Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Judge lays some blame on top brass during sentencing of reservist

Cpl. Matthew Wilcox of Glace Bay, N.S., is followed by family members at his court martial in Sydney, N.S. on June 23, 2009. The reservist faces charges in the shooting death of another Canadian soldier in Afghanistan.


Officers in the Canadian military were partly to blame for lax firearms safety in Afghanistan, a military judge said as he sentenced a former reservist to four years in jail for fatally shooting a fellow soldier.

Lieutenant-Colonel Louis-Vincent d'Auteuil said on Friday that Matthew Wilcox was well trained and "should have known better" than to point a loaded pistol at his best friend, Corporal Kevin Megeney, on March 6, 2007.

However, Col. d'Auteuil also said senior officers at Kandahar Airfield hadn't done enough to crack down on improper handling of firearms before and during the deployment of Mr. Wilcox's unit.

Story continues below advertisement

"No discipline was imposed other than warning soldiers," the judge said, referring to incidents in which soldiers failed to unload the magazines from their pistols after leaving a shooting range on the base.

"All combined brought an atmosphere … where a human being forgot to unload his weapon, pointed and fired at somebody and killed somebody. He is responsible, but the Canadian Forces must be blamed for not having the proper leadership in the circumstances."

The judge convicted the Glace Bay, N.S., man earlier this week of criminal negligence causing death and negligent performance of a military duty in the death of Cpl. Megeney, a reservist from Stellarton, N.S.

It was Mr. Wilcox's second conviction. An earlier verdict was set aside last year after his lawyers argued the military jury wasn't properly balanced.

During sentencing on Friday, Col. d'Auteuil said he would subtract the 3½ months of jail time that Mr. Wilcox, 26, has already served in military and federal prisons.

"The incident was out of character in terms of what you did and who you are," Col. d'Auteuil told Mr. Wilcox.

The judge said he felt he had to apply the four-year sentence to Mr. Wilcox because it was the minimum penalty for the same offence in civilian law.

Story continues below advertisement

He also noted the Megeney family had suffered enormously from losing their loved one.

On Thursday, Cpl. Megeney's mother, Karen, told the court: "Here's your life, and then there's a hole and nothing can fill it."

The judge also said the minimum sentence was applicable because Mr. Wilcox's senior officers had let his unit down.

"Leaders, section leaders, the company commanders … created an atmosphere that let soldiers think if they forget to unload their weapons, it was not a big deal," he said.

The judge noted that during the trial, the court saw videos and photos of other soldiers pointing their pistols at one another, violating military safety rules.

The prosecution had argued that Mr. Wilcox was playing a game of "quick draw" when the shooting occurred.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Wilcox disputed that version of events, testifying during both trials that he fired his Browning pistol in self-defence when he noticed a gun pointed at his head as he unloaded gear inside the tent he shared with Cpl. Megeney.

Defence lawyer David Bright said he understood the judge's decision to impose a four-year sentence, but argued that under military law, it could have been less, or a suspended sentence.

"Having regard to all of the circumstances of the offence, the failure of the chain of command to support him and basically abandoning him, that the judge should look at that and lower the sentence," he said outside court.

Mr. Bright said his client has 30 days to decide whether to appeal.

Military prosecutor Anthony Tamburro said the Megeney family and the prosecution team were content with the sentence.

He said he's sure the military will take steps to avoid similar incidents.

"I think any time there's issues with weapons mishandling, there are concerns, and I'm sure the chain of command is taking steps to deal with that," said the prosecutor.

The prosecution argued for a six-year sentence while the defence wanted a one-year term.

Mr. Wilcox will begin serving his time at the Springhill Institution, a federal prison in central Nova Scotia.

Report an error
Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.