Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Uncivil servant: Woman wins case against flatulent, foul-mouthed, barefoot colleague

A public service board has granted an Ottawa bureaucrat the right to work in a different building from a loud and flatulent co-worker who swore, uttered odd noises and even washed his bare feet with vinegar in the office.

Line Emond, a data quality manager at the Parole Board of Canada, has been granted the right to a new workplace in a decision by the Public Service Labour Relations and Employment Board.

Emond filed a grievance claiming that the behaviour of her co-worker, identified only as Mr. X, made her ill.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. X arrived in Emond's office in the fall of 2009 and Emond took sick leave in August, 2011, and was on disability leave until March, 2013.

At one point, Mr. X filed a grievance against Emond, which was upheld in part.

Emond complained that her employer had failed to deal with her grievance properly.

Other workers testified about Mr. X's strange behaviour, including making "bizarre noises, such as strange yawns," walking around the office barefoot and washing his feet with vinegar in front of others "who found it disgusting."

A lawyer for the government said it appeared the dispute was a personality conflict, not a matter of illness and incapacity.

A doctor testified that Emond demonstrated a high anxiety level about the co-worker and felt threatened.

The arbitration ruling said there was a clear clash.

Story continues below advertisement

"Counsel maintained that the evidence is abundantly clear about Mr. X's abusive behaviour and his negative and harmful effect on the grievor," the ruling said.

"For example, all the witnesses described him as being physically imposing and behaving strangely, inappropriately, and abusively in the workplace."

Linda Gobeil, the arbitrator, ruled that Emond should be moved to another building and ordered that she be reimbursed for salary and benefits lost during her a portion of her time on long-term disability.

"I find it hard to believe that a cubicle could not be found in Ottawa in which the grievor could work," Gobeil wrote.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to