Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Teachers college overhaul will ‘weed out bad apples’

The agency responsible for regulating school teachers in B.C. will be overhauled this fall to help "weed out the bad apples" from the ranks of the province's 75,000 licenced educators.

Education Minister George Abbott promised "substantial" changes to the B.C. College of Teachers when legislation is introduced later this fall, so that parents will be able to determine if concerns about individual teachers have been investigated, and whether those teachers are still serving in classrooms.

However, he said the amendments to the Teaching Profession Act will not be made retroactive, so any existing concerns about teachers won't be captured.

Story continues below advertisement

"I don't think any of us in our professions want to be tarred by those bad apples and I'm hoping we'll see better management of issues around bad apples with these changes," Mr. Abbott said in an interview Thursday.

The B.C. government pledged to overhaul the college almost a year ago, after a report by fact-finder Don Avison concluded that the agency does not consistently put student safety ahead of the interests of teachers.

The college sets standards for professional educators, issues teaching certificates, investigates complaints and imposes discipline.

In his report, Mr. Avison cited three examples where individuals were granted the right to teach in B.C. despite serious professional misconduct – including one teacher who had been convicted of sexual assaults on students.

Even today, Mr. Abbott said he does not know if any of those teachers cited in the Avison report are currently working in B.C. schools. "But I believe the changes we are proposing with respect to the reform and renewal of the college of teachers will give us the ability to answer your important question definitively."

Mr. Abbott said the changes will ensure that teachers who face discipline by the college cannot elude discipline by surrendering their teaching licence – and then find a teaching job elsewhere.

But Susan Lambert, president of the B.C. Teachers' Federation, said it is a "myth" that teachers are evading discipline, and accused the government of manufacturing a crisis in confidence.

Story continues below advertisement

Ms. Lambert said the government has refused to investigate the cases in Mr. Avison's report to determine what happened. "In our view the Avison report was seriously flawed," she said. "The charges themselves were never fully investigated."

The changes are being drafted even as the teachers union is engaged in contract talks and is taking job action.

Ms. Lambert said she is not entirely satisfied with the new college model – which will replace the existing college with an organization embedded in the Ministry of Education – because it will diminish the role of the union.

But she offered grudging support for the changes. "The strength of the proposal is that it focuses on conduct and confidence and discipline," she said.

Kit Krieger, the registrar for the College of Teachers, says he is alarmed that the proposed changes will only make things worse by formalizing the role of the teachers' union in regulating teachers.

Mr. Krieger, a former president of the BCTF, says there is no doubt the college needs to be changed, but he said Mr. Abbott has overlooked what he believes to be the fundamental problem: The college needs to be independent of the union.

Story continues below advertisement

"This is a terrible setback for our profession," he said. "As long as he is placing the union in any role – majority or minority – he's compromising the regulatory function, he has he has sacrificed the public interest and he has put kids at risk."

Mr. Abbott did not provide details of the proposed legislation, which is still in draft form. But he said: "The college will not be an instrument of the union."

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
B.C. politics reporter

Based in the press gallery of the B.C. Legislature in Victoria, Justine has followed the ups and downs of B.C. premiers since 1988. She has also worked as a business reporter and on Parliament Hill covering national politics. More

Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.