Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

MacKay says navy will get supply ships it needs, despite budget officer claims

Minister of Defence Peter MacKay responds to a question in the House of Commons in Ottawa on March 1, 2013. Mr. MacKay says the navy will get the supply ships it needs, despite a Parliamentary Budget Officer’s report that shows the government has not set aside enough cash to build them.

Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press

Defence Minister Peter MacKay says the navy will get the supply ships it needs, despite a Parliamentary Budget Officer's report that shows the government has not set aside enough cash to build them.

Mr. MacKay would not indicate whether he will ask the federal cabinet for more money.

In a report Thursday, budget watchdog Kevin Page said that if the government sticks to the $2.6-billion budget, it will have to strip out capabilities from the ship design, which has already been downgraded.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Page estimated that replacing the existing replenishment ships – HMCS Preserver and HMCS Protecteur – would cost about $3.2-billion, but that the budget should be set at $4.1-billion because the Canadian industry has no recent experience building similar vessels.

Federal officials have said the ship's design will undergo a costing review, perhaps this year.

Mr. MacKay said he would study the advice, but insisted new ships will either "match or surpass" the current vessels.

Public Works Minister Rona Ambrose this week defended the government's estimates, saying safeguards have been put in place to ensure the project is affordable.

Like Mr. MacKay on Friday, Ms. Ambrose underscored that the ships were still in the design phase.

Defence expert Dave Perry, of Carleton University and the Conference of Defence Associations, said the chances of the navy getting the ships it wants are "pretty low."

Based on government statements, the only option will be to reduce the vessels' capabilities, he said.

Story continues below advertisement

"They're not going to be able to get the same calibre of [resupply] ship," Mr. Perry said.

"Not only are you not getting the extra capability that was intended in 2004, '05, '06, you're going to be getting less capability than what was planned for in 2008."

The program to replace the existing replenishment ships, which refuel and restock warships at sea, was first proposed by the Chrétien government in 1994, but the Liberals did not order them until 10 years later.

The Harper government embraced the program, but shipyard proposals were deemed too expensive, among other things, in 2008, and the project was restarted the following year with a drastic scaling back of the capabilities the navy wanted.

The program is not expected to deliver replacement ships until 2018.

Internal Defence Department documents show the navy proposed a program budget of $2.9-billion, but it was scaled back to the current $2.6-billion, which the government has been called on to defend.

Story continues below advertisement

The budget officer's report said the higher cost is driven, in part, by the insistence that the ships be built entirely in Canada. That's something that runs contrary to the defence practices of many other nations, but Mr. MacKay said it's not something the government is willing to compromise on.

"There are lessons from the past we hope to learn from," he said after the signing of a defence agreement with Peru's Defence Minister.

"It is very much our intention that we get the right ship, the right build, the maximum benefits for Canadian industry and Canadian jobs. So there is mutual benefit here to the Canadian Forces and the Canadian economy."

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨