Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

New study casts more doubt on controversial multiple sclerosis theory

Italian researcher Dr. Paolo Zamboni, at a 2009 neurology conference in Toronto.

Tim Fraser/The Globe and Mail

A controversial condition coined and championed by Italian doctor Paolo Zamboni as the key to treating multiple sclerosis doesn't appear to exist, according to a new study published in a leading Canadian medical journal. But the veinoplasty procedure, used to treat the non-existent condition known as chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency, may yet help some people with MS.

The idea that CCSVI, which refers to blocked or abnormal neck veins, plays a pivotal role in MS has been a controversial, hotly debated topic for the last five years in Canada, which has one of the world's highest rates of the disease. The theory was developed by Zamboni, an Italian vascular surgeon, and brought to public attention by media reports, including in The Globe and Mail. Thousands of Canadians have travelled overseas and payed $20,000 or more to have veinoplasty, a procedure to prop open the neck veins to promote blood flow.

The new study, published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal on Monday, examined 120 patients with MS and 60 healthy controls and found no meaningful difference in vein abnormalities between the groups. The authors, led by Dr. Fiona Costello at the University of Calgary, conclude that their findings "revealed significant methodologic concerns" about the proposed diagnostic criteria for CCSVI that "challenge their validity."

Story continues below advertisement

It's just the latest in a slew of scientific papers that have cast serious doubt on the existence of a condition that supposedly interferes with normal blood flow and leads to an accumulation of iron in the brain. Many studies have found that venous abnormalities are quite common in healthy people and that many who have MS don't have venous malformations.

Despite the doubt surrounding Zamboni's original hypothesis, there is a burning question the studies haven't answered: Why do so many MS patients report feeling better after undergoing the veinoplasty procedure?

The possibility exists that somehow, vein-widening surgery is an effective treatment option for a subset of patients, said Dr. Anthony Traboulsee, MS Society of Canada Research Chair and associate professor at the University of British Columbia. He was part of a survey that asked 100 people about their experiences getting the vein-widening treatment overseas. About half of respondents said they noticed an improvement in symptoms, while half didn't.

"Something is happening to people, a certain proportion of people," he said. "The easiest thing to do is discount it all as a placebo effect."

Traboulsee and other researchers across Canada are on a mission to answer the question of whether the positive effects are real.

Plenty of anecdotal evidence of the success of vein-widening surgery exists online, thanks to outspoken advocates who use social media to share news and raise awareness.

But what's missing are the randomized controlled trials that can take anecdotes and see if they stand up to evidence-based scrutiny.

Story continues below advertisement

Traboulsee is part of a four-centre trial (Vancouver, Winnipeg, Montreal, Quebec City) that will eventually study 100 MS patients. Half will receive the treatment and half won't. No one in the study, including the researchers, will know who received what.

After a year of observation, the researchers will analyze the data and report their findings, which could be late next year or sometime in 2016.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author

Carly Weeks has been a journalist with The Globe and Mail since 2007.  She has reported on everything from federal politics to the high levels of sodium in the Canadian diet. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨