Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Disgraced pathologist Charles Smith stripped of medical licence

Dr. Charles Smith, shown in Toronto in 2008, faces a disciplinary hearing in February, 2011.

Kevin Van Paassen/The Globe and Mail/Kevin Van Paassen/The Globe and Mail

A disciplinary panel in Toronto has stripped disgraced pathologist Dr. Charles Smith of his medical licence.



The panel also ordered Mr. Smith to appear in person for a reprimand.



Mr. Smith did not attend Tuesday's hearing but pleaded no contest to disgraceful conduct and incompetence through his lawyer. He did not fight the penalty the panel imposed.

Story continues below advertisement



Mr. Smith's expert evidence on more than a dozen baby and child deaths saw several people prosecuted or jailed.



A public inquiry three years ago savaged his methods and he has not practised medicine since August 2008, when his registration expired.



Carolyn Silver, speaking for the college, said Mr Smith failed in "multiple cases" to gather "relevant information."



"Dr. Smith expressed opinions ... that were either contrary to, or not supported by, the evidence," Ms. Silver told the hearing Tuesday, reading from an agreed statement of facts.



"These failures compromised the administration of justice."



Mr. Smith blamed others for his mistakes, exaggerated his experience and offered opinions outside his expertise, the hearing was told.



Those opinions were "overly dogmatic" as well as "speculative," Ms Silver said. His evidence was "misleading" and he "acted as an advocate" rather than offering unbiased opinions.

Story continues below advertisement



Mr. Smith's lawyer, Jane Langford, told the panel the doctor would plead no contest and a statement of facts would be filed.



The panel accepted the facts and made a finding of professional misconduct and incompetence.



For more than a decade, Mr. Smith enjoyed a stellar reputation as the country's leading pathologist when it came to infant deaths. Several complaints about his work had little effect.



Still, his professional career began unravelling about eight years ago. In 2005, Ontario's chief coroner ordered a review of 44 autopsies Smith had conducted. Thirteen had resulted in criminal charges and convictions.



The review uncovered serious problems in half of those cases.



Mr. Smith voluntarily agreed to restrictions on his medical licence pending the outcome of the public inquiry led by Justice Stephen Goudge, who issued a damning 1,000-page report in October 2008.

Story continues below advertisement



During his testimony before the inquiry, Mr. Smith said his errors were not intentional.



He also apologized to William Mullins-Johnson, who spent 12 years in jail for the rape and murder of his four-year-old niece before being exonerated.



The Ontario government later paid Mr. Mullins-Johnson $4.25 million in compensation for his horrific ordeal.



"I'm still humiliated by the fact that I will never see justice done," Mr Mullins-Johnson wrote in his victim impact statement, which Ms. Silver read during Tuesday's hearing.



"He was allowed to continue his reign of terror even after complaints were registered."



In all, Ontario's top court has set aside five convictions based, in part, on Mr. Smith's testimony and another half-dozen appeals are pending.



Brenda Waudby, who was wrongly accused of murdering her two-year-old daughter, said Mr Smith showed no remorse.



"You took it upon yourself to destroy my life," Ms Waudby's statement read.



"The college could not punish you enough for what you have done."



Report an error
We have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We expect to have our new commenting system, powered by Talk from the Coral Project, running on our site by the end of April, 2018. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback@globeandmail.com. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters@globeandmail.com.