Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

McGill under fire after Andrew Potter resigns over Quebec column flap

Andrew Potter, the author of a controversial article on Quebec society that was published in Maclean’s magazine this week, has resigned his position as the director of the McGill Institute for the Study of Canada.

Hossein Taheri

Pressure is intensifying on McGill University to explain why a high-profile academic administrator stepped down after writing a controversial opinion piece, with the school releasing a statement on Thursday aiming to assure its community it upholds academic freedom.

Professors at McGill and elsewhere have said the university's handling of Andrew Potter's resignation as director of the McGill Institute for the Study of Canada is making them question that commitment.

Dr. Potter resigned on Wednesday as director, but will continue his three-year contract as a professor.

Story continues below advertisement

The former journalist stepped down after extensive criticism of an opinion piece he wrote in Maclean's magazine from politicians and commentators in Quebec.

Related: A week after Montreal's bungled blizzard, questions and blame linger

In the article, Dr. Potter argued the province was beset by low trust and alienation. He had apologized for the piece before resigning.

The controversy is the second issue to roil McGill this month.

Earlier in March, the university said it would bring forward a new hazing policy after it found that its varsity basketball team participated in a hazing ritual in 2015.

"I am not at all happy," said Desmond Morton, an eminent historian who was the founding director of the institute. "To accept somebody's resignation without further investigation is premature. It's a sad end to a promising candidate for the job."

McGill's statement said fears that academic freedom is threatened are unfounded.

Story continues below advertisement

"I want to assure members of the McGill community that academic freedom is a foundational principle of McGill University," principal Suzanne Fortier said in the statement.

At the same time, the statement said Dr. Potter "recognized that he had failed to uphold … [the institute's] mission and that the 'credibility of the Institute would be best served by his resignation.'" That mission, the statement explained, is partly to promote a better understanding of Canada and its heritage.

In response to questions, McGill said the office of Premier Philippe Couillard had not been in contact with the university. Mr. Couillard called Dr. Potter's commentary "an article of very poor quality" earlier this week.

Still, groups at McGill and nationally said they were concerned about why Dr. Potter resigned.

The McGill Association of University Teachers (MAUT), a faculty group to which about half of the school's professors belong, is asking the university if Dr. Potter decided to step down voluntarily.

"If you are fired for having an opinion, we will all have to think about how to frame our opinions," Terry Hébert, MAUT president, said. (Membership is voluntary, and Dr. Potter had not joined the group, Dr. Hébert added.)

Story continues below advertisement

The national academic organization representing professors said it too is asking questions.

"If there was external pressure for him to resign, McGill would have an obligation to protect his academic freedom," said David Robinson, the executive director of the Canadian Association of University Teachers (CAUT).

This was to have been an important week for Dr. Potter's academic career. McGill-Queen's University Press has just published a book he co-edited on electoral reform in Canada. The volume of scholarly essays was part of his transformation from a prominent journalist – he was editor-in-chief of The Ottawa Citizen for five years and is the author of two non-fiction books – into an established academic.

His hiring at McGill was announced last spring and he began the job less than a year ago.

"It would defy the imagination that this would be a resignation," said Emmett Macfarlane, an assistant professor of political science at the University of Waterloo.

"This is an abject failure on the part of the administration," he said.

Dr. Macfarlane blasted McGill over the situation in a Maclean's article this week.

Shortly after Dr. Potter's article was published and as public criticism was increasing, the school sent out a tweet distancing itself from the piece.

The "views expressed by @JAndrewPotter in the @Macleansmag article do not represent those of #McGill," the tweet said.

The school could have handled the controversy and Dr. Potter's article in other ways, some professors at McGill said.

Rather than accept Dr. Potter's resignation, the university should have examined the facts in his article, said Dr. Morton, now a history professor at McGill. While Dr. Potter's claims were "inadequately proven by the standards of social science," he said, he believes the controversy raises free-speech issues.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Authors
Postsecondary Education Reporter

Simona Chiose covers postsecondary education for The Globe and Mail. She was previously the paper’s Education Editor, coordinating coverage of all aspects of education, from kindergarten to college and university. She has a PhD in political science from the University of Toronto. More

Ingrid Peritz has been a Montreal-based correspondent for The Globe and Mail since 1998. Her reporting on the plight of Canadians suffering from the damaging effects of the drug thalidomide helped victims obtain federal compensation and earned The Globe and Mail a National Newspaper Award, Canadian Journalism Foundation award, and the Michener Award for public service. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨