A few cities aside, the housing market in Canada has cooled to a point where prices are either dropping or rising just a little. Yet the temperature is definitely rising in the dialogue about young adults and home ownership.
We recently presented a gallery of millennial voices on housing that presented a troubling situation. In expensive cities like Toronto, Hamilton, Vancouver and Victoria, young adults feel either shut out of the market or weighed down by the cost of owning homes they have already bought.
The volume and, um, tenor of the comments suggest that inter-generational tensions over housing are building. On one hand, we have young adults who are eager to own but feel frustrated by the high cost. Pollster David Coletto tweeted on this after our gallery and a column I wrote about it were published. “In every survey of Canadian millennials I’ve done this year, housing is the top issue,” he wrote. “The kettle is getting hot and close to boiling.
On the other hand are members of older generations who think millennials should stop complaining. “It has NEVER been easy!” said one online commenter. Another offered this helpful contribution to the debate: “Stop stamping your feet like a two year old complaining that you can’t afford a home in the area you want to live.” One more, just for fun: “I find it interesting that most of the millennials here want to live in the most expensive places in Canada and blame everyone but themselves for their predicament.”
It’s so ironic to see boomers raging about this. They’ll need a strong contingent of young adult buyers to keep the housing market buoyant. Without young buyers in the market, how will boomer lock down the huge equity gains they’ve made in their homes?
Many boomers are actually quite worried about how their young adult children will afford houses. Here’s an interesting case study to look at if you’re a parent in this group. Can Anne, a 60-year-old recent retiree, afford to give her two adult children $200,000 each for a house down payment? The analysis was done by a money management firm that earlier wrote a piece headlined: “House Rich, Cash Poor: Beware of Strangling Your Kids with Debt.” Here’s a column I wrote about the debt problem for new home buyers. Here’s a story we ran last year on how some worried parents are buying homes for their school-aged kids.
Many boomers feel they had it tough in the early 1980s, when interest rates ranged as high as 20 per cent or so. Bizarro high rates were definitely a challenge, but here’s an analysis that says it’s significantly harder to afford a house today in the Toronto market. High prices today are worse than high rates were.
Anyone for renting? The upside of renting is covered well in a Q&A with the author of a book called The Wealthy Renter.
Subscribe to Carrick on Money
Are you reading this newsletter on the web or did someone forward the e-mail version to you? If so, you can sign up for Carrick on Money here.
Today’s featured financial tool
Renting a car for your summer vacation this year? AutoSlash claims to be able to save the average customer about 30 per cent by comparing rates at multiple rental companies and tracking discount coupons.
Q: “It’s actually recommended to sell utility shares. I own Emera shares and my cost is $18.50. Should I sell them? I’m 64 years old.”
A: Yes, the share price of utilities like Emera are suffering as interest rates rise. So what? If you’re investing for dividend income, utilities remain a core holding. Emera shares trade these days in the $40 range, with a dividend yield of 5.6 per cent. Anyone who bought Emera shares at $18.50 is getting a much higher yield than that on his or her initial investment thanks to dividend increases over the years.
Do you have a question for me? Send it my way. Sorry I can’t answer every one personally. Questions and answers are edited for length.
The latest data on household debt, net worth and more is covered in this video from Statistics Canada.
What I’ve been writing about
- Could your loved ones figure out your finances if you died?
- How to bluntly break up with your adviser (for Globe Unlimited subscribers)
- Analyzing Canada’s largest mutual funds: ‘Mediocre is kind in some cases’ (for Globe Unlimited subscribers)
More Carrick and money coverage
For more money stories, follow me on Instagram and Twitter, and join the discussion on my Facebook page. Millennial readers, join our Gen Y Money Facebook group. Send us an e-mail to let us know what you think of my newsletter. Want to subscribe? Click here to sign up.