Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

I was diagnosed as clinically mute as a child. Now I know I was right to fear the power of words

Facts & Arguments is a daily personal piece submitted by readers. Have a story to tell? See our guidelines at

I was diagnosed as clinically mute not long after I learned how to talk. I spoke solely to my immediate family members and sparingly so, even to them. It was not that I couldn't speak or that I didn't understand the utility of language. Rather, it was my hyperawareness of its power that made language a precarious resource and one that I dared not use recklessly.

Kindergarten was an ordeal, to say the least. I dreaded "play hour," the seemingly endless portion of the day allocated to compulsory socialization. I would regress into a catatonic state at the mere thought of having to approach another child and ask to play. When my teachers would become frustrated and plead with me to "use my words," I would hyperventilate, turn blue and pass out. (This was a function of my cyanotic spells, with which I was subsequently diagnosed.)

For years, I persisted in my silence. On multiple occasions, I rode all the way home in carpool without my seat belt on because I couldn't do it up myself, and I was too afraid to ask for help.

"You've been sitting here all this time without your seat belt on?" the carpool mother would say. "Why didn't you tell me?"

I thought but never said, "Because I'm terrified of speaking."

I was almost seven years old when I "broke my silence," so to speak. I was on a walk with my mother when we bumped into her good friend. She was a woman whom I was well acquainted with and also a woman whom I had never uttered a single word to. When I saw her approaching, I promptly performed my routine procedure, concealing myself behind my mother's legs.

As I observed the two women converse, I felt unaccountably moved to say "hello." It was hard to fathom this impulse; it was so foreign, yet so instinctual. The desire to talk came over me like a tidal wave – wholly and forcefully; it was a phenomenon that was not a result of perseverance, but a product nature.

Having had no experience with the task of greeting someone, I managed a meagre "hi" before cowering in confusion at the sound of my own voice. She didn't hear me, but that didn't matter. Because, with that one word, I unleashed myself into the realm of talkers, inexplicably leaving behind my trepidation.

Mariah Llanes for The Globe and Mail

My shyness no longer debilitated me, but I remained frugal with my words throughout elementary school. My brothers would return home from school and share drawn-out stories about their day or excitedly exchange predictions about the upcoming hockey game; they spent their words frivolously. I, on the other hand, preferred to express myself through drawings and diagrams, providing brief verbal explanations where my artistry failed me.

“Is that a ladder over there?” my mother asked softly, with one hand pointing to the fence that I had drawn and the other resting gently on my shoulder as she carefully examined my artwork.

“It’s a fence,” I explained.

As I matured, I became increasingly liberal with my use of speech. The gnawing fear of words that once controlled my life eventually dissipated. I was completely emancipated from my childhood anxiety. I was unrestrained. I was reckless.

When I was in seventh grade, I learned what shame tastes like. I was sitting with my friends at lunch, chatting mindlessly about TV shows and the latest gossip. One of my friends began remarking about the new haircut of a girl in our grade.

“She looks like a boy,” my friend snickered.

“I know,” I replied, “it looks horrible!”

Our words were careless. Idle. But powerful, nonetheless.

The following day, I found myself in conversation with that girl; we were discussing our work during class. After a few minutes, she looked down at the ground and whispered to me, “I don’t like my haircut, either.”

I had never felt so ashamed, and, in that moment, I realized that my words were possessing me in the very same way that my silence once did.

That was in seventh grade – the day I reclaimed my fear of words, and that fear has remained within me ever since. I know this now, as I knew it when I was in kindergarten: Words are powerful, far more so than the person who speaks them; perhaps silence is not my disease, but my remedy.

Laura Goldfarb lives in Toronto.

Story continues below advertisement

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to