Skip to main content

On Tuesday, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale, who oversees the Mounties, urged forces big and small to audit how they approach sexual-assault allegations.Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press

The nation's largest police force has not said if it plans to mount an audit of recent sexual-assault complaints, leaving it out of step with a growing legion of law-enforcement agencies launching wholesale case reviews in light of a Globe and Mail investigation.

The RCMP said on Wednesday it would look at how it handles future sex-assault allegations – even as all nine police departments in New Brunswick not run by the RCMP, and eight elsewhere, announced comprehensive probes.

The Ontario Provincial Police alone plans to pore over approximately 4,000 sexual-assault investigation reports that officers deemed unfounded between 2010 and 2014.

Read more: Unfounded: How police and politicians have responded to The Globe's investigation so far

Read more: Unfounded: Police dismiss 1 in 5 sexual assault claims as baseless, Globe investigation reveals

Read more: Will police believe you? Find your region's unfounded sex assault rate

On Tuesday, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale, who oversees the Mounties, urged forces big and small to audit how they approach sexual-assault allegations. The minister's request came in the wake of a Globe probe into the disproportionate number of sex-assault complaints being dismissed by investigators as unfounded. The investigation, and the call from Mr. Goodale, has so far triggered at least 24 reviews.

Meanwhile, in British Columbia, Premier Christy Clark said she was "heartened" by the finding that police in her province were more likely to believe sex-assault complainants and said the problem is more pressing elsewhere.

"I think Ontario is probably confronting a more urgent problem [than B.C.] – the numbers The Globe uncovered suggested it's much tougher in Ontario to find a police officer who believes you when you report a sexual assault," she said on Wednesday. "That doesn't mean we can't do better here so the Justice Ministry is looking at that now."

The RCMP's approach raises questions about equal access to justice in places such as New Brunswick, where complainants living in nine communities policed by municipal forces will have their allegations reviewed while those living in RCMP-policed jurisdictions will not.

Across 467 communities nationwide policed by RCMP detachments, the force had an unfounded rate of 17 per cent, slightly better than the national average of 19 per cent. But at least 77 of those jurisdictions posted unfounded rates topping 30 per cent.

In all, Globe data requests for 140 RCMP jurisdictions remain outstanding.

"The RCMP has worked and continues to work to ensure that its policies with respect to how it collects and assesses evidence, and its practices aligning with those policies, are robust and effective," RCMP spokesman Harold Pfleiderer said. "In light of recent reports, we are examining those policies and practices to ensure that they are consistently adopted and enforced across all of our jurisdictions."

In a statement on Wednesday, Mr. Goodale's office further clarified his position, saying RCMP policies and training procedures will be updated "if a gap is identified in how sexual assaults are investigated." In addition, the federal government wants RCMP officers to have better training on the proper way to enter data on sexual-assault cases in the force's records-management systems.

"Better data input will ensure we have better data to inform decision-making," Mr. Goodale's office said.

The RCMP announcement came a day after Mr. Goodale raised the issue directly with RCMP Commissioner Bob Paulson and called on police and prosecutors across Canada to "re-examine all of their approaches, all of their procedures, all of the ways that cases are managed, that investigations are conducted."

The minister was responding to a 20-month Globe investigation that drew on 250 freedom-of-information requests in revealing that, on average, one out of five sexual-assault complaints is dismissed as unfounded by Canadian police investigators.

Independent research from around the world suggests the actual rate of false reports lies somewhere between 2 per cent and 8 per cent.

The one-in-five figure hides jarring variations between jurisdictions. Sexual-assault complaints are categorized as unfounded 16 per cent of the time in Fredericton and 51 per cent of the time in Saint John, both in New Brunswick and both around the same size.

"I know police forces work really hard, but clearly across the country some are doing a better job than others," Ms. Clark told reporters. "Everybody needs to be striving to make sure women feel they are heard when they are hurt."

Paul Fiander, president of the New Brunswick Association of Chiefs of Police – who also heads the Miramichi police department – said they will be meeting next week to discuss the review, but that some forces, including his, have already begun.

"We started our review a couple of days ago based on the article and its findings, and all of the municipal police services in New Brunswick – I can't speak for the RCMP… all are carrying out a review of their files," he said.

In Miramichi, the review will focus on cases closed as unfounded beginning in 2010. Chief Brent Blackmore of the province's Woodstock department said he will be waiting to hear from the other chiefs before setting up a framework for the review so that it is consistent.

Beyond New Brunswick, eight more police services said they would either be starting an audit of unfounded cases – or had already completed one as a result of The Globe's inquiries. They include: South Simcoe Police; Woodstock (Ont.) Police Service; Delta Police Department; Truro Police Service; Hamilton Police Service; Service de police de la ville de Gatineau; Waterloo Regional Police Service; and LaSalle Police Service.

In Truro, N.S., the police chief vowed to get to the bottom of his force's 55-per-cent unfounded rate.

"I was surprised to see that our police service had such a high number of cases cleared as 'unfounded,'" Chief Dave MacNeil said in an e-mail, "and as a result of this, I wanted to know why."

With a report from Justine Hunter

The findings of a 20-month long investigation expose deep flaws in the way Canadian police forces handle sexual assault allegations. The Globe's Robyn Doolittle explains.

Follow Patrick White on Twitter: @Nut_GrafOpens in a new window
Follow Daniel Leblanc on Twitter: @danleblaOpens in a new window
Follow Robyn Doolittle on Twitter: @robyndoolittleOpens in a new window

Report an error

Editorial code of conduct

Your Globe

Build your personal news feed

Follow the authors of this article:

Check Following for new articles

Interact with The Globe