Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Orca’s death off B.C. coast not likely caused by another whale, expert says

An orca breaches off the coast of B.C. in a file photo from July, 2005.

Jared Towers/AP

The death of an endangered killer whale found off the coast of British Columbia was not likely caused by another whale, according to an expert, leaving open the possibility the animal was struck by a ship at sea.

"These whales do exhibit aggressive behaviour with one another but it's very minimal," said Washington's Center for Whale Research director Deborah Giles. "And it's generally done in play or social behaviour. [The whale] doesn't have any other bite marks or scratch marks that I can tell from the photo."

The 18-year-old male orca, known as J34, was found dead last Tuesday off the Sunshine Coast, north of Vancouver. The animal was part of the endangered southern resident killer whale population, which live in the waters off southern B.C. and Washington state. The group's population is now 79, down from 88 in 2005.

Story continues below advertisement

A necropsy determined the whale died of blunt-force trauma to its head and neck, but officials with the federal Fisheries Department have been careful not to speculate about what caused the animal's injuries – specifically if it was caused by a vessel.

The fate of killer whales in the Pacific Northwest region of B.C. and Washington State has become a central issue in the debate about the Kinder Morgan pipeline expansion from Alberta to B.C.

The federal government approved the project last month, but environmentalists and others have said the increased tanker traffic associated with the pipeline would put whales in serious danger, either from ship strikes or because the ships' noise will disrupt the whales' ability to track prey and communicate. Environmental groups filed a lawsuit last week challenging the federal approval of the pipeline because, they argue, the government did not adequately consider the impact on the whales.

Still, experts have yet to confirm the dead orca was struck by a ship of any kind. Ms. Giles said it is possible the seven-metre-long orca was struck by a ship, but she also said it is rare for a vessel to strike smaller-toothed whales, such as the southern resident killer whales, because they are hypersensitive and uniquely aware of their surroundings.

"What was happening in the water at the time that would have allowed him to be struck by a ship? That's what's so perplexing for us. So maybe there was another noise in the water, other disturbances in the water that were occurring at the same time that would have made him disoriented or unable to sense things in the water – to see and hear," she said.

The necropsy showed the orca was in overall good condition with a thick layer of blubber, which is the fat marine mammals use to insulate and store energy. The whale also had a hematoma, indicating it was alive for a time after the injury.

Ms. Giles also said southern resident killer whales are going through long periods of malnutrition because of the lack of salmon in the region.

Story continues below advertisement

"Southern resident killer whales are very picky eaters. They only eat salmon and they preferentially eat chinook salmon. And all salmon species are just a fraction of what they used to be in the past. We know there's not enough fish in the water to grow the population, so these whales end up being nutritionally deficient during pregnancy and after pregnancy."

She also raised concerns with the Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain expansion pipeline – the Liberal government gave the green light to the $6.8-billion expansion project late last month.

The number of tankers with crude oil sailing from the pipeline terminal into Juan de Fuca Strait will increase from approximately five a month to 34, in 2019, when the project is expected to be completed.

"Our entire ecosystem in the Salish Sea would be disrupted and potentially catastrophically destructive," she said.

For Living Oceans executive director, Karen Wristen, new developments in the Salish Sea, such as the extension of the Kinder Morgan pipeline, are a threat to the southern resident killer whales.

"The population viability study that we've done on it suggests that any further disturbance could lead to extinction," Ms. Wristen said.

Story continues below advertisement

Her organization and the Raincoast Conservation Foundation have applied for a judicial review of the NEB's report recommending approval of the pipeline expansion. They've also filed a new request asking the court to satisfy the cabinet's decision to accept that report.

"When a species is designated endangered, as the southern resident killer whales have been, you must take action to protect their habitat and to create an action plan that will encourage the recovery. You cannot approve projects that will endanger them further… That's contrary to law."

Report an error Licensing Options

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨