We have a cliché problem in personal finance. Too many empty phrases that get repeated endlessly because they suggest expertise and mastery of money. You’ll find some prime examples of stale personal finance clichés in a recent blog post by money coach Anita Bruinsma. Under the headline “Personal finance hogwash,” Ms. Bruinsma takes on real estate investing, passive income, side hustles and more. I liked her post so much I invited her to expand on it in a Q&A. Here’s our exchange by e-mail:
Q: Anita, can you tell us a little about your background in investing and the type of work you do?
A: I spent 15 years as a stock market analyst, researching companies and making stock recommendations for the mutual funds that my group was managing. Now I’m a financial coach and one of my service offerings is teaching people how to become do-it-yourself investors. On the personal side, I’ve been a DIY investor since the age of 23.
Q: What prompted you to single out those five phrases as hogwash? I mean, lots of people really believe some of this stuff.
A: I think that personal finance and investing have become hobbies for some people, and this has led to a lot of information being presented online by people who are far from being experts in the field. There are phrases and ideas that just keep being repeated over and over again as if they are unquestionably correct. The rhetoric can make it seem like people are getting rich by doing these remarkable things while everyone else is missing out. This can feel daunting and can lead people to throw their hands in the air and give up on doing anything at all about their finances because it’s too difficult or complicated. Of course, it doesn’t have to be this way.
Q: I cannot believe how often I’ve heard the phrase “investment property” in the past couple of years, both professionally and in conversations with friends and family. You’ve taken aim at the idea that investing in real estate is the best way to get rich. Why?
A: There’s a sense of FOMO if someone doesn’t own real estate in this country. The truth is that owning real estate as an investment requires work and can be stressful. It’s easy to say, ‘my tenant’s rent pays my mortgage,’ but what about the new fridge they need in their unit or the broken air conditioner? What about taxes, insurance and upkeep? Then there’s the hassle factor: difficult tenants, recordkeeping, and the call you get from a tenant about a plumbing emergency while you’re away on vacation. It’s not unusual for people to run a loss on their rental property on an annual basis once all costs are taken into consideration. That means their cash flow is reduced, leaving less money available for their everyday lives.
Q: What about trading stocks or crypto – what’s your sense of how feasible it is to trade your way to building wealth? God knows, the personal finance universe is full of people who say it is.
A: If you want to see me get fired up at a dinner party, invite someone who loves to talk about trading crypto and stocks. People who brag about how much money they made trading stocks and crypto usually aren’t telling the whole story. Winning in trading on a consistent basis is rare – so rare that even the most experienced Bay Street money manager can’t do it. Why would someone with no experience and training in stock market analysis, and who has no support from a team of people, think they can do better? The thought of trading stocks makes a lot of people feel like investing isn’t possible for them because they don’t have the time or inclination. The truth is that anyone can invest in the stock market with a buy and hold strategy using exchange-traded funds or mutual funds.
Q: You also took aim at the side hustle, a phrase has always bugged me because it suggests the reason you’re not getting ahead financially is that you’re not working enough. Yet in today’s economy, I wonder if some people might need a side hustle to get by. What are your thoughts?
A: There’s no question that the high inflation we’ve experienced recently has made it harder to get by. However, we have to be careful when looking at aggregate data and averages when determining how well people are “getting by.” Every person’s situation is unique. Some people are definitely struggling to pay their bills and in some cases they simply need to earn more. For many people though there are other ways to get by – sometimes it’s a question of the choices they are making, especially with respect to how they spend their money. If someone wants to take on a side hustle that’s great. But for a lot of people, it’s simply not possible. What would the ‘hustle’ be? Would they have any downtime at all? Will they give up time with their family? I’d like people to stop feeling guilty for not taking on an additional job disguised as a side hustle.
Q: The hogwash phrases you picked all have a common theme – that there are shortcuts or proven formulas for getting rich. In your experience, what does it take to build wealth, and how long a timeline should you have?
A: Building wealth is based on the simplest of concepts: Spend less than you earn, save, and invest. Yes, it’s boring, it’s tedious, and it takes time. But for average people, this is how wealth is built. When I say “wealth,” I don’t mean accumulating money to hoard it. I primarily mean accumulating enough money to pay for your retirement so that you don’t have to stress about it.
Subscribe to Carrick on Money
Are you reading this newsletter on the web or did someone forward the e-mail version to you? If so, you can sign up for Carrick on Money here.
Rob’s personal finance reading list
Home prices down, and so is affordability
Higher mortgage rates offset declines in home prices, which means worsening affordability. Here’s how much income you need to afford a home in cities across the country. Now for a comprehensive look at how rents have soared in major cities across the country.
FHSA rules for couples
A tax and estate planning expert on what couples need to know about the new first home savings account, or FHSA. For example, can one spouse contribute to the other’s FHSA?
Questions your bank will never ask
A helpful anti-fraud initiative from the Canadian Bankers Association lists questions your bank will never ask you. Give this a read and cut your risk of clicking on dangerous phishing e-mails.
SUVs for families
A ranking of 13 different seven-seater SUVs on the basis of value for the buck. Hybrids and ICE – internal combustion engine – models included.
In a recent newsletter, I answered a question about how to choose which profitable stocks to sell. A newsletter subscriber had an additional suggestion – donating some or all of the shares to charity. “There would be no capital gains and a donation tax credit. Your reader would be doubly rewarded.”
Do you have a comment or question for me? Send it my way. Sorry I can’t answer every one personally. Questions and answers are edited for length and clarity.
Tools, explainers, guides and charts
A tax primer on the various types of investment income.
The Money-Free Zone
Does the world need more Velvet Underground tributes? Not really, but I still enjoyed the new album Some Kinda Love, by the alternative band The Feelies. Fave song: What Goes On.
For the Feelies at their original best, check out this live version of the song Higher Ground. And for an appreciation of Velvet singer Lou Reed, here’s a review of a new Reed bio. Loved this line: “you know things are bad when Lou Reed is healthier than you are.”
Callout: We want to hear from you
The Globe is exploring how being retired affects a parent’s ability to help children with housing costs. We are hoping to hear from retired parents who have supported children with down payments or by co-signing a mortgage, children who have had support from retired parents, or those who didn’t because their retirement introduced specific challenges. If you are willing to share your personal story, please get in touch with Globe and Mail reporter Irene Galea at email@example.com.
In case you missed these Globe and Mail personal finance-related stories
- The RESP is the best way to save for schooling, but does it unfairly benefit the rich?
- Do surviving spouses tend to die soon after the death of a long-time partner?
- A better way to compare bonds and GICs
More Rob Carrick and money coverage
Subscribe to Stress Test on Apple podcasts or Spotify. For more money stories, follow me on Instagram and Twitter, and join the discussion on my Facebook page. Millennial readers, join our Gen Y Money Facebook group.
Even more coverage from Rob Carrick:
- 🎧 Catch up on Stress Test: Why millennials and Gen Z are Alberta-bound for a more affordable life • Rising interest rates brought pain for new homeowners – and opportunity for house hunters • Why more Canadians are choosing to be childfree or delay parenthood • Love in the time of inflation: How to manage rising costs when dating • You're not bad at money – you're suffering from money shame • Retirement might look different for Gen Z and millennials. Here's how to plan for it • Recession-beating tips for the job market, housing, investing and the cost of life • Is the middle class dead for millennials and Gen Z?
- ✔️ The housing file: A house isn’t special. Get your head straight about the reality of home ownership • The good, the sad and the unaffordable: Saving for a home downpayment in Canada’s big cities • Property taxes are popping in some cities – how worried should you be about other tax hikes? • Our other real-estate problem – people have too much wealth tied up in houses • Borrowers and savers, here’s how to time the eventual rollback of interest rates
- 📈 Investing: Canada's top digital broker is TD Direct Investing, with an assist from the TD Easy Trade app • 2023 Globe and Mail ETF buyer's guide part one: Canadian equity ETFs • For the ultimate in cheap investing, check out the Freedom .08 ETF Portfolio • Yes, there is risk in Canadian bank deposits for the unwary and complacent • CDIC covers bank deposits, but who protects your investments if your broker goes bust? • Answers to your questions about the low-risk ETF paying almost 5% • Happy fifth birthday to one of the all-time best investing products for everyday people • An investing strategy that wins cleanly over the long term by outperforming in bad years like 2022
- 💰 Your money: Mortgage holders, savers and GIC investors, it’s time to change your thinking on interest rates • How much debt is each generation of Canadians carrying, and how do you compare? • For the sake of their financial futures, young people should leave Toronto and Vancouver • This practical new spin on a savings account might just peel you away from your big bank • Rental fraud grows amid rise in fake, falsified tenant applications • Are Canadians worse off financially now than in the 1980s? • From groceries to auto loans, here’s how much more it costs to live right now • When saving for retirement, should you change your asset mix over the course of your career? • Do retirement income needs always rise alongside inflation? Not necessarily • When the bank suggests you lock in your variable rate mortgage, it has an angle