Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content


Entry archive:

Mammograms are among the medical tests that doctors worry are overused. (ER Productions/Corbis)
Mammograms are among the medical tests that doctors worry are overused. (ER Productions/Corbis)

When standard medical testing does more harm than good Add to ...

Think that getting medical tests or undergoing all available screening exams is the key to health? Think again.

There is growing concern that many tests or procedures, such as computed tomography (CT scans) or mammograms are being overused simply because they are available, even though they may not help patients and, in many cases, even cause harm.

Groups of doctors in the U.S. released lists Wednesday of tests and procedures that doctors should think twice about ordering.

The move is part of a campaign called “Choosing Wisely”. Organized members of the American Board of Internal Medicine, the campaign includes lists of five services performed by nine different medical specialties.

The Wall Street Journal reports that some of the initial tests on the list include imaging scans that may not help patients, such as imaging for non-specific low back pain. There is growing concern that many patients are undergoing medical scans unnecessarily, which not only costs the system but also exposes patients to potentially harmful radiation.

The new recommendations also call for a stop to the routine prescribing of antibiotics for mild to moderate sinus infections. And it suggests avoiding chemotherapy or radiation for cancer patients with solid tumours who are in poor health, haven't responded to other treatments and don't qualify for a research trial.

While that recommendation could spark accusations that “death panels” are alive and well in the U.S., many doctors and medical organizations say it doesn't make sense, and may even be detrimental, to offer services to patients who likely won't benefit from it.

The issue of availability of screening tests and other medical procedures has become increasingly contentious in recent years as more evidence emerges that these medical services may not help patients.

Last November, for instance, there was considerable controversy when Canadian guidelines were issued saying only women aged 50 to 74 should have regular mammograms, and that they should be done every two to three years instead of annually. (The guidelines don't apply to women with high risk of breast cancer.)

Many patient groups disputed the recommendations, arguing they put the lives of women at risk. However, mounting scientific evidence shows that performing mammograms on low-risk women can increase the risk of false positives. Women can be wrongly diagnosed and undergo invasive procedures unnecessarily, for instance.

Would you demand a medical test or procedure even if your doctor told you it would do no good?

Report Typo/Error

Follow on Twitter: @carlyweeks

Next story




Most popular videos »

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular