocks with the highest 10 per cent of yields (the top decile) and another portfolio that contained the next highest 10 per cent of yielding stocks. (Both contained just a handful of stocks in the early years.)

Story continues below advertisement

The small stocks with extremely high yields (the top decile) gained an average of 7.4 per cent annually over the 16 years and lagged the market index slightly. The second-highest decile fared better with average annual returns of 13.5 per cent. Incidentally, the poor performance associated with giant dividend yields isn’t limited to small stocks; in a previous column I found this applies to large dividend stocks as well.

Small dividend stocks deserve a spot in a well-diversified portfolio owing to their return potential. But treat them with caution and due consideration. Investors should be particularly careful when dealing with firms with extremely high yields.

S&P/TSX dividend payers with a market cap between $200-million and $2-billion

Company Ticker Price 10/2/18 P/E Yield
Corus Entertainment Inc. CJR-B-T $4.26 3.66 26.76%
Just Energy Group Inc. JE-T $4.33 11.41 11.55%
CanWel Building Materials Group CWX-T $5.55 10.44 10.09%
Pizza Pizza Royalty Corp. PZA-T $9.10 10.56 9.40%
Invesque Inc. IVQ-UN-T $8.15 16.88 9.04%
Medical Facilities Corp. DR-T $14.39 19.45 7.82%
Alaris Royalty Corp. AD-T $20.78 57.00 7.80%
Cardinal Energy Ltd. CJ-T $5.42 161.07 7.75%
Ensign Energy Services Inc. ESI-T $6.32 17.38 7.59%
Timbercreek Financial Corp. TF-T $9.36 14.12 7.37%
ZCL Composites Inc. ZCL-T $7.34 13.69 7.36%
MCAN Mortgage Corp. MKP-T $17.53 9.69 7.30%
Diversified Royalty Corp. DIV-T $3.09 27.49 7.20%
Firm Capital Mortgage Investment FC-T $13.23 14.00 7.07%
Gluskin Sheff + Associates Inc. GS-T $14.16 11.70 7.06%
Exchange Income Corp. EIF-T $31.50 15.10 6.95%
Dorel Industries Inc. DII-B-T $23.11 9.95 6.83%
High Liner Foods Inc. HLF-T $8.56 5.12 6.78%
Rogers Sugar Inc. RSI-T $5.47 13.86 6.58%
Atrium Mortgage Investment Corp. AI-T $13.83 15.45 6.51%
Chorus Aviation Inc. CHR-T $7.42 7.35 6.47%
Fiera Capital Corp. FSZ-T $12.46 28.08 6.42%
Peyto Exploration & Development PEY-T $11.29 10.73 6.38%
First National Financial Corp. FN-T $29.05 9.49 6.37%
Extendicare Inc. EXE-T $7.65 27.02 6.27%
Bonterra Energy Corp. BNE-T $19.17 35.41 6.26%
AKITA Drilling Ltd. AKT-A-T $5.57 n/a 6.10%
Acadian Timber Corp. ADN-T $18.55 18.06 6.09%
Laurentian Bank of Canada LB-T $42.35 7.18 6.04%
Gamehost Inc. GH-T $11.50 15.97 6.00%
Valener Inc. VNR-T $19.37 12.17 5.99%
Freehold Royalties Ltd. FRU-T $11.03 n/a 5.71%
Russel Metals Inc. RUS-T $27.18 10.00 5.59%
Caribbean Utilities Co. Ltd. CUP-UN-T $13.00 19.47 5.38%
Sienna Senior Living Inc. SIA-T $17.31 37.68 5.30%
AGF Management Ltd. AGF-B-T $6.07 7.74 5.27%
Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. INE-T $12.91 58.33 5.27%
High Arctic Energy Services Inc. HWO-T $4.05 17.97 4.89%
Reitmans Canada Ltd. RET-A-T $4.10 17.87 4.88%
Rocky Mountain Dealerships Inc. RME-T $10.21 8.55 4.80%
Bird Construction Inc. BDT-T $8.18 n/a 4.77%
Computer Modelling Group Ltd. CMG-T $8.42 34.14 4.75%
Information Services Corp. ISV-T $16.85 17.33 4.75%
Lucara Diamond Corp. LUC-T $2.20 15.52 4.55%
North West Co. Inc. NWC-T $28.19 17.79 4.54%
Evertz Technologies Ltd. ET-T $16.14 22.16 4.46%
DHX Media Ltd. DHX-T $1.83 n/a 4.37%
Western Forest Products Inc. WEF-T $2.07 9.20 4.35%
Corby Spirit and Wine Ltd. CSW-A-T $20.34 22.85 4.33%
Absolute Software Corp. ABT-T $7.40 44.17 4.32%
TORC Oil & Gas Ltd. TOG-T $6.54 51.28 4.04%
Sprott Inc. SII-T $3.01 14.33 3.99%
Surge Energy Inc. SGY-T $2.60 40.47 3.85%
Mullen Group Ltd. MTL-T $15.72 34.96 3.82%
Intertape Polymer Group Inc. ITP-T $19.24 12.50 3.78%
Transcontinental Inc. TCL-A-T $22.29 6.83 3.77%
Ag Growth International Inc. AFN-T $63.99 23.77 3.75%
Calian Group Ltd. CGY-T $30.09 14.47 3.72%
Wajax Corp. WJX-T $26.88 13.73 3.72%
Pinnacle Renewable Holdings PL-T $16.18 n/a 3.71%
Melcor Developments Ltd. MRD-T $14.19 7.32 3.66%
Wall Financial Corp. WFC-T $27.60 79.67 3.62%
Pason Systems Inc. PSI-T $20.22 56.17 3.56%
Boralex Inc. BLX-T $17.83 96.30 3.53%
Newfoundland Capital Corp. Ltd. NCC-A-T $14.24 12.06 3.51%
Labrador Iron Ore Royalty Corp. LIF-T $28.52 16.69 3.51%
AGT Food & Ingredients Inc. AGT-T $17.53 n/a 3.42%
Clearwater Seafoods Inc. CLR-T $5.85 n/a 3.42%
Alcanna Inc. CLIQ-T $10.66 47.03 3.38%
Exco Technologies Ltd. XTC-T $10.07 10.91 3.38%
Secure Energy Services Inc. SES-T $8.45 n/a 3.20%
Algoma Central Corp. ALC-T $12.56 11.71 3.18%
K-Bro Linen Inc. KBL-T $38.25 71.49 3.14%
Leon's Furniture Ltd. LNF-T $17.95 13.87 3.12%
AutoCanada Inc. ACQ-T $13.24 18.09 3.02%
Cervus Equipment Corp. CERV-T $13.55 10.13 2.95%
Aecon Group Inc. ARE-T $17.00 27.97 2.94%
Morneau Shepell Inc. MSI-T $27.25 32.60 2.86%
Quarterhill Inc. QTRH-T $1.78 11.46 2.81%
Bonavista Energy Corp. BNP-T $1.45 n/a 2.76%
Tidewater Midstream and Infras TWM-T $1.45 38.38 2.76%
Stingray Digital Group Inc. RAY-A-T $8.87 24.57 2.71%
Cogeco Inc. CGO-T $59.37 7.04 2.63%
Horizon North Logistics Inc. HNL-T $3.05 n/a 2.62%
Sleep Country Canada Holdings ZZZ-T $28.31 17.69 2.61%
Tricon Capital Group Inc. TCN-T $10.73 8.30 2.61%
Madison Pacific Properties Inc. MPC-T $4.11 5.04 2.55%
Westshore Terminals Investment WTE-T $26.67 15.67 2.40%
Vecima Networks Inc. VCM-T $9.25 n/a 2.38%
Shawcor Ltd. SCL-T $25.58 29.24 2.35%
AirBoss of America Corp. BOS-T $11.94 17.54 2.35%
Enerflex Ltd. EFX-T $16.44 21.06 2.31%
Total Energy Services Inc. TOT-T $10.91 33.21 2.20%
Savaria Corp. SIS-T $19.37 36.01 2.17%
Neo Performance Materials Inc. NEO-T $18.05 n/a 2.11%
Birchcliff Energy Ltd. BIR-T $4.90 18.41 2.04%
Osisko Gold Royalties Ltd. OR-T $10.05 215.69 1.99%
Guardian Capital Group Ltd. GCG-A-T $25.40 10.91 1.97%
Altus Group Ltd. AIF-T $30.61 n/a 1.96%
Hardwoods Distribution Inc. HDI-T $16.60 10.92 1.93%
Magellan Aerospace Corp. MAL-T $18.54 11.95 1.83%
Stelco Holdings Inc. STLC-T $22.24 n/a 1.80%
Park Lawn Corp. PLC-T $25.51 45.88 1.79%
Badger Daylighting Ltd. BAD-T $30.76 17.10 1.76%
New Look Vision Group Inc. BCI-T $34.35 39.50 1.75%
BMTC Group Inc. GBT-T $16.15 n/a 1.73%
goeasy Ltd. GSY-T $52.03 19.10 1.73%
Uni-Select Inc. UNS-T $22.33 13.92 1.66%
Equitable Group Inc. EQB-T $66.12 7.27 1.63%
Recipe Unlimited Corp. RECP-T $27.86 18.51 1.53%
Mountain ProvInce Diamonds Inc. MPVD-T $2.65 65.25 1.51%
CES Energy Solutions Corp. CEU-T $4.01 23.74 1.50%
Jamieson Wellness Inc. JWEL-T $26.26 84.27 1.37%
Lassonde Industries Inc. LAS-A-T $237.51 18.46 1.36%
Cascades Inc. CAS-T $12.25 15.72 1.31%
Andrew Peller Ltd. ADW-A-T $16.07 20.50 1.28%
Altius Minerals Corp. ALS-T $12.70 n/a 1.26%
Martinrea International Inc. MRE-T $14.32 6.51 1.26%
TECSYS Inc. TCS-T $16.50 56.70 1.21%
ECN Capital Corp. ECN-T $3.68 17.16 1.09%
Silvercorp Metals Inc. SVM-T $2.99 9.45 1.08%
Velan Inc. VLN-T $11.40 n/a 1.05%
Canfor Pulp Products Inc. CFX-T $23.99 8.32 1.04%
TransGlobe Energy Corp. TGL-T $4.43 8.97 1.03%
Cargojet Inc. CJT-T $84.23 52.52 1.01%
MTY Food Group Inc. MTY-T $64.25 25.27 0.93%
Clairvest Group Inc. CVG-T $48.45 3.87 0.91%
Richelieu Hardware Ltd. RCH-T $29.08 24.57 0.83%
North American Construction Group NOA-T $12.51 29.85 0.64%
TWC Enterprises Ltd. TWC-T $12.75 21.35 0.63%
Canaccord Genuity Group Inc. CF-T $6.97 26.41 0.57%
Hudson's Bay Co. HBC-T $9.44 n/a 0.53%
Trilogy International Partners TRL-T $3.80 n/a 0.53%
Pollard Banknote Ltd. PBL-T $23.74 43.82 0.51%
Hudbay Minerals Inc. HBM-T $6.55 5.71 0.31%

Source: Bloomberg

Norman Rothery, PhD, CFA, is the founder of StingyInvestor.com.

Report an error Editorial code of conduct
Comments

Welcome to The Globe and Mail’s comment community. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. Non-subscribers can read and sort comments but will not be able to engage with them in any way. Click here to subscribe.

If you would like to write a letter to the editor, please forward it to letters@globeandmail.com. Readers can also interact with The Globe on Facebook and Twitter .

Welcome to The Globe and Mail’s comment community. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. Non-subscribers can read and sort comments but will not be able to engage with them in any way. Click here to subscribe.

If you would like to write a letter to the editor, please forward it to letters@globeandmail.com. Readers can also interact with The Globe on Facebook and Twitter .

Welcome to The Globe and Mail’s comment community. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff.

We aim to create a safe and valuable space for discussion and debate. That means:

  • All comments will be reviewed by one or more moderators before being posted to the site. This should only take a few moments.
  • Treat others as you wish to be treated
  • Criticize ideas, not people
  • Stay on topic
  • Avoid the use of toxic and offensive language
  • Flag bad behaviour

Comments that violate our community guidelines will be removed. Commenters who repeatedly violate community guidelines may be suspended, causing them to temporarily lose their ability to engage with comments.

Read our community guidelines here

Discussion loading ...

Due to technical reasons, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this fixed soon. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback@globeandmail.com. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters@globeandmail.com.
Cannabis pro newsletter