Skip to main content
bus crash

A piece of heavy equipment strains to move a bus which plummeted 200 feet down an embankment in rural Eastern Oregon on Dec. 30, 2012, killing nine and sending multiple people to hospital.RANDY L. RASMUSSEN/The Canadian Press

Two British Columbia passengers who survived a bus crash that killed nine others on an Oregon highway have filed a lawsuit against the tour bus company and the driver.

June Won Kim and his wife Hee Eun Kim said in their notice of civil claim that the bus was mechanically defective and the tires were inadequate for the road conditions on Dec. 30, when the vehicle crashed through a guardrail on Interstate 84 and tumbled down a snowy embankment near Pendleton, Ore.

The Burnaby couple allege in separate B.C. Supreme Court documents that Mi Joo Tour and Travel failed to equip the bus with proper headlights, windshield wipers and warning devices to ensure it could be safely operated on the trip from Las Vegas to Vancouver.

The Kims also alleged the driver, from Surrey, B.C., was too tired, speeding, failed to obey road signs and operated a vehicle contrary to restrictions on his driver's licence.

"The plaintiff pleads that the defendant, Haeng-Kyu Hwang, was negligent in the use and operation of the motor vehicle ... and that said negligence caused or contributed to the collision and that the defendant is thus liable for the losses, damages and expenses thereby sustained by the plaintiff," court documents said.

The couple say they both suffered a brain injury, a collapsed lung, and back and neck injuries resulting in permanent disability.

June Won Kim, a dental technician, said he also suffered permanent injuries to his face, hand, knee, feet and teeth.

His wife's shoulders, eyes and legs were injured and she is dealing with anxiety issues, her lawsuit said.

"The effects or results of the said injuries upon the plaintiff include pain and suffering, headaches, fatigue, dizziness, nausea, sleeplessness, loss of amenities and loss of enjoyment of life."

The B.C. couple's lawsuit followed another by two Korean exchange students in Tacoma, Wash., who said they witnessed a nightmarish scene on the bus as they lay among dead passengers while the injured were screaming and crying.

Jong-Hyun Chae and Seong-June An, along with the Kims, were among 38 people injured on the bus on a stretch called Deadman Pass.

The driver, a deacon at a Methodist church, was also hurt.

However, a lawyer for the bus company has said black ice, not driver fatigue, led to the crash in an area that has a history of traffic accidents.

Mark Scheer said the driver had seven and a half hours' sleep before the crash and had a rest break during the two and a half hours he'd been on the road.

Interact with The Globe