Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Human error behind highway deaths involving ducks: police

Emma Czornobaj is pictured at the Montreal Courthouse in Montreal, Tuesday, June 3, 2014.She is charged in the deaths of two people amid allegations she stopped her car on a highway to help some ducks.


Human error was behind the deaths of two people whose motorcycle slammed into the back of a car on a highway as the motorist was allegedly helping some ducks, a police investigator testified Monday.

Emma Czornobaj has pleaded not guilty to two counts each of criminal negligence causing death and dangerous driving causing the deaths of Andre Roy, 50, and his 16-year-old daughter, Jessie.

Witnesses have said the accused was tending to a family of ducks when the accident occurred on a westbound lane of Highway 30 near Candiac, a suburb south of Montreal.

Story continues below advertisement

A Quebec provincial police officer tasked with reconstructing the scene of the accident in June, 2010, told the accused's jury trial that Ms. Czornobaj's vehicle was parked in the left lane of a busy highway south of Montreal but that she wasn't in it.

"The collision was caused by a human factor," said Samuel Beaudet. "The driver of the Honda [Ms. Czornobaj] parked in the left lane on a limited access road and got out of her car.

"The driver of the Harley-Davidson [Mr. Roy] was surprised by the presence of the Honda in the left lane and was not able to come to a complete stop or take evasive action to avoid a collision."

Mr. Beaudet, the final Crown witness, said Mr. Roy was going between 113 and 129 kilometres an hour at the moment he applied his brakes. The investigator said Mr. Roy managed to slow down to between 105 and 121 km/h at the time of impact.

Mr. Roy and his daughter, who was riding on the back seat, were propelled from the motorbike. The girl was caught under the car, which itself was launched nearly 20 metres on impact.

Mr. Roy's wife, Pauline Volikakis, was on another motorcycle behind the victims, but was able to stop and avoid serious injury.

The rear window of the accused's car was shattered and Jessie Roy's helmet and sunglasses were found in the back seat of the vehicle. It was one of several dozen images Mr. Beaudet presented to the jury of 10 men and two women.

Story continues below advertisement

The investigator said the crash occurred on a section of highway where the maximum speed dropped to 90 km/h from 100 km/h.

Earlier on Monday, Mr. Beaudet said both victims were wearing helmets that did not meet safety standards. Later, he specified that a visual examination of the helmets suggested they did meet standards.

The investigator said the helmet issue did not contribute to their deaths.

Charges against Ms. Czornobaj, who is now 25, were laid more than a year after the deaths. While the maximum sentences are unlikely, criminal negligence causing death carries a maximum term of life imprisonment, while the charge of dangerous driving causing death comes with a maximum of 14 years in jail.

The defence is expected to begin its case once the final Crown witness wraps up on Tuesday.

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨